Asia-Pacific, Economy & Trade, Global Governance, Headlines, IPS UN: Inside the Glasshouse, Labour

US-LABOUR: Unions Want Tough Action Against Burma

Abid Aslam

WASHINGTON, Aug 12 1997 (IPS) - The leaders of 11 U.S. trade unions have called on President Bill Clinton to “vigorously defend” a Massachusetts law that bars the state from making purchases from companies doing business in Burma.

The law has drawn fire from the European Union and Japan, who have complained to the World Trade Organisation (WTO) that it violates U.S. obligations under international trade rules. In addition to Massachusetts, 11 local governments have passed similar ‘selective purchasing’ laws, according to labour sources. Most recently, New York City passed such legislation on May 30.

In a letter to U.S. Trade Representative Charlene Barshefsky, the union chiefs urge the Clinton administration to “remain resolute in protecting the right of state, county and municipal governments in the United States to make such purchasing decisions.”

Barshefsky currently is negotiating with the EU and Japan in hopes of “working out something” before a WTO dispute resolution panel is formed to settle the case, a USTR spokeswoman told IPS. A panel could be named in October if the parties fail to reach agreement next month.

When the EU and Japan first made their objections in January, the U.S. State Department tried to persuade Massachusetts to repeal its prohibition – the first of its kind in the country. But state officials, led by then-Republican Governor William Weld, refused and asserted the state’s right to control its own procurement practices. (Weld left office earlier this year, to campaign hard as Clinton’s nominee for the post of U.S. ambassador to Mexico.)

Since then, Washington has adopted a more supportive stance. Clinton, citing concern over the human rights situation and officially sanctioned drug smuggling in Burma, issued an executive order barring any new U.S. investments in the military-ruled South East Asian nation.

The case, however, has fueled an anti-WTO backlash in the United States with critics from both the political left and right arguing that the global agency posed a threat to U.S. sovereignty and constitutional principles – including states’ rights.

“If the people of Massachusetts don’t want their tax dollars spent on buying products from companies complicit in torture and repression, that’s their right,” says Kenneth Zinn, North America coordinator of the International Federation of Chemical, Energy, Mine and General Workers’ Unions (ICEM). “The WTO has no right to tell (these taxpayers) from whom they should, and shouldn’t, buy.”

The European Union, while condemning human rights abuses in Burma, opposes the Massachusetts law on the grounds that it violates a 1994 agreement barring national and local governments from using political considerations in making procurement decisions.

By pressing its case against the state law, the EU risks “contravening the spirit of its own sanctions” against the Rangoon regime, Zinn argues. He dismisses complaints of discrimination against foreign firms, noting that the Massachusetts ban applies to all companies dealing with Burma, regardless of where they are based.

Such corporations “have provided support and sustenance to the dictatorship (in Burma) and because of this, Nobel peace laureate Aung San Suu Kyi and the Burmese opposition National League for Democracy have asked that foreign companies disinvest from Burma,” say the labour leaders, most of whose unions are affiliated to the ICEM. The federation says its affiliates in 113 countries represent some 20 million workers.

In their letter, the union presidents highlight a number of oil companies they say “continue to prop up the military regime (in Rangoon) by providing it with large amounts of desperately needed hard currency.” These include the U.S.-based Unocal, Atlantic Richfield Company (ARCO) and Texaco, and France’s Total. The companies have disputed this characterisation of their role.

Coupled with other forms of grassroots economic activism, state and local selective-purchasing laws played an important role in the anti-apartheid campaign of the 1980s by forcing foreign and domestic companies to choose between doing business with South Africa or with public agencies in the United States, analysts say.

Activists are banking on a similar effect in Burma although analysts are divided over the results so far. All but a handful of U.S. companies continue to invest in Burma – taking advantage of a clause in Clinton’s April ban that permits them to maintain pre- existing investments, labour and human rights. At the same time, however, the United States has become the market for nearly two-thirds of Burma’s garment exports, according to the National Labour Committee, a New York-based labour rights group.

While some economists here and in Asia have questioned the impact of U.S. sanctions on the Burmese junta, others say the sanctions must be working because they have drawn stiff opposition from a number of this country’s trading partners and also from large companies.

The companies have assembled under two main umbrellas, the National Foreign Trade Council (NFTC), an association whose members claim to account for around 60 percent of U.S. non- agricultural exports and private investments overseas, and USA Engage, a new coalition of some 440 businesses, agriculture groups, and trade associations.

The organisations were formed primarily to oppose unilateral federal sanctions – and, in the case of NFTC, to lobby for federal export-promotion programmes and services. But they have participated in recent meetings with U.S. legislators and European diplomats seeking new alliances and strategies in the fight against unilateral and extra-territorial sanctions of all sorts, ranging from the federal anti-Cuba Helms-Burton law, to the Massachusetts selective-purchasing law.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags