Friday, November 20, 2026
Danielle Knight
- Crops being produced through certain methods of biological-engineering threaten the future of sustainable farming, says an international coalition of environmental and farming organisations.
“Chemical corporations that are commercialising Bt plants are waging an undeclared war against sustainable farming practices,” says Benedikt Haelin of Greenpeace International here.
“Bt” is Bacillus thuringiensis, a microorganism that produces a toxin that environmentalists say could lead to the development of Bt resistance in major pests within 2 to 10 years.
“The use of biologically-engineered Bt crops will have disastrous affects on worldwide efforts to enablke farming to be carried out without risks to human health or the environment,” Linda Bullard International Forum of Organic Agriculture Movements (IFOAM) based in Germany told IPS.
Chemical and agricultural corporations, such as Monsanto and Pioneer, both based in the United States, have already begun commercialisation of Bt crops – mainly corn although the process can be applied to almost any crop.
“These crops have been approved by various U.S. government agencies so we feel confident that they are safe technology,” Dan Holman of Monsanto told IPS.
Tim Martin, a spokesman for Pioneer add that “We are sure that Bt crops are safe and will improve grain supply.”
Biologically-engineered Bt crops cover more than three million acres of U.S. farmlands and, while they yet must be approved in countries such as Brazil and Argentina, corporations are planning to market them widely in developing countries.
Since the 1960s, Bt bacteria, as it naturally occurs, has been an essential element in organic farming and in the international effort to reduce the environmental and human health impact stemming from the use of chemical pesticides, say environmentalists.
Bt sprays leave no poisonous residue on crops or trees and it is quickly degraded into the environment. The Bt bacteria is deemed a perfect pesticide because it can specifically target certain pests without having detrimental effects on mammals, birds or non-target insect species and microorganisms, say environmentalists.
Biologically-engineered Bt crops, on the other hand, will have a negative impact on organisms that are not pests, says the International Center for Technology Assessment (CTA), a non- governmental organization (NGO) based here. “This could have disastrous effects on human health and the functioning of healthy ecosystems,” said Andrew Kimbrell of CTA.
The essential difference between Bt spray and Bt crops is that the Bt in the spray breaks down in sunlight after a few days. The Bt engineered into the plants, does not break down when exposed to UV rays and is also a more intense toxin, says scientist Sally Fox, a Bt specialist.
“Bt crops express the toxin in continuously high doses over a long period of time and thereby exert a natural selection pressure unlike the short term impact of Bt sprays,” she says.
A small percentage of any population of organisms will be resistant to a toxin because of naturally occurring genetic differences in individual organisms. Eventually the surviving individuals breed and the entire population becomes resistant to the toxin.
Therefore, widespread use of so-called ‘transgenic’ Bt plants could permanently destroy the Bt spray’s effectiveness among the world’s primary agricultural pests, say critics. This would be a devastating blow to sustainable agriculture, especially organic farmers, says Greenpeace.
“Bt is by far the most important material to organic potato farmers,” Jim Gerritesen, a farmer from Maine told IPS. “If the potato bugs become resistant to Bt I don’t know what organic farmers like me will do.”
While the corporations marketing Bt crops say they are confident that U.S. government regulatory agencies are protecting farmers and the environment, critics of Bt crops have filed a lawsuit against the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) for approving Bt crops.
The coalition of Bt critics, including Greenpeace, IFOAM, CTA, Sierra Club, say that EPA has failed to address the potentially devastating environmental impacts of these genetically engineered plants by approving Bt crops.
In early 1995 the EPA began the limited registration of Bt crops for farming and, more than 20 have now been approved or awaiting approval world-wide. Opponents are demanding the EPA to cancel the registrations of all Bt plants and refrain from approving any new Bt crops. The coalition is also asking the agency to complete a impact statement analyzing the effect of the Bt crops.
“The EPA has put the interests of a few corporations ahead of its mandate to protect the environment and the public,” said Joseph Mendelson of CTA. “In doing so they have violated several federal laws and their own regulations.”
The EPA says it will look at these demands. “We take these claims very seriously,” Al Heier of the EPA told IPS. “But at the same time we believe that we have done a thorough job examining the impact Bt crops will have on pest resistance.”