Europe, Headlines

EUROPE: Russia Comes To Terms With NATO

IPS Correspondents

PARIS, May 27 1997 (IPS) - His pact with the world’s most powerful military alliance signed, Russian leader Boris Yeltsin now begins the tortuous process of explaining its disputed worth to a deeply sceptical Russian public and a overtly hostile parliament.

Before the ink was even dry on the ‘Founding Act on Mutual Relations, Cooperation and Security between NATO and the Russian Federation’, signed here by Yeltsin and NATO’s 16 heads of government, NATO leaders reconfirmed their own summit scheduled for Madrid on Jul. 8.

There it will start talks on enlargement with leaders of at least three of Russia’s former Cold War allies.

If approved, the accession of Poland, Hungary and the Czech Republic to the North Atlantic Treaty Organisation, plus possibly Romania and Slovenia, will bring the Alliance up to the borders of the old Soviet Union. Most Russians are unhappy about being corralled by so many tanks, bombers and cruise missiles under NATO — read U.S. — command.

“Russia still views negatively the expansion plans of NATO,” Yeltsin bluntly told the gathered heads of states in Paris Tuesday.

“At the same time,” he added, “we pay tribute to the readiness exhibited by NATO countries, despite those difficulties, to reach an agreement with Russia and take into account our interests.”

Yeltsin diplomatically overstated the case. During six months of tortuous negotiations ahead of Tuesday’s signing Russia tried and failed to redefine the process of expansion as a top-level political initiative legally binding on all. Moscow had hoped that a new NATO-Russia institution would become the key political forum for security issues, alongside or even ahead of the Alliance’s ruling North Atlantic Council of member states.

Instead the planned ‘NATO-Russia Permanent Joint Council’, will only consider matters of common interest such as terrorism, nuclear safety, and planning for peacekeeping, and neither side will have a veto over its activities in these spheres.

“There is not enough trust yet,” noted Philip Gordon, a senior fellow at the London-based International Institute for Strategic Studies. “At the same time, the agreement does not constrain anyone to do anything. There is neither the trust nor the binding agreement.”

The new joint council must hold its first meeting by the end of September. It has a back up network of military cooperation through liaison offices and staff exchanges to reinforce mutual trust.

The fact that NATO has given a specific undertaking in the document to review its own outdated strategic concept was another positive thing to emerge from the agreement, said Tasos Kokkinides of the London-based British-American Security Information Council.

The ‘concept’ is based on a 1991 document which stressed the Cold War guiding principle of nuclear and conventional deterrence. Russia has long demanded that NATO should adapt to the new situation.

Kokkinides thinks the result will be a stress on peacekeeping, conflict resolution and diplomatic initiatives ahead of more conventional dependence on maintaining military preparedness.

“European security is not a zero-sum game,” U.S. president Bill Clinton said Tuesday, “where NATO’s gain is Russia’s loss, and Russia’s strength is our Alliance’s weakness. That is old thinking; these are new times.” He said that NATO is changing from a military alliance aimed at Russia into a transatlantic system that includes it.

Yeltsin cites western concessions in far more promising economic and political fields. Russia is to join the Group of Seven richest nations; there will be talks on a new START nuclear weapons reduction pact, and more foreign loans, investment and trading opportunities.

His trouble is that his loudest critics care little for these advantages. His truculent parliament (duma) is dominated by Russian nationalists furiously opposed to ceding more of Russia’s superpower authority to NATO. They are still more angered by the fact that since the Founding Act is not a treaty, they will not be required to ratified it, denying them a say over the process.

According to Zgzisalaw Lachowsky, a Polish researcher with the Stockholm-based Swedish International for Peace Research Institute, it is Russia which must now take the initiative. “Much depends on Russia, though so far Yeltsin has been going quite well with the nationalist opposition,” he said.

Last week Russian foreign minister Yegevny Primakov personally addressed the Duma in closed session last week to make the case that the Founding Act was not a closed document, but a means of defining NATO-Russian relations that could well be in Russia’s benefit.

“It is wrapped up in nice words, but is still subject to different interpretations,” Lachowsky said. “Though it is a politically binding document, there is enough room to manouevre. It gives Russia a certain amount of leeway in consolidating its relationship with other countries of the former Soviet Union.”

Last week Yeltsin spokesman Sergei Yastrzhembsky said that both houses of the Russian parliament, the Council of the Federation and the Duma, the lower house, could add “certain conditions” to the accord after its signature.

So far only two conditions have been laid down by Primakov as cast-iron; a ban on deployment of nuclear forces on new member territory, and an absolute refusal to allow former Soviet Union nations to join the Alliance.

NATO made advance concessions on the nuclear issue. But the second issue has severely alarmed the Baltic states of Latvia, Lithuania and Estonia, swallowed up by the Soviet Union during World War II and restored to sour independence in 1990/91. They say NATO membership is their only guarantee of independence.

Yeltsin has warned that Russia will declare the pact invalid if the western alliance gives membership to any ex-Soviet countries. NATO replies that membership for Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania has not been ruled out, along with possible Russian membership at some point in the future.

NATO is determined to ensure that there will be no ‘second class’ membership. All future members of the Alliance will be fully covered by Article Five of the NATO treaty, which commits members to defend each other from attack.

“I expect Russia to increasingly raise the issue of NATO expansion in the Joint Council and though it has no veto, the resultant pressure will be on NATO,” Kokkinides said. “It will not look nice if they keep disagreeing on the subject.”

Few central Europeans still believe that Russia harbours secret desires to run its tanks over their lands again, and recognise that even though Russia has recovered some of its old assertiveness in foreign policy, it is a long way from cutting itself out of consensus building on European military activity.

Also NATO’s sole foray into combat so far, in Bosnia-Hercegovina, was co-authorised by Russia through U.N. Security Council resolutions and joined by Russian troops. Few generals anywhere envisage future NATO action that would not get similar approval from Moscow first.

Yet the fact remains that any expansion to the east does place the western military alliance on the borders of the former Soviet Union, though not of Russia itself. It would still amount to the creation of a defined security border and revive the concept of two military blocs in Europe.

Polish president Lech Walesa has argued that by allowing Russia to maintain the illusion of still being a superpower, NATO was increasing the chances of it adopting a policy of confrontation with the west and abandoning its internal reform process.

“Only by increasing its power will NATO ensure that Russia abandons its policy of confrontation,” Walesa said last week, accusing NATO of “limitless naivete” in striking a deal with Moscow.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags