Asia-Pacific, Economy & Trade, Global, Global Geopolitics, Headlines, Labour

LABOUR-ASIA: Countries Drag Their Feet on Migrants’ Rights

Johanna Son

MANILA, Dec 19 1997 (IPS) - Asian activists are leading a renewed campaign to get more countries to ratify a seven-year old United Nations convention for protecting migrants’ rights, saying the world continues to drag its feet on the touchy matter.

Proof of this lack of political will lies in the fact that seven years after the UN produced the convention, the agreement remains but a set of nice words on paper.

So far, only nine countries have ratified the 1990 Convention on the Protection of the Rights of All Migrant Workers and Members of their Families. Twenty ratifications are needed for it to enter into force.

“Perhaps the document is so thorough and so bold that so few nations have ratified it and there is little enthusiasm for it globally,” Anwar Fazal, head of the secretariat of a new network called Asian Partnership on International Migration (APIM), said with a note of irony.

Based in Kuala Lumpur, the group was formed recently among Asia- Pacific non-government organisations and experts to lobby governments to support the convention, and recognise that migrants’ rights do not disappear when they cross borders.

With the support of the U.N. and other international agencies, APIM launched on Dec 18 the first International Day of Solidarity with Migrant Workers and Members of their Families.

“We must continue to push for the ratification of the 1990 convention because there is no better convention, and no alternative,” Roger Bohning of the International Labour Organisation’s (ILO) South-east Asia office said at the launch.

Many countries, among them labour-receiving countries and developed nations, have shied away from the convention on migrant workers, wary of formally conferring rights on non-nationals and fearing the accord would somehow lead to permanent migration.

The nine countries that have ratified the convention, adopted on Dec 18, 1990, are Bosnia-Hercegovina, Cape Verde, Colombia, Egypt, Morocco, the Philippines, Seychelles, Sri Lanka and Uganda.

However, none of these nations are major labour-receiving countries. The Philippines and Sri Lanka are major labour exporters keen on greater protection for their workers.

The international community’s record on the protection of migrants’ rights pales beside its ready rhetoric when it comes to talk of supporting general human rights, and rights for groups like women and children, activists say. “When it comes to migrants, they are less enthusiastic,” said Cecille Motus of Philippine Migrants Rights Watch.

If past trends continue, “it could take seven more years before this convention enters into force — and it may not even have the labour-receiving countries in it,” remarked Fr Graziano Battistella, director of the Scalabrini Migration Centre here.

Bohning says it is regrettable that the supposed democratic countries in Europe, North America and Oceania “have not taken steps to ratify the convention”. This calls into question their commitment to human rights, he argued.

The convention puts together in one document all human rights applicable to migrants. A new primer on the convention says that among others, migrants have the right to life, liberty and property, to humane treatment and freedom of thought and religion, freedom to leave any country, to preserve their cultural identify and to be free from harm or torture.

Anwar says there is nothing really new added to migrants’ rights listed in the convention. The reason behind countries’ reluctance to back it is “basically just fear and ignorance”, he said in an interview.

Indeed, labour-receiving countries often value the economic contribution of overseas workers but turn wary when talk goes to basic services for them. As Battistela said, in many countries’ view they import “workers, not people”.

Experts say the fear of encouraging permanent and illegal migration is understandable. But far from regular and orderly migration, it is the growth of global syndicates trafficking people that is the real threat. The convention seeks to help improve management of the migration process, they add.

Bohning says migrant workers are vulnerable to abuse because the countries where they work are sovereign entities that can “draw a line between nationals and foreigners and treat migrants worse”. But he said “somewhere the arbitrariness of the state has to stop”, which is why global standards are badly needed.

Likewise, migrants, especially illegal ones, are often ignorant or defenseless in the host countries. “We have to strike a balance between the state’s rights and human rights,” Bohning added.

With the convention unenforceable, huge labour exporters like the Philippines, which has some 4 million overseas workers, has been resorting to bilateral labour agreements or putting up joint commissions with labour-receiving countries.

The Philippines has bilateral labour links with Jordan, Iraq, Qatar, Libya, Papua New Guinea, Micronesia, Marianas Islands and Liberia. It has joint labour commissions with the Gulf Cooperation Council and accords with Malaysia and South Korea.

It is also negotiating labour agreements with Taiwan, Bahrain, Lebanon, Kuwait, Saudi Arabia and Oman, Acting Philippine Foreign Secretary Leonides Caday reported.

“But some problems can’t be solved by a mere stroke of the pen,” Philippine Labour Secretary Leonardo Quisumbing said, adding that migrant workers continue to be threatened or abused, or deported without due process.

Despite the difficulty of getting the convention enforced, ILO director in Manila Richard Szal said: “Management of migration flows without human rights violations has to be guaranteed. But the UN can only do so much, and protective mechanisms should be high on the agenda of both sending and receiving countries.”

Meantime, Bohning says Asia’s currency and economic crises threaten to make things even harder for migrants, who are among the first to be booted out in difficult times. In the coming years, labour-exporting Asian countries will need to find ways to absorb returning workers, even as they cope with growing unemployment at home, he added.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags