Development & Aid, Environment, Headlines, Health, North America

ENVIRONMENT-HEALTH: Environmental Link with Cancer

Danielle Knight

WASHINGTON, Oct 1 1997 (IPS) - Health organisations, scientists and environmental activists are pushing forward with a campaign to call attention to the link between toxic pollution and breast cancer in women.

“The knowledge of industrial pollution’s link to breast cancer is there,” says Liane Clorfene-Casten, a Chicago-based community activist. “It is positively frightening how the link is so under- reported and how women are so uninformed.”

At public hearings and conferences over the past three years in cities including New Orleans, Minneapolis, New Jersey and San Francisco, activist groups have been blaming corporations for polluting the environment with chemicals believed to cause breast cancer. The next public hearing scheduled for mid-October will take place in Philadelphia.

An estimated one million women worldwide die each year from breast cancer, and the incidence of the disease has been rising rapidly, says the New York-based Women’s Environment and Development Organisation, a co-sponsor of the hearings.

“Cancer is reaching epidemic proportions and we need to identify the links between the public health crisis and the environment,” Priscilla Rosenwald of the Pennsylvania Women’s Health and Environment Network told IPS.

Devra Lee Davis, former medical researcher with the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, says the growing evidence from hundreds of articles on experiments on animals and the growing literature on humans all point to industrial pollution being a cause of breast cancer.

Concerned organizations have stepped up their attacks on industrial chemicals and other toxins, instead of focusing on medical approaches to fighting breast cancer which, in recent years, have emphasized genetics and life style.

Most women carry around a major misconception about breast cancer – that it is somehow their “fault” that they have or might get the disease, said Clofene-Casten. “We are told that it is because of something we did – like over-eating or having children late in life or that we have a family history of cancer – but the main cause of the disease is toxins in the environment,” she said.

In her book, ‘Breast Cancer: Poison, Profits and Prevention,’ Clofene-Casten says that it is likely that more than 70 percent of breast cancer cases are caused by industrial chemical companies such as Monsanto, Imperial Chemical Industries and Dow. Interestingly, these same companies produce the drugs that treat cancer.

“Corporations must be held accountable and heavily penalized for causing this deathly epidemic,” Clofene-Casten told IPS. Corporations say that the environmental link to cancer has not been proven.

Since the dawn of the chemical age – and the increase of cancer- causing and hormone manipulating chemicals in the air, water and soil – breast cancer has steadily risen, activist organisations maintain. They point to industrial pollution and pesticides containing common chlorine-based organochlorines as the main culprit.

Organochlorines, such as lindane and DDT, are chemicals which “mimic” or “block” estrogen and progesterone – natural hormones which instruct the body on how it should develop. These hormone-mimicking chemicals, when taken into the body through our food, water, and air, can trigger unnatural cell growth that can progress to cancer.

Dioxin, a type of organochlorine, is the unwanted by-product of such industrial processes as paper bleaching and waste incineration. “We don’t set out to ingest these chemicals but we cannot escape them in our modern world,” says Clofene-Casten.

The Environmental Protection Agency found that U.S. counties with hazardous waste sites were 6.5 times more likely to have elevated breast cancer rates than counties that did not have such sites.

Other groups have provided evidence from different perspectives. Greenpeace, for example, in a 1992 report notes several occupations that contribute to the breast cancer epidemic.

“Women working in the petroleum, chemical, pharmaceutical, and electrical equipment manufacturing industries had significantly higher rates of breast cancer than the general public,” says the report.

A 1997 World Health Organisation report predicts that the number of cancer deaths throughout the world will double in most countries over the next 25 years. Breast cancer is listed as one of the top killers and, while breast cancer rates are rapidly rising in developing countries, activists point out that rates are higher in industrialised countries.

Japan provides interesting proof of the link between industrial pollution and breast cancer. Until very recently the incidence of breast cancer was the lowest in the world, approximately 4.8 percent, according to WEDO.

During the past two to three years, however, this rate has risen to 5.4 percent. Furthermore, Japanese women moving to North America reached U.S. national levels within one generation.

Israel is another interesting example. A dramatic 30 percent drop in breast cancer rates was witnessed after Israel banned three cancer-causing pesticides, according to an official Israeli study.

At the World Conference of Breast Cancer held last July in Canada, Bella Abzug, the director of WEDO and a former New York Congresswoman, said a global action plan on breast cancer will be presented to the United Nations before the end of the year.

“While it has taken governments decades to begin to respond to the link between smoking and cancer, women cannot wait several more decades for the appropriate bodies to take substantial and committed action on breast cancer,” she said.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags