Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Headlines, Population

PHILIPPINES: Long Wait for New Anti-Rape Law Becomes Even Longer

Johanna Son

MANILA, Jun 9 1997 (IPS) - After waiting for a decade, supporters of a bill that makes the Philippines’ law against rape more women- friendly must wait some more before the measure makes it into the country’s statute books.

The bill, which was to be a major revision of current laws on rape, was scheduled for signing into law by Philippine President Fidel Ramos on Friday.

But a last-minute hitch emerged Thursday night, when key members of the House of Representatives refused to ratify the bill because they objected to a provision that recognises the concept of marital rape. The Senate had earlier approved the measure.

The congressmen’s objection meant the bill could not be enacted into law last week — the third time its enactment had been aborted due to controversial provisions.

Activists say the rough sailing of anti-rape legislation shows the insensitivity of many lawmakers to women’s concerns, not least of which was some male lawmakers’ inability to understand how there could be such a thing as marital rape.

“Congress has held on to its power to exclusively define women’s experiences by ignoring women’s voices,” said Evelyn Ursua of the Women’s Legal Bureau.

Congress’ failure to pass the bill does not help the country’s heretofore decent record in promoting women’s rights at the United Nations, they added.

“For failing to pass a very critical bill for the prevention of violence against women, the Philippines’ ratings will drop for sure,” Aurora Javate de Dios, the country’s representative at the U.N. Committee on the Elimination of Discrimination against Women, told journalists.

Women’s campaigners have been seeking changes to the rape law for a decade now, though lobbying picked up some five years ago. Disappointed, the bill’s main sponsor, Sen. Leticia Shahani, said on Friday: “I am really sorry because I thought we would be making history today.”

Rape cases reported to the police have been rising lately, reaching 3,384 cases nationwide in 1996 or an increase of nearly 50 percent from the previous year. Women’s groups estimate that one in 20 rapes go unreported.

The bill changes the legal nature of rape from a crime against chastity to a crime against a person, which shifts its definition away from a sexual crime to one of violence. Experts say this should make prosecution easier under a legal system biased against women.

Because many victims opt against prosecution, the bill allows persons related to the rape victim to file charges in court. Rape is also punishable by death in the Philippines, especially when the victim is a minor or when combined with murder.

Activists say they thought the original anti-rape bill would be major step in correcting the law’s flaws. But after it seeing it change shape amid political compromises in the legislature, they say it is no longer the landmark measure it promised to be.

The bill’s only gain for women is the reclassification of rape as a crime against a person, they point out. “On all other provisions such as marital rape, Congess gives, but the subtantially takes away,” said a press statement by SIBOL, a coalition of women’s groups that lobbied Congress.

The Senate version of the measure had at first provided that a husband who forces his wife to have sex can be liable for marital rape. But senators soon found out there was no way legislators, particularly in the lower house, would agree to it.

Under the Philippines’ bicameral form of legislature, both houses of Congress have to agree on a measure before it sent to the President for enactment into law.

Senators then left out an explicit definition of marital rape and instead said the crime of rape is extinguished if the wife “forgives” the husband, or the victim marries the offender. Shahani said this clause was needed to prevent scenarios where wives would be repeatedly dragging husbands to court.

“What kind of marriage is that? So we thought the more humane aspect was to forgive the crime of rape,” and allow marriages to be patched up when they can, Shahani said. But congressmen turned down the forgiveness clause, saying it implicitly recognised marital rape.

Shahani herself favours a marital rape clause because “every woman retains full control of her body even in marriage”. But a compromise had to be made to get the anti-rape bill passed.

Shahani says the non-mention of marital rape does not weaken the law, because local jurisprudence has time and again accepted there is such a thing as marital rape. Some experts it would have been worse if legislators had agreed to classify marital rape as mere sexual assault, as had been proposed.

Women’s activists cautioned that the law may interpret as “forgiveness” what in reality may be a woman’s inability to break out of an abusive situation due to psychological, economic or cultural factors.

When the bill was first filed, it proposed to widen the definition of rape from sexual penetration to include other forms of rape, such as the insertion of foreign objects into genitalia, anal orifice or mouth. But this created such an outcry in the legislature that the measure had to be toned down.

In its latest version, the bill imposes lighter penalties nd shorter prison terms for those convicted of these other forms of rape. This trivialised other forms of rape that are “just as devastating”, SIBOL said.

Supporters say the bill widens the definition of rape by covering male victims, but women say this glosses over the reality that “the vast majority of rape victims are women and the perpetrators of rape of women, children and men are men”.

Legislators now say they hope to get the bill passed in a few months, when Congress reconvenes for a new legislative year. But whatever the bill’s final form, there is likely to be a sizable gap between what activists want to see and compromises that politicians have to make to get the law through Congress.

Activists say they are not surprised by the failure of many congressmen to grasp the reality of rape for women. One of their own, congressman Romeo Jalosjos, is now facing charges for the rape of an 11-year-old girl.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags