Environment, Headlines, North America

CANADA-POLITICS: Election Debate Ignores Environment, Foreign Policy

Stephen Dale

OTTAWA, May 26 1997 (IPS) - Environmental protection and foreign policy have been virtually excluded from the election debate as Canadians prepare to choose a new government June 2, say frustrated observers here.

Issues related to international relations are rarely prominent in Canadian electoral contests, with the notable exception of the 1988 federal vote which was largely fought over the impending free- trade pact between Canada and the United States.

“But even against the normal standards, you can’t help but think that there’s even less discussion (of foreign policy) than usual, that we are even more inward-looking this time than before,” says Roy Culpepper, president of the independent North- South Institute in Ottawa.

With an almost singular focus on what the next Prime Minister would do in the event of another referendum on Quebec’s separation from Canada, there has been little time to discuss domestic economic concerns, let alone foreign policy and the environment.

That does not mean that the parties do not have their platforms on these issues. The governing Liberals, for instance, have a foreign policy section in their book of campaign promises, in which they tout Canada’s independence from the United States on the world stage. Prominently mentioned are Canada’s opposition to the United States’ anti-Cuban law and Canadian efforts to achieve a global ban on land mines.

The current Liberal government of Jean Chretien has been careful to portray itself as an independent operator, since former Prime Minister Brian Mulroney was seen by the Canadian public as being too close to the U.S. administrations of Ronald Reagan and George Bush.

“Canadians want their government to play an active, independent, internationalist role in the world,” says the Liberal campaign book. “Canadian foreign policy should reflect Canada’s commitment to values such as peace, tolerance, co- operation, and respect for democracy, human rights, and the rule of law.”

Despite such noble pronouncements, critics say the Chretien government has been inconsistent in applying its foreign policy goals. Human rights is one area in which Canada has been highly selectively in its response, these critics note.

Although Canada took a lead role in condemning Nigeria’s military regime for human rights abuses, Ottawa has reversed its traditional stand of condemning the human rights record of China, where Canada hopes to do a lot of business, and has also failed to raise human rights concerns in countries like Indonesia during high-level foreign trade missions led by Prime Minister Chretien.

Some commentators here say Canada will pay a practical as well as a moral price for turning a blind eye to human rights issues abroad when commercial interests are at stake.

Foreign affairs reporter Jeff Sallot commented recently in the Globe and Mail newspaper that democratic forces will ultimately assume power throughout Asia, and that when they do, “the triumphant democrats will remember who their friends were and who kept faith with their cause. Canada does not want to be remembered for cozying up to dictators and turning a blind eye to human rights abuses we would not tolerate at home.”

Culpepper of the North-South Institute says the appointment of Lloyd Axworthy as Foreign Affairs minister half-way through the Liberals’ first term was a good sign. But he says Axworthy will find it hard to push for a more active Canadian stance on human rights if the Liberals win a second term (as the polls show they are likely to do), given that fellow cabinet ministers look to expanded foreign trade as the bigger priority by far.

“Axworthy took human rights much more seriously than his predecessor; it’s one of his principal issues,” Culpepper told IPS. “But when you factor in the whole government…one doesn’t see (human rights concerns) as anything more than just an ongoing sideshow in the person of Lloyd Axworthy. One can’t be terribly hopeful on the basis of the record so far.”

Canadian environmentalists are similarly frustrated that reporters have failed to quiz the candidates about Canada’s failure to work towards meeting its international commitments on climate change.

Claiming that the powerful petroleum lobby was pushing Canada to default on its commitment to reducing earth-warming, greenhouse gas emissions, a prominent environmental group, the David Suzuki Foundation, recently bought a full-page newspaper advertisement, headlined, “It’s time for Canadian Voters to Turn Up the Heat”.

The ad quotes a Canadian Association of Petroleum Producers (CAPP) memo as saying that “CAPP is fully engaged to ensure Canada does not adopt drastic measures in Kyoto”, where emissions will be discussed next year. The ad \quotes the memo as saying that “a move towards an emissions cap would end the significant growth the industry now enjoys.” It also quotes an Imperial Oil company document as declaring that “Canada must avoid committing to any legally binding arrangement to constrain greenhouse emissions.”

According to David Hocking, communications director at the Suzuki Foundation in Vancouver, Canada’s political parties want to steer clear of this issue, for fear of alienating voters in the country’s chief petroleum-producing province, Alberta, where meddling with oil company profits has proven to be political poison in the past.

Canada, which is the second largest per capita producer of carbon dioxide emissions in the industrialised world, was once a strong international proponent of reducing this and other gases that trap heat in the atmosphere. But Hocking tells IPS that the petroleum industry has derailed those efforts by portraying emission curbs as a killer of jobs and economic activity, a statement which the foundation says has been refuted by a group of 2,800 leading U.S. and Canadian economists.

“Sooner or later, there will be regulation on this issue, because we can’t afford not to regulate it,” says Hocking. “Canada could take a lead role and make our economy more energy efficient and be able to sell our new technologies to the rest of the world. Or we could put our heads in the sand and try to protect yesterday’s economy and be in a far less competitive economic position.”

Hocking adds that retreating from its targets to reduce emissions will damage Canada’s reputation, since “what happens to people who say one thing and do another is that others start not to trust them.”

But if the Liberal government’s international record is greeted with some cynicism by internal critics, the platforms of competing parties offer little consolation. The two right-wing parties — the Conservatives and the Reform Party — which pose the greatest threat to the Liberals, are both campaigning on the platform of tax cuts which will require major reductions in government spending.

The Conservatives, for instance, who are in second place nationally in the polls, propose significant cuts to the environment ministry as well as cuts in the annual foreign affairs and international development budgets amounting to about six billion U.S. dollars.

Coming on the heels of successive budget cuts that have moved Canada away from its longstanding target of increasing foreign aid to 0.7 percent of gross domestic product, Culpepper says the Conservatives’ promised aid cut is callous and “extremely opportunistic.”

“I can’t think of anything more charitable to say about it,” he says. “It just reeks of opportunism and a lack of any kind of policy integrity.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags