Headlines, Middle East & North Africa

IRAQ: Honesty an essential starting point for US to win a wider trust from

Att.Editors: The following item is by the United Arab Emirates news agency (WAM)

ABU DHABI, May 30 2003 (IPS) - The US and British governments appear to have misled the world with their claims that Iraq had weapons of mass destruction, said a United Arab Emirates (UAE) English daily.

– This failure of truth will now give both governments a serious challenge when they ask the Arab world to trust them in their efforts to rebuild Iraq or to find peace in Israel. Why should the Arabs believe governments that treat the truth so lightly?" asked the Dubai-based ‘Gulf News’ in its today’s editorial comment.

The paper reminded its readers that when the US-led coalition invaded Iraq and toppled the government of Saddam Hussain, their declared purpose was to stop the production and use of weapons of mass destruction. US President George W. Bush, and Prime Minister Tony Blair were both quite specific in their statements before the war, stating that their war was because Iraq had both the means to make weapons of mass destruction and a store of the weapons themselves.

At the time, the United Nations and International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) inspectors in Iraq had not found any weapons of mass destruction. Despite this, the US and British governments persisted in their claims that these weapons existed, quoting their own intelligence sources. In fact no such weapons were found and now US Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld has said that the weapons of mass destruction might have been destroyed before the war.

In Britain, the paper went on to say, the failure of the coalition to find weapons of mass destruction has led to the resignation of two ministers, Robin Cook and Clare Short, from the government, and a mounting campaign to have the war declared illegal. Such allegations, coupled with other charges on the indiscriminate use of cluster bombs, may harm Tony Blair’s political standing.

When Bush and Blair wanted United Nations approval for the war, they were forced to base their case on how Iraq had broken UN resolutions. They could not make the political case that they really wanted, which was that the dictatorship of Iraq had to be ended. That more brutal reality was hidden behind a legal cover, which has now turned out to be false.

It is certain that Iraq is a better place without Saddam’s government, and there is a historic opportunity to make the country into a better place. However, it is all too likely that this opportunity will slip past, as the United States does not seem to have a coherent plan for taking the country forward. To do so requires the Iraqis to trust the Americans, and it appears that they have made up the evidence that took them into Iraq in the first place.

The paper concluded that if the United States wants to be taken seriously as a force for good, it must work to the highest standards. Otherwise it will degrade itself to being just a military power and lose all claims to the moral high ground. This is happening now, and the United States has a brief opportunity to put it right.

It does not look likely that the US realizes that it is on trial in Iraq, and the Arab world is watching, with some hoping for it to succeed and others for it to fail. Honesty is an essential starting point for the Americans to win a wider trust from the Arabs, and a false war aim has been a disaster for that test.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags