Headlines, Human Rights, Middle East & North Africa

POLITICS-MIDEAST: Time Running Out for U.S.-Palestine Ties

Abid Aslam

WASHINGTON, Jul 28 1997 (IPS) - Time is running out for diplomatic and financial ties between the United States and the Palestinian Authority.

The Middle East Peace Facilitation Act (MEPFA) – which authorises Washington’s diplomatic relations with and aid to the Palestinians – expires August 12. On that date, the Palestine Liberation Organisation (PLO) would be forced to close its office here and U.S. financial assistance to the Palestinians would be frozen.

This “would effectively end the peace process,” senior Democrats in the House of Representatives warn.

There is little hope the law will be extended before Congress takes its August recess, legislative staffers say, citing growing anti-Palestinian sentiment and concern that the Palestinians have failed to meet their security-related obligations under the Oslo peace agreements.

Human rights and political analysts here are concerned that the emphasis on security measures is counter-productive, serving merely to add pressure to an already tense situation. In testimony before Congress, staffers at Human Rights Watch (HRW)/Middle East have argued that, by insisting the Palestinian Authority clamp down further, the United States is promoting Palestinian authoritarianism and repression.

U.S. lawmakers have held hearings on human rights violations by the Palestinian Authority. Yet, they also encourage abuses by supporting mass arrests, state security courts, and other repressive measures enacted in the name of security, says Joe Stork, advocacy director at HRW/Middle East. The state security courts – set up in 1995 with “explicit encouragement” from the U.S. government – offer defendants few due process rights and no right of appeal, Stork told IPS.

The U.S. approach also has been criticised for endorsing Israeli border closings. Human rights advocates regard these as ‘blanket’ or collective means of punishing entire populations for the alleged offenses of a few. Economic analysts note that the closings – which prevent Palestinians from getting to their jobs in Israel and disrupt the flow of trade – destabilise an already shaky economy and contribute to the climate of insecurity and frustration.

MEPFA, which was enacted after the Israelis and Palestinians signed their peace pact in September 1993, has expired three times before. But each time, Congress renewed the law after only a brief disruption in relations. This time around, staffers say, U.S. lawmakers’ enthusiasm has been drained by the breakdown in Israeli- Palestinian talks and the recent arrest by Isreali forces of four Palestinian police officers suspected of plotting a terrorist strike against Israel.

Growing violence between the Isrealis and Palestinians also has scuppered U.S. State Department efforts to certify that the Palestinians are complying with the Oslo accords. Under MEPFA, this certification permits President Bill Clinton to waive long- standing restrictions on doing business with the PLO, which is classified as a terrorist organisation under U.S. law. Certification is required every six months and was last issued in January.

The process, however is dogged by charges of one-sidedness. Senior U.S. officials acknowledge privately that they have merely fretted about Israeli blockades and housing expansion, while holding the threat of political and financial sanctions over the Palestinians’ heads.

Republicans in the House of Representatives, led by House Speaker Newt Gingrich of Georgia, have called for a tougher line on certification and dealings with the Palestinian Authority. But House Democrats John Dingell of Michigan and Nick Rahall II of West Virginia are proposing that MEPFA be extended for six months while Congress and the White House negotiate modifications to the law.

“A freeze in relations with the PLO and suspension of urgently needed economic aid would effectively end the peace process,” Dingell and Rahall said in a letter to colleagues last week.

Nearly four years after Oslo, the Palestinians have yet to see a ‘peace dividend’ – or economic reward. Rather, unemployment has doubled and individual incomes have fallen by one-fifth, accompanied by a downswing in overall and private investment, according to the International Monetary Fund (IMF).

At the same time, foreign investment in Isreal has grown six- fold. Israeli exports have surged by 43 percent, in part because a number of countries rescinded long-standing embargoes of Isreali goods after the accords were signed.

Four out of every ten Palestinians of working age are without jobs, according to Palestinian figures cited by the IMF. Many more are underemployed, meaning that their jobs do not permit them to work enough hours to earn a subistence wage, says University of Michigan economist Jennifer Olmstead in a report for the non- governmental, Washington-based Middle East Research and Information Project (MERIP).

Although a ‘Protocol on Economic Relations’ agreed to in May 1994 commits both sides to maintaining “the normality of movement of labour” between them, border and labour restrictions have increased since last year’s suicide bomb attacks inside Israel.

Invoking security concerns, Israel has shunned Palestinian workers and imported replacements from as far away as Thailand, says Olmstead. Some 120,000 Palestinians had jobs in Israel in 1992, the year before Oslo. Before hostilities intensified again last year, the number was only 25,100 workers, out of a total labour force of some 450,000, the IMF says.

Israel has also restricted the movement of goods across borders, she adds, forcing Palestinian businesses to slow down production because they have been cut off from their imported supplies and export markets.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags