Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Headlines, Population

SOUTH ASIA: Demographic Shift Can Be Turned into Gift

Birman Maharjan

NEW DELHI, Dec 8 1997 (IPS) - The population of South Asia will cross the 1.5 billion mark in the next 15 years. But rather than impeding economic growth, economists say, this provides the subcontinent with a demographic “gift” to finally break out of poverty in the next century.

By 2010, South Asia will be undergoing a demographic revolution — average fertility rates in countries like India, Bangladesh and Pakistan will continue to decline. The result: a sharp increase in the share of the population that is of working age.

“For each mouth that has to be fed in South Asia, there will be many more people working in the future than now. This demographic shift will provide an opportunity to boost growth of South Asian incomes,” predicts Vishwanath Desai, team leader of a new Asian Development Bank (ADB) study, ‘Emerging Asia, Changes and Challenges’.

Desai cautions, however, that this will not be automatic. “The additional workers need to be educated, and jobs have to be created before the economic potential of more working age people can be realised,” he says.

When their fertility rates declined in the past 30 years, East Asia’s economic tigers used the higher proportion of working age people in the population to spur development, and the ADB says this demographic shift explains one third of their rapid economic growth.

The ADB study was carried out before the recent currency turmoil and East Asia’s stock market crisis, but it concludes that the economic downturn does not diminish the achievements of countries like Thailand, Malaysia and Indonesia in lessening poverty.

For instance, in 1962 Thailand was at the same level of economic development as some South Asian countries with 57 percent of its population living below the poverty line. Today, that figure is down to five percent.

“Thailand was a model till a year ago. The crisis at the moment is a foreign currency crisis of convertibility, it does not detract from our development achievements. And now the IMF comes and tell us to get our policies right. Thailand has been getting it policies right for the past 30 years,” says Chalongphob Sussangkarn of the Thailand Development Research Institute.

Most economists agree. The East Asian meltdown which started with a cataclysmic fall of the Thai Baht in July and has now spread to South Korea and Japan was caused by economic reforms not being accompanied by prudent norms and financial supervision. Another factor was that a disproportionate share of financial capital inflows were in the form of short-term foreign exchange spot transactions.

South Korea, Thailand, Malaysia and Indonesia will now have to go through years of adjustment, and it may take another four years for their economies to stabilise again. But ADB’s Desai says: “The tone of our assessment of Asia’s future is one of qualified optimism. But despite the currency turmoil in Southeast and East Asia, we feel the optimism is still justified.”

ADB’s Emerging Asia study says there are plenty of lessons from all this for South Asia. The Bank brought together economists, academics and politicians from South Asia recently in New Delhi to discuss these lessons.

One of the architects of India’s economic reforms, Finance Minister P. Chidambaram told the gathering: “Just as the story of the Asian miracle was much hyped, that of the Asian debacle is much exaggerated. Lessons are quickly learnt in this part of the world. Countries in Asia which have lagged behind their more successful neighbours to the east, are now putting the lessons into practice, and the results are already beginning to show.”

So, what did Southeast and East Asia do that the subcontinent could emulate? The ADB study points to four main ones: An early commitment to basic health and education. “This is an important bedrock on which broad-based growth and quality of life improvement will rest,” says the Bank.

Support for agriculture and rural economic activity. This raises purchasing power and is a deterrent to uncontrolled urbanisation. Opening up the markets, open trade, unshackling the economy. “South Asian government must do more to promote openness and more liberal trade.” Private sector. Southeast and East Asia made the private sector the hub of development, South Asia could do the same.

Not everyone is convinced. They doubt if the “trickle down” of rapid growth in East Asia that led to a rise in the quality of life can be replicated in South Asia. And there are misgivings

about a reduction in the government’s role, when it is clear that it was the governments in East Asia that played a key role in policy and implementation.

“Even those who have accelerated IMF-prescribed reforms are in trouble, and they are turning to the IMF again for help. Is that what the IMF is for: to rescue countries when they get into trouble for following their own advice?” asks Shankar Sharma, senior adviser in Nepal’s Ministry of Finance.

And the private sector is also not the saviour it is touted to be. In Bangladesh and Pakistan, for instance, private borrowers are defaulting on billions of dollars worth of loans. “In fact,” says Akbar Ali Khan of Bangladesh’s Finance Division, “private banks are as bad as public banks. And we have seen the phenomenon where small borrowers without collateral pay back all their loans, whereas big and powerful borrowers default.”

ADB’s Emerging Asia study does not go into political stability and corruption as factors affecting economic growth. For various reasons, one of them being that many East Asian countries were dictatorships at a time when their economic strategies were being laid out, reform did not become mired in debate and these countries forged ahead.

Some countries, like South Korea, are seeing a backlash of the incestuous relationship between big business and government. But most South Asian countries have tried dictatorships, and it didn’t work either.

The ADB says politics is not within its mandate. But it says the recommendations in its report for replication of East Asian strategies in South Asia do not have to wait for stable governments.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags