Headlines, North America

CANADA-CHILE: Ottawa Urged to Set Good Example in Trade Talks

Stephen Dale

OTTAWA, Jan 9 1996 (IPS) - Trade analysts are warning Canadian officials that upcoming bilateral negotiations with Chile should set proper standards for wider, regional talks.

Canada and Chile have moved a small step closer to hemispheric free trade, by announcing they will begin negotiations on their own bilateral trade agreement in mid-January.

Chile was set to become the fourth signatory to the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) alongside Canada, Mexico, and the United States, but U.S. President Clinton has hit a political roadblock in getting Congress to go along.

Canada’s international trade minister Roy McLaren has made it clear that the proposed Canadian-Chilean agreement is intended to move Chile further into the orbit of the North American trading partners, despite the lack of U.S. participation.

“Canada and Chile are both committed to the successful negotiation of Chile’s accession to the NAFTA,” McLaren said recently in a statement.

“But since these talks cannot currently proceed as quickly as we all would prefer, because the U.S. Administration and the Congress have not yet agreed on ‘fast track’ negotiating authority, we have decided to seek an interim bilateral agreement.

“This agreement will provide a bridge to full NAFTA accession for Chile and will be folded into the NAFTA once the accession negotiations are eventually completed.”

A Canadian trade department official told IPS that negotiations are at such an early stage that it is not possible to say what items will be “on the table” during the talks.

But analysts say the success of the trade talks will depend, not so much on the direct impact on the countries’ bilateral trade, but on the precedent set for broader negotiations in the future.

Michael Hart, director of the Centre for Trade Policy and Law at Carleton University here, told IPS that the multilateral General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT) and the World Trade Organisation (WTO) already address most of the two country’s bilateral trade concerns.

He added that with less than half a billion U.S. dollars in two- way trade between them, the countries’ economic relationship is “a very small cake. But it is a very nice cake, and this agreement might put some more icing on it.”

Hart believes that a new bilateral agreement will mostly benefit Chile, which wants to demonstrate that, after five years of democratic rule, the country has not been badly shaken by a period of economic and political turmoil.

“Partly what they want to do is to show that a democracy is in a better position to negotiate trade than a dictatorship,” the trade analyst said.

But Hart concedes that Canadian investors may be interested in a deal that loosens the conditions for investment in Chile. The cumulative total of Canadian investment in Chile is 2.5 billion U.S. dollars, concentrated mostly in the mining and telecommunications sectors.

The possibility Canada will push for liberalised investment criteria is hinted at in a Canadian document, which notes that “the Central Bank of Chile’s reserve requirement of 20 percent for one year for all foreign currency inflows continues to be a mild irritant for some investors, as is the stamp tax on investments of approximately 0.1 percent per month.”

Paul Mably of the non-governmental Oxfam-Canada adds that some Canadian companies want to expand into Chile’s fishing and forestry industries.

Mably says that Canadian forestry companies may be looking for countries with less environmental restrictions, since the forestry- dependent Canadian province of British Columbia implemented tough new laws limiting logging in old-growth forests.

Mably says the same kind of labour and environmental concerns raised in connection with Mexican border industries will also be a factor if Chile joins NAFTA.

“Labour standards, health and safety standards, and environmental standards aren’t as high in Chile as in Canada, and it’s obvious that Canadian executives who do business there are aware of that,” he told IPS.

Trade Minister McLaren points proudly to exports as the one bright light in the Canadian economy.

Canada’s exports, which grew by 18.4 per cent in the first 10 months of 1995, “for individual Canadians…is one of the most important sources of job creation,” McLaren told the Toronto Star newspaper.

But Bruce Campbell, executive director of the Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives, says the boom in exports is merely reflective of a restructuring of the Canadian economy under free trade, which benefits the rich.

The top 200 Canadian corporations account for 90 percent of export sales, he says, noting that Canada’s new competitiveness has only been accomplished through cutbacks in other areas.

“The growth in exports has come at a terrible price to the domestic economy,” Campbell told IPS. “The crucial indicators — jobs, social programmes, the prosperity of most citizens — shows we’re in a state of social and economic crisis. Exports alone can’t be the litmus test of the health of the Canadian economy.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags