Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Headlines, Population

HONG KONG-REFUGEES: A Problem That Refuses To Go Away

Yojana Sharma

HONG KONG, Jul 29 1997 (IPS) - Months before Hong Kong’s handover to Chinese rule, lawyers and refugee officials were counselling Vietnamese boat people in camps here to return home, warning that they may not get a very sympathetic ear from the new Chinese rulers.

However, a new influx of boat people since the June 30 handover had belied the belief among many in the refugee assistance community that fear of China would stop the Vietnamese from putting out in their rickety, barely seaworthy boats for the haven of Hong Kong.

So far this year, 1,218 Vietnamese asylum seekers have entered Hong Kong, more than the 1,038 recorded for the whole of last year and four times 1995 levels. In the last two days alone, 34 arrived in Hong Kong.

Most of the boat people who have arrived here in recent years were economic migrants, not people fleeing political persecution at home.

According to the Hong Kong government’s Security Branch which handles the situation, a large percentage — almost a quarter of the 1,700 in Hong Kong’s camps — have returned after being repatriated to Vietnam at least once.

And of the 34 who arrived in the last two days, 25 have been repatriated at least once, a possible indication of persecution in Vietnam on their arrival. Some claimed they were heading to Taiwan.

Some have reapplied for refugee status in Hong Kong although they were refused the first time round. “Some of them have stronger cases when they return because of the persecution they faced when they returned,” says refugee lawyer Pam Baker.

Earlier this year, the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) launched a massive effort to try to empty the camps by repatriating boat people and resettling those granted refugee status.

Several hundreds of them returned voluntarily to Vietnam in late May in keeping with an earlier agreement forged among British, Vietnamese and UNHR officials.

Most of the 1,000 or so left in the camps at the time of the handover were rejected for resettlement because of drug problems or criminal records.

And it became clear at the weekend that those still here would not leave without a fight. Five boat people climbed onto the roof of Hong Kong’s Victoria Prison to stage a protest against their impending repatriation.

They remained for several hours shouting slogans including “we would rather die than be repatriated”, a government spokesperson said.

China had demanded that Britain clear Hong Kong of Vietnamese boat people before the handover date, and Vietnam had made it clear that it did not want to negotiate with China over the issue, insisting it was Britain’s problem.

China and Vietnam are rebuilding their ties after years of hostility sparked by a brief border war in 1979.

A Hong Kong immigration official based at the British embassy in Hanoi was withdrawn just before the handover, and diplomats say talks will have to be conducted long distance between the two sides.

But without any apparent deadline such as the handover date, diplomats said “the heat has gone out of the issue”.

The latest arrivals have succeeded in bringing the problem to the fore gain and has led directly to calls by legislators to abandon Hong Kong’s port of asylum policy.

A government official said Hong Kong’s port of first asylum policy exists “in name only” because Vietnamese illegal immigrants who have been coming to Hong Kong recently will not be screened and will be treated as illegal immigrants.

He said boat people have come to work as illegal labour.

“We must send a clear signal to boat people that we are not accepting them any more,” said Hong Kong legislator Selina Chow who has tabled a motion to scrap the port of asylum policy. It is likely to be debated next month.

Chow says boats carrying Vietnamese should be “chased away” from Hong Kong waters.

Legislators argue that this is the only realistic course to stop the flow of boat people to Hong Kong. But even if the message gets back to Vietnam, voluntary relief groups say it does not resolve the problem of what will happen to the boat people already here, likely to be a thorny problem between China and Vietnam.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags