Development & Aid, Headlines, Latin America & the Caribbean, Population

CARIBBEAN/U.S.: Illegal Immigrants Face Yet Another Deadline

Patrick Smikle

HOLLYWOOD, FLORIDA, Oct 20 1997 (IPS) - Caribbean people living illegally in the United States who, like millions of others are trying to legitimise their status, have lived this year through a series of dates and deadlines which they had no say in choosing.

There was the Apr. 1 deadline for the implementation of a new immigration law designed to prevent people from entering the U.S. illegally and to facilitate the easier deportation of those who evaded the increased border security.

There was the Sep. 27 deadline when, under the new law, persons still in the U.S. illegally would be barred for three years from returning. This move would take effect whether they left the country voluntarily or involuntarily.

Then there was the Sep. 30 deadline for the expiration of Section 245(i) of the Immigration and Nationality Act. Signed into law by President Bill Clinton in 1994, Section 245(i) allowed persons in the U.S. illegally, but who had a basis to legitimise their status to pay a fine of 1,000 dollars and remain in the country while their papers were being processed.

A relatively small number of the estimated five million people living illegally in the U.S. qualified. The categories were those who had already applied and had been approved for an immigrant visa, the spouses or minor children of U.S. citizens and the parents of U.S. citizens over 21.

As specialist immigration reporter, Marcus Stern, explains it, in a 1986 immigration amnesty, three million persons were legalised. These persons then applied for visas for their families but that process takes years.

In the meantime many of those family members have been living illegally in the U.S. Under the previous laws those illegal immigrants who remained in the U.S. more than seven years had a good chance of having their status legalised. Under the new law, if they are caught, their chances of avoiding deportation are much less.

It is for these people that Section 245(i) provided a ray of hope. Pro-immigration groups lauded the measure, saying it would prevent families from being split up and appealed for it to become a permanent feature of U.S. immigration law. At the same time they lamented the 1,000-dollar fee, saying most families could not afford it.

Anti-immigration groups declared it to be a watering down of U.S. immigration law which, according to them, rewarded illegal immigrants.

And the Immigration and Naturalisation Service (INS), while not taking any public position on the issue, privately supported it. After all, say some admittedly cynical observers, the penalty fee added some 200 million dollars a year to the INS coffers, which was used to build additional detention centres and build up the agency’s security apparatus.

It was a temporary measure of which nearly 500,000 illegal aliens took advantage. However, for a variety of reasons –including the difficulty of finding the fee — another one million who could have qualified, were still struggling to meet the deadline as Sep 30 approached.

Once again there was panic in the immigrant communities across the country as the House of Representatives kept the country guessing as to whether it would extend the measure. The Senate had already voted unanimously for an extension.

“Here is the dilemma people face,” explains Cheryl Little of the Florida based, Immigrant Advocacy Centre. “…If 245(i) is not extended, these people will either have to leave the United States while their papers are being processed, or remain here illegally and risk being picked up and put in deportation proceedings.

“Some of them have been here for years. Many have children who were born in this country and know no other home. Families will be split apart. But if they leave, they risk being barred from re- entering for three to 10 years.”

As Little spoke to IPS word came that the House of Representatives had voted to extend 245(i), but only to Oct 23. The Congressional vote changed the situation “but only slightly,” specialist immigration attorney, Michael Shane told IPS.

“It’s a very very small number of people who are eligible.” But to some immigration attorneys, pro-immigration activists, and pro-immigration legislators who favour 245(i) being made a permanent feature of the immigration laws, the brief extension offer hope.

But the extension of 245(i) has only eased, not relieved, the concerns of the immigrant community and the debate over whether to go home or to stay rages.

One line of argument is that the economic situation in most Caribbean countries is desperate and people have nothing to go home to. They should therefore remain in the U.S. and work for as long as they can get away with it. The counter argument is that people who are “out of status” should leave voluntarily rather than risk the humiliation of being caught and deported.

Much would depend on how people assess this risk. That assessment, as well as the sustained panic, is affected by rumours and reports. Many of these obviously have no basis. Some seem credible.

One report says the INS has strengthened the resources of its border patrol section, presumably to embark on a drive to round up illegal immigrants.

Shane, at times a severe critic of the INS, says he does not believe the Service has any such intention. But other IPS sources attach some credibility to this report. They tell of many new vehicles having been acquired. When reminded of Clinton’s promise in Costa Rica last April, that there would be no mass deportations, they point out that this promise was made at the same time that people returning from carnival in Jamaica, including legal aliens or green card holders were being denied re-entry to the U.S.

One of the features of the current situation is confusion and disorganisation. And it worsens as another deadline approaches.

Immigration lawyers admit that they are unclear about several provisions of the new laws. “Congress went ahead and drafted all of this stuff without thinking clearly about who it’s gonna affect and how it’s gonna affect people and how its gonna work,” says Jamaican born immigration attorney, Sherna Spencer. “It is confusing.”

With some applicants trying to save money by preparing and filing the various forms themselves, the confusion is taking its toll on the immigrant community.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags