Saturday, November 21, 2026
Kalinga Seneviratne
- Australia’s courts may have already upheld the land rights of its Aboriginal communities, but native leaders are now gearing up for yet another struggle amid a government plan that could roll back legal gains of the past years.
They are upset over a plan by the government of Prime Minister John Howard that would effectively extinguish native title on pastoral leases held by Australian farmers and miners, a right upheld by the country’s High Court in December.
In what is called the “Wik decision”, named after an indigenous group, the High Court declared then that native title by Aboriginal communities could “co-exist” with pastoral leases, if they can prove traditional links to the land.
Analysts interpreted the decision to mean that Aborigines could enter their traditional lands, now worked by Australians, to hold ceremonies, visit sacred shrines or gather food.
But farmers and miners fear the consequences may go beyond that and believe the Wik judgement would open their lands to claims by Aboriginal peoples, who make up less than two percent of Australia’s 18 million people.
Some 40 percent of Australia’s area is covered by pastoral leases, created during colonial times to allow farming on large tracts of land in a process that displaced Australia’s original inhabitants.
Far from helping ease tensions between Aboriginal leaders and Australian farmers and miners, Howard’s plan may be firing up the debate even more.
His 10-point plan includes limiting the rights of Aboriginal people to negotiate on land use while expanding the rights of pastoralists. It changes the process for native land claims and contains sunset clauses.
Dismayed, Aboriginal leaders have threatened to internationalise the issue by seeking United Nations intervention and launch protests in the run-up to the 2000 Sydney Olympics.
Geoff Clarke of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Commission chief and spokesman on native title issues, says Aboriginal leaders will seek a boycott of the Sydney Olympics if Howard goes ahead with his plan and seeks legislation for it.
Saying Aboriginals are running out of patience, he said: “We believe we have just about exhausted the process of diplomacy in this country with this government.”
As a first step, he says native leaders will go to the Commonwealth leaders’ summit in Scotland later this year to lobby African nations on the issue.
The debate shows how Australia has not quite figured out how to deal with its past.
In 1992, the High Court in a judgement known as the “Mabo Decision” overturned the 204-year-old concept of “terra nullius” – that Australia was a vast, empty land when the first white settlers set foot on it in 1788.
Recognising the traditional land rights of the native people, the court declared that Aborigines and Torres Strait Islanders could be owners of the Crown Land on which their people had always lived. This was called native title.
The Native Title Act, which recognised native title for the first time in Australia, was passed by the government and became law in January 1994. Under it, Aborigines could lay claim to land if they could prove uninterrupted traditional usage.
In June 1993, the indigenous Wik people of northern Queensland went to the High Court to claim title to their old lands on Cape York peninsula, leased to white pastoralists in 1915.
In December 1996, the High Court declared by a vote of 4 to 3 that pastoral leases did not necessarily extinguish native title. Since that time, farmers, miners, the Queensland and West Australian state premiers and many government backbenchers have been pressuring Howard to move legislation in Parliament to extinguish native title on both pastoral land and mining leases.
“There are nearly 500 unresolved registered native title claims” said Donald McGauchie, president of the National Farmers Federation.
“The Wik decision has resulted in even freehold rural property sales collapsing, some banks expressing concern about asset security … a slowing or stopping in a wide range of real estate activity and a widespread reluctance to invest in rural Australia”, he added.
Warning that uncertainty over the status of lands used for mining and farming could shake business conference, he asked: “What is the cost to Australia and its export income of that scenario continuing?”
Howard’s plan, presented to the Cabinet last month, is the government’s response to the Wik decision.
At this point, the plan is some way from becoming law. A bill has to be sent to Parliament and even if passed, will meet objections in the Senate, where the government does not have the votes. And even if it becomes law, it could be challenged before the High Court.
Clarke warns that the Australian public will have to pay a great social cost for Howard’s actions.
But Howard says that he is not going to extinguish native title or change the racial discrimination act. “My plan will give certainty which they (farmers) believe extinguishment will deliver, without some of the costs” he told a meeting of party faithfuls in Queensland recently.
Under the Howard plan, pastoralists would be able to undertake any activities defined as primary production in the tax act. This broader definition would considerably enhance the value of pastoral leases. It would allow farmers greater freedom in the way they use the land leased from the state, while protecting them from any native title claims by Aborigines.
Noel Pearson, leader of the National Indigenous Working Group, last month presented a position paper offering a compromise, but Howard rejected the paper, saying Pearson’s group will have to move a long way before he could accommodate it.
The Group’s compromise offer includes agreement to streamline the native title process and guarantee that pastoralists’ rights to their leased lands would not be eroded. But it also rules out upgrading leases to primary production ones — and extinguishing native title.
Still, Pat Dodson, chair of the Council for Aboriginal Reconciliation, said the concept of ‘terra nullius’ had found a new political structure under the Howard government though it had been struck down by the High Court.
Going beyond legal debate, he says the real problem lies in many Australians’ attitudes on the issue of native communities. “It’s a fundamental problem for the Government to accept the Aboriginal right to negotiate,” observed Dodson. “You can’t have a right to property if you don’t have any say over what happens to it.”
“In other circumstances, conservative politicians and business leaders would have flocked to the opposite side of the argument,” said Dr Henry Reynolds, an eminent historian with Queensland’s James Cookes University. “They would normally applaud the centuries-old battle of the common law to protect property rights against the State.”
But “the problem in the Wik case was that the wrong people had acquired rights to land”, he said.
Added Reynolds: “What they balk at is that they will have to deal with indigenous Australians as equals for the first time in 200 years, that Aborigines can now come to the negotiation table with something of substance beyond their sense of moral outrage.”