Friday, November 20, 2026
Danielle Knight
- The Cassini Space Craft, roared into space Wednesday over the protests of critics who say its plutonium fuel load poses a hazard for people on Earth.
Critics, who include some NASA employees, call the mission risky – they have dubbed it Casino Cassini – and contend that an accident could do everything from lower property values to ban future agricultural land uses to kill thousands of people.
“Accidents do happen, humans and machines are not perfect – a collision with the earth while the spacecraft flies past on its way to Saturn presents a risk of widespread plutonium distribution around the world,” warns physicist Michio Kaku.
The Cassini Space Craft is carrying more than 36 kilogrammes of plutonium – the most toxic substance known to scientists. The 3.4 billion dollar mission is the last in a series of costly projects by the National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA).
Named after the 17th century Italian astronomer Cassini who discovered the gaps in Saturn’s rings, the space craft is scheduled to cruise toward Venus, then back past Earth in 1999, before heading off to reach its final destination, Saturn – a total journey time of seven years.
Pointing out that the Cassini mission “could teach us a great deal about outer space,” NASA argues that there is less than a one-in-a-million chance that an accident could occur when the craft flies by Earth.
“In the next year, the Earth is in greater danger of being hit by a comet or asteroid than of a Cassini mishap,” says NASA while admitting that problems could occur. The Titan IV rocket, which successfully launched Cassini Wednesday has a historical failure rate of 1 in 20 but NASA insists the chances are low of any plutonium dioxide being released by Cassini – even assuming that it blew up.
“NASA is extremely conservative,” said Bruce Gagnon, state coordinator for the Florida Coalition for Peace and Justice, which unsuccessfully filed a lawsuit last week to halt Cassini. “They create the numbers they want. That’s enough plutonium for every person on earth to be affected.”
Cassini critics point out that three out of the 26 earlier U.S. nuclear space missions have involved mishaps. One of the worst, according to journalist Karl Grossman, was a 1964 satellite with a plutonium system aboard fell to earth, disintegrating and dispersing about 1 kilogram of plutonium.
John Gofman, professor of medical physics at the University of California linked that accident to the rise in lung cancer on earth.
Grossman also points to the Russian probe that crashed to Earth along the Bolivia/Chile border in November 1996. “U.S. officials still admit that they don’t have a clue what happened to the plutonium it carried,” he says.
Otto Raabe, president of the Health Physics Society, a group of 6,500 professionals in radiation safety, says that even a worst- case Cassini catastrophe would cause no significant risk. He said there is a big difference between plutonium-238, which will be used on Cassini, and the plutonium used in nuclear reactors.
Raabe says if Cassini were to burn up on impact during a “fly- by” the dose would be less than the cosmic rays a passenger would receive during a commercial airline flight. Kaku says such optimism was “speculation masquerading as the laws of physics” and maintains that, depending on wind conditions, hundreds of thousands of people could die in a fly-by mishap.
Since the Florida Coalition for Peace and Justice began its anti- Cassini campaign three year ago, the movement against nuclear power in space has become a national movement. A last minute leagl challenge by environmentalists filed in Hawaii failed to halt the mission. A federal judge in Honolulu said the risks cited by Green lobbyists were outweighed by the disadvantages of delaying the biggest and most expensive interplanetary exploration project ever mounted.
Even though protests did not stop the launch, Cassini critics say they will keep up the pressure to halt the earth “fly-by.”
“We will continue to alert the public about future health and environmental hazards that this and other plutonium powered missions pose worldwide,” Carol Mosley of the Florida Coalition told IPS. “I find the space program very exciting but, nuclear- powered missions are insane, eventually you are going to have an accident.”
Opponents of nuclear powered space probes say they could be powered by solar energy instead of nuclear energy.
“Cassini, and other large plutonium powered crafts, should be made into smaller, more frequent solar powered missions,” says Kaku. “The idea that Cassini has to be large is an idea left over from the Cold War when the U.S. was competing with Russia to have the largest space missions.”
NASA, however, has insisted on sticking with atomic power on Cassini and other planned space missions. It says solar panels would be impractical a billion kilometers from the Sun.
NASA, says Grossman, will not stray from nuclear fuel because it is under pressure from Lockheed Martin, the company that manufactures plutonium systems and the U.S. Department of Energy.
“NASA also seeks to stay in coordination with the U.S. military which wants to deploy nuclear-powered weaponry in space,” adds Grossman.