Friday, November 20, 2026
Abid Aslam
- ‘Case by case’; The desires of arms manufacturers and the fears of arms control advocates are understood to hang on those three words following the Bill Clinton administration’s latest move on advanced weapons transfers to Latin America.
The White House is softening a long-standing U.S. practice, known as the “presumption of denial”, under which Washington would generally refuse to authorise sales of jet fighters and other advanced weapons to Latin American countries. From now on, Washington will review each application on its own merit and issue rejections only in exceptional circumstances.
The change has been welcomed by the U.S. arms industry but denounced by arms control advocates. Analysts warned, however, that the former’s celebration of new business opportunities and the latter’s consternation about a possible regional arms race are premature.
Even some senior government analysts want to play down the significance of the administration’s announcement, made Friday. “It’s always been case-by-case,” one national defence specialist told IPS on condition of anonymity. “(The arms) industry has said it amounted to an unwritten bias against them. At a minimum, they wanted an overt statement of non-bias. That’s all they got.”
Nevertheless, the move is a “bad symbol (which) threatens to divert resources from social and economic investments” in the region by boosting military spending, said Bill Spencer, deputy director of the Washington Office on Latin America, a policy think tank. “The real test will be what (U.S. authorities) do on a case- by-case basis,” he added.
Congressional and administration sources doubt a Latin American arms race will ensue. With the exception of Peru and Ecuador, which have gone to war with one another and are stockpiling weapons in anticipation of future conflict, the region’s countries have what one U.S. analyst here described as “rivalry, not conflict, and machismo, not hatred.”
As another official put it, “Ecuador and Peru need not apply.”
Officials at the World Bank, Inter-American Development Bank (IDB) and International Monetary Fund (IMF), usually circumspect about such matters, are withholding judgement for now. The agencies have counseled Latin American and other developing countries to rein in state spending – especially military spending – and give higher priority to social investments.
Privately, however, some officials conceded that countries would risk the agencies’ ire if they sought to increase military spending. In particular, significant upswings in weapons procurement would throw off public-spending deals struck with the IMF, and possibly jeopardise loan programmes.
The prospect of poor relations with the IMF, coupled with pro- arms control sentiments among key members of Congress, will suffice to keep the lid on the Latin American arms market, U.S. officials argued.
Their assertions are of little comfort to Spencer, who noted that the IMF has continued to support Peru’s programme to reduce its external commercial debt and debt-service obligations, even as the country has acquired some 300 million dollars’ worth of MiG fighters. The IMF in February released 223 million dollars for the debt reduction effort under a facility approved in July 1996. Lima took delivery of the first MiGs last November.
Friday’s announcement followed a two-year review by senior officials – and intense pressure from the arms industry. It could clear the way for Chile, and then Brazil, to buy U.S. military aircraft. Deals in the pipeline include possible purchases of F-16 jet fighters made by Lockheed Martin and F/A-18s made by McDonnell- Douglas.
The Chile deal alone could be worth about one billion dollars to U.S. companies, said William Hartung, senior fellow at the World Policy Institute of New York’s New School for Social Research. Although each F-16 is priced at roughly 20 million dollars, the sale would be worth between one-and-a-half and two times as much in contracts for technical support and spare parts, he added.
Washington’s current stance “announces to other possible suppliers that we’re in the game,” said Tom Cardamone, arms trade analyst at the Council for a Livable World Education Fund, a non- governmental organisation (NGO). In particular, it sends a signal to France, Sweden and Russia that “the United States fully intends to participate in all future competitions for attack jets and other high-technology items,” he added.
The F-16 and F/A-18 are competing against France’s Mirage-2000, Sweden’s JAS-39 Gripen, and Russia’s MiG-29 for business from Chile, which is expected to buy at least two dozen aircraft early next year, according to industry analysts.
The American jets entered the trade fray in March, when Clinton agreed to provide technical data on them to Chilean defence officials. The latest White House announcement will enable Washington to pass on more highly classified information about the aircraft.
Corporate spokespersons have complained that domestic demand for the U.S. arms industry’s products has fallen since the end of the Cold War. As a consequence, competition to sell weapons in the developing world has intensified.
Although the United States remains the world’s largest supplier of arms, U.S. companies have taken a beating in many Third World markets. By 1995, Russia had emerged as the leader in signing up new sales orders from developing countries, scooping up 9.1 billion dollars’ worth of new business, or 31.6 percent of the world total, the Congressional Research Service (CRS) reported last year.
The origins of the “presumption of denial” lie in U.S. legislation passed in the late 1960s, according to government researchers. When that legislation lapsed, the practice was retained by then-President Richard Nixon and reasserted by Jimmy Carter – ostensibly to stop a regional arms race and keep advanced weapons systems out of the hands of military regimes. Under Ronald Reagan, who invoked concerns over Cuba, the United States in 1981 authorised the sale of a dozen F-16 fighters to Venezuela.
The new practice would place Latin America on an equal footing with other parts of the world under Clinton’s 1995 presidential directive on conventional arms policy, which sets the ground rules for arms transfers, administration officials said. The move acknowledges progress made in constructing democracies where once military juntas had reigned supreme.
Such progress may have occurred, said Spencer, but Peru is still able to spend on defence without congressional approval, and Chile’s armed forces – which by some estimates spend twice the regional average on weapons – continue to benefit from profits set aside by state-owned mining operations. Since these are technically business profits, they do not appear in the official defence budget.