Friday, November 20, 2026
Stephen Dale
- Talk of a national break-up has enlivened a Canadian election campaign that began as a quiet contest focused on Prime Minister Jean Chretien’s economic record.
Canada stood at the brink of dissolution in Oct. 1995, when federalist forces narrowly won a referendum in the French-speaking province of Quebec on whether the province should separate from the rest of Canada. The vote to remain within Canada was decided by a margin of only one percent of electors.
Quebec sovereignty soon faded as a public preoccupation in Canada, but the issue has re-emerged with a vengeance during the current campaign, with federalist parties seeming to have achieved heightened popularity at the expense of the Bloc Quebecois, the party that represents Quebec separatists in Ottawa.
But even if the Bloc suffers major losses in the Jun. 2 federal vote, some observers say that Canada could still face the prospect of splitting up during the next term.
“The Bloc could do quite badly, but I don’t think that will mean the sovereignty issue will be over,” says Carolyn Andrew, professor of political science at the University of Ottawa. “It would just reinforce what people have been saying for a long time: that Quebeckers have a very deep, very interesting ambivalence over the position of Quebec within Canada.”
With the separatist Parti Quebecois still controlling the provincial government, a vote against the Bloc at the national level may only reflect that fact that the Bloc “has run a very soft campaign” marred by miscues and images of incompetence, the political scientist argues.
While the Bloc has faltered, Canada’s two right-wing federalist parties — the Progressive Conservative party and the Reform Party — have used the national unity issue to enhance their own profiles and to chip away at the commanding lead in the polls held by the governing Liberals.
Reform and the Conservatives share similar economic platforms, with both promising tax cuts and massive cuts to government spending, but they take opposite approaches on the issue of Quebec separation.
Conservative leader Jean Charest has boosted his party’s fortunes, especially within Quebec, by promising to acknowledge Quebec as “a distinct society” and to prove to Quebeckers that they are still welcome within the Canadian federation. During a recent televised leaders’ debate, Charest won the only spontaneous applause of the evening by passionately declaring that “I intend to make this country work.”
By contrast, Preston Manning, leader of Reform, a populist party with its base of support in Western Canada, has taken a hard line towards Quebec separatists and won more support from some parts of English Canada. He opposes “distinct society” status for Quebec, in favour of “equality for all provinces,” which in policy terms translates as a devolution of major federal powers to all of the provinces.
Manning has also said that Quebec must be told that if this is not enough for the province, and Quebec votes to separate from Canada, the province will have to pay reparations to account for its portion of the federal debt, and that disputed territory will stay within Canada.
Leaders of the other parties have accused Manning of using inflammatory language for political gain at the expense of the health of the country.
Alexa McDonough, leader of the left-leaning New Democratic Party (NDP), told a Vancouver news conference that “I think it is absolutely clear that where Preston Manning’s policies would lead us in this country is straight into a civil war.”
The NDP holds the position that restoring funding to federal social programmes will be the strongest incentive for Quebec to remain within Canada, which at one time had a reputation as “the Sweden of North America” because of its comprehensive health and social welfare programmes.
The current wave of anxiety of Quebec separation began several weeks ago when the Quebec City newspaper, Le Soleil, published an excerpt from the memoirs of Jacques Parizeau, who was Premier of Quebec during the 1995 referendum. Parizeau became a public relations albatross for the separatist cause when he declared, on the night of the referendum, that the loss to the separatists was due to “money and the ethnic vote.”
In his book, Parizeau says that he was prepared to declare Quebec’s independence immediately after a pro-sovereignty referendum vote, even though the referendum question asked for a mandate to spend the next year negotiating the terms of Quebec’s secession with the federal government.
Parizeau wrote that former French President Valery Giscard d’Estang had convinced him of the need for a swift declaration of independence, so that France could recognise Quebec as an independent country.
“France, like the other countries of the world, only recognises countries. It doesn’t recognise intentions,” the ex- premier wrote in his book, ‘Pour un Quebec Souverain’. He says he believes that French recognition would have forced the United States to also recognise Quebec’s sovereignty.
The rising furor over national unity has largely obscured the debate over the economic performance of the Liberal government, which claims it has set the stage for economic growth in Canada by reducing the federal deficit and bringing down interest rates.
The Liberals won a landslide majority in 1993, in an election that dramatically changed the political landscape in Canada. Traditionally, the Liberal and Conservative parties had alternated in government, with both governing from the centre. The leftist NDP has served as the “conscience” of Canada with relatively strong third-place showings.
In 1993, however, the Conservatives were reduced to just two seats in Parliament after two terms of majority government under Prime Minister Brian Mulroney. The NDP were also hurt badly, as they were reduced to just nine seats. The newly formed Bloc Quebecois won enough seats to form the official opposition and the upstart right-wing Reform Party rocketed to about 50 seats.
Although the Liberals took power after promising to restore government spending for job creation and social programmes, they continued to attack the deficit with more spending cuts once in office.
The NDP is now telling Canadians that more NDP candidates in Parliament would keep the Liberals honest, while the Reform and Conservatives are pushing for tax-cuts to stimulate private-sector job creation.
Some analysts argue that the Liberals may return to higher social spending and more centrist economic policies if they win the June 2 contest, particularly if the NDP has greater representation in Parliament.
This direction, says political scientist Carolyn Andrew, would “correspond to a significant strain in public opinion, since you have a lot of polls showing that Canadians, given the choice, would rather not have tax cuts if it means more cuts to social spending.”
“What the Liberals can now argue,” she says, “is that the battle of the deficit is largely won, and that allows them to move back towards the centre.”