Headlines, Human Rights, Middle East & North Africa

KUWAIT: Kuwaiti Parliament, An Exception To The Gulf Rule

Dilip Hiro

LONDON, Jun 13 1997 (IPS) - Kuwait’s parliament could be facing a new challenge to its independence in the wake of the arrest of five men in connection with a bid to assassinate anti-corruption campaigner and Kuwati MP Abdullah al-Naibari.

Liberal MP Mishari al-Osaimi has accused the five suspects of being part of a “mafia” busy embezzling public funds. He vows that “bullets will not silence people” who speak out against public corruption.

His words were seen as a challenge to the ruling authorities and especially, a defence of the independence of parliament in Kuwait — a feature that sets the tiny emirate apart from the rest of the Arab Gulf monarchies.

Alone among other Gulf monarchs, who permit only advisory bodies of nominees, the Kuwaiti ruler has an elected 50-member legislature, called the National Assembly.

It is elected only on a limited franchise; the vote is granted only to literate male citizens whose family has been living in Kuwait since 1921.

Yet the independence of the Kuwaiti parliament, specified by the constitution promulgated by independent Kuwait in 1962, has long been a bone of contention between the ruling Emir and his MPs, with the Emir dissolving the legislature twice in a little over two decades.

Despite attempts by the Emir to regulate its proceedings, over the years the National Assembly has evolved into an institutional means of expression and political access to the main socio- economic elements of society: nomadic and sedentary tribes, urban merchants and businessmen, and professionals and political intellectuals.

In 1976, and again in 1986, the Emir could not tolerate the tone of debates in the National Assembly and dissolved it, suspending the pertinent articles of the constitution. The first suspension lasted five years, and the second four.

On Tuesday there was a familiar tone to the ruling family’s reaction to the parliamentary charges. “I am trying to control my temper,” snapped acting prime minister and foreign minister Sheikh Sabah al-Ahmad al-Sabah.

“They should discuss this crime, but not accuse us of anything,” the furious sheikh told parliament, warning MPs not to force him “to do something I don’t want to do.” MPs interpreted this as a threat to dissolve parliament again.

Al-Talia, a newspaper run by al-Naibari’s Democratic Forum liberal movement last month accused “figures close to ministers,” including an army officer, of corruption. Al-Naibari, who headed a committee for the protection of public funds in the last parliament was shot twice in his car. Three Kuwaitis and two Iranians were arrested within 24 hours of the attack.

The MPs in Kuwait have been particularly alert in sniffing out corruption. Possessing nearly a tenth of the world’s oil reserves, Kuwait is inordinately rich. Of its tiny population of 1.5 million, only two-fifths are Kuwaiti citizens.

Among them the members of the governing al-Sabah family are at the pinnacle. Besides providing the Emir, the final arbiter of power, they also, invariably, head the crucial ministries of oil, finance and defence.

Well aware that petroleum is a non-renewable asset, the Kuwaiti government set up a Reserve Fund for Future Generations in 1976. By injecting 10 percent of its annual oil revenue into the Reserve Fund, it brought the cumulative total to nearly 100 billion dollars on the eve of the Iraqi invasion of Kuwait in August 1990.

Seven-eighths of this sum was invested abroad, and managed mostly by the Kuwait Investment Authority (KIA), a department of the finance ministry.

Soon after the expulsion of the Iraqis from Kuwait in February 1991, a scandal broke out concerning alleged mismanagement of the Reserve Fund assets by the KIA. But since there was no Kuwaiti parliament at the time, its members could not pursue the matter and the local press lacked investigative zeal to fill the gap.

However, when the al-Sabahs resumed their rule in March 1991, they failed to win back the respect of their subjects they had enjoyed before the Iraqi invasion. Their hasty departure in the face of the Iraqi onslaught did much damage to their popular standing.

As a result, when in 1997 another scandal erupted about the mishandling of the assets of the Reserve Fund for Future Generations, the parliamentary opposition felt emboldened to urge an investigation into the charges, and succeeded. Abdullah al- Naibari played an active role in the matter, and also in having similar charges in the case of the Kuwait Oil Tanker Company examined.

Material corruption stems from the monopoly of political power that the ruling dynasties enjoy in the oil-rich Gulf states.

The ruler of Saudi Arabia promised a partly elected legislature and ‘basic laws’ in 1960. But it was only in March 1992 that King Fahd ibn Abdul Aziz issued a decree setting out ‘basic laws’ of governance (meaning constitution), and only in August 1993 did he appoint a 60-member Consultative Council with a four-year tenure.

It was authorised to do nothing more than question the government, and any official action it disputed was to be referred to the monarch.

In Oman there is as yet no written constitution. And it was only in late 1991 that Sultan Qaboos ibn Said issued a decree concerning a fully-nominated 60-member Consultative Council with a three-year tenure. The chamber is empowered to draft legislation only on social and economic affairs for submission to the appropriate ministry.

Similarly in Qatar, the fully-nominated Advisory Council, established soon after the country became independent in September 1971, is authorised to advise the cabinet only on the matters referred to it by the ruler.

In contrast, in the United Arab Emirates, a federation of seven emirates, the fully-nominated 40-member Federal National Council, drawn from the constituent emirates, has the power to amend or reject the legislation proposed by the cabinet.

The only Gulf monarchy which can claim to have emulated Kuwait in having an elected parliament, albeit on a limited franchise, is Bahrain, after it became independent in August 1971.

Its constitution, drafted by a partly elected Constituent Assembly, specified a National Assembly of 42, with 30 deputies to be elected on a limited franchise. The experiment was brief. The first National Assembly, convened in December 1973, was dissolved, and the constitution suspended, by the Emir in August 1975.

After the 1991 Gulf War, to meet the rising demand for political reform, the Emir appointed a 30-member Advisory Council in 1993.

This proved insufficient. In December 1994 widespread demonstrations erupted, with the protesters calling for the restoration of the dissolved parliament. Government repression followed.

But despite the death of 16 people and arrest of nearly 2,000, the protest continued, intermittently, for nearly two years. It has not died down yet.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags