Development & Aid, Global, Global Geopolitics, Headlines, Population

UNITED NATIONS: Peacekeepers’ Planning Chief Defends Unit Records

Ramesh Jaura

BONN, Oct 14 1997 (IPS) - The United Nations has carried out 43 peacekeeping operations since its inception 52 years ago and all of them have — “as a matter of rule” — been successful, says U.N. assistant secretary-general Manfred Eisele.

Eisele, a lieutenant general in the German army, has been in charge of planning and support at the U.N. department of peacekeeping operations since 1994. He is to quit the post at end 1997 after unspecified “policy differences” with German defence minister Volker Ruehe.

At a ‘meet-the-press’ session arranged by the Bonn office of the United Nations Information Centre (UNIC) Tuesday, Eisele strongly defended the U.N. peacekeeping record in general.

He also singled out two operations that have been particularly criticised internationally — the U.N. operations in Somalia and Bosnia-Hercegovina — which he said had been “complete successes” as humanitarian missions.

According to a U.N. briefing paper provided by Bonn UNIC, the second U.N. operation in Somalia (UNOSOM II) was ordered to assist “the Somali people in rebuilding their economy and social and political life, re-establishing the country’s institutional structure, achieving national political reconciliation, recreating a Somali State based on democratic governance.”

But UNOSOM II, which operated between March 1993 and March 1995 followed in the bootsteps of the U.S. led Unified Task Force in the country.

The U.S. led Task Force had been authorised by the U.N. Security Council in December 1992 to use “all necessary means” to establish a secure environment for humanitarian relief operations in Somalia. In this it failed, despite the relative success of the first U.N. mission in Somalia (UNOSOM I) between April 1992 and March 1993.

UNOSOM I was primarily humanitarian. Briefed to monitor the ceasefire in the capital Mogadishu and provide security for U.N. personnel, equipment and supplies at the seaports and airports, the UNOSOM I teams escorted aid deliveries from there to distribution centres in the city and later across the country.

UNOSOM II’s brief was more political. It was required to complete, according to the U.N. documentation, through disarmament and reconciliation, “the restoration of peace, stability, law and order”.

This, as observers have noted since, was intensely difficult in a situation left fragile by the policy failures of the U.S. led force and its disastrous failure to defeat Somali militia leader Mohammed Farah Aideed.

Eisele suggested that the mission had failed in its efforts to replace “a Somalia specific socio-political structure by a western style structure”.

He also singled out the humanitarian successes of the United Nations Protection Force (UNPROFOR) in the former Yugoslavia.

During the time it was deployed in the Balkans, the force was widely criticised by some western factions, which accused UNPROFOR of concentrating on feeding the victims while allegedly allowing the warmongers to run riot.

Operating in Bosnia-Hercegovina, Croatia, Serbia, Montenegro and the former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia between Feb. 1992 and March 1995, it was eventually replaced by a NATO-led force that had both a clearer political objective and the means to achieve it by force if necessary.

In contrast to the heavy forces deployed in the former Yugoslavia, Eisele also cited the United Nations Verification Mission in Guatemala (MINUGUA). Its 190 unarmed military observers – earlier this year helped demobilise rebel forces, and paved the way to a peaceful settlement.

The German press has reported that both U.N. secretary-general Kofi Annan and German foreign minister Klaus Kinkel would like him to stay on in his post, despite his reported differences with Ruehe.

Eisele declined to comment on the dispute, saying only that he said he was on attachment to the U.N. from the German defence ministry and a decision in regard to his term in office would be taken by Ruehe as minister in charge.

In his address to the media, both the scale and the sacrifice of the U.N. peacekeepers was detailed.

Some 800,000 U.N. military and civilian police personnel have been deployed in peacekeeping operations since they began in 1948 at the behest of the five permanent nations on the Security Council and their ten rotating members.

Some 1,600 U.N. troops had died since 1948. The number of U.N. interventions has greatly increased in the last ten years; thirty peace-keeping operations were ordered by the Security Council in the years between 1988 and 1997.

There are currently 17 still under way, involving some 23,000 peacekeepers, the so-called ‘blue helmets’. As of April 1997, 71 countries were contributing military and civilian police personnel to these operations.

The total cost of operations between 1948 and Dec. 31, 1995 was estimated at about 16 billion dollars. The estimated annualised cost of operations in 1996 was about 1.4 billion dollars and in the current year nearly 1.3 billion dollars.

Eisele said the costs of peacekeeping — which he said should not be confused with peace enforcement and other forms of military intervention — were tiny compared to the costs of conflict and its toll in lives and property.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags