Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Headlines, Population

VIETNAM: Reluctantly, Asylum Seekers Head Home

Nguyen Phan Phuong

HANOI, May 9 1997 (IPS) - As the deadline nears for the June 30 clearing by Hong Kong of its refugee holding camps, the Hanoi government and United Nations officials are stepping up a campaign to convince Vietnamese asylum seekers to return home.

The repatriation of Vietnamese asylum seekers is expected to accelerate in the next several weeks, as the Chinese government has said it wants first-asylum camps in Hong Kong closed when it regains control over the territory on the midnight of June 30.

Some 2,600 Vietnamese asylum seekers still remain in Hong Kong’s crowded camps, and many doubt that all can be sent back to the country by the June 30 handover.

The issue of asylum seekers traces its roots to the mass exodus of more than 250,000 Vietnamese after the fall of Saigon in 1975, which triggered an international effort to shelter and then resettle these ‘boat people’ in western countries.

But unlike the waves of ‘boat people’ that washed up on shores of neighbouring countries, most of the Vietnamese who fled in the late 80s were economic migrants and not political refugees. Many view them as illegal immigrants.

Screening for genuine political refugees eligible for resettlement in third countries was adopted under the 1989 Comprehensive Plan of Action. Since then, countries hosting Indochinese refugee camps, Vietnam and the U.N. have been trying to persuade asylum seekers to return to Vietnam.

At first, only a trickle volunteered to return home, since most asylum-seekers were still hoping for resettlement in the west. This led to their forcible repatriation from camps in Hong Kong and the Philippines amid protests and violence.

But the numbers of returnees began picking up as the prospect of returning to Vietnam appeared inevitable.

As of last month, 109,199 Vietnamese have returned here from camps in Indonesia, Hong Kong, Singapore, the Philippines, Malaysia and Japan, Thailand. All were adjudged economic migrants.

Of that number, narly nine-tenths or 94,241 persons returned voluntarily while the rest were forced back, said the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR).

Now, Vietnam is trying to convince remaining asylum seekers that coming home is not as bad as they feared. Asian diplomats often point out that the country is undergoing an economic boom.

In late April, Sergio Vieira de Mello, assistant U.N. High Commissioner for Refugees, told a press conference here that there have been “no instances” of persecution of returning Vietnamese boat people reported by its monitoring teams.

The Vietnamese government continues to adhere fully to its commitments, ensuring that returnees enjoy amnesty concerning their illegal departure from the country, he says.

Hopefully, he added, the saga of the Vietnamese ‘boat people’, one of the most tragic examples of human suffering in the region’s recent history, is finally coming to an end.

Since 1989, UNHCR has been monitoring individual returnees, in some cases visiting them repeatedly, to ensure that Vietnam keeps its promise of amnesty for those who left the country illegally. Monitoring activities by its eight international staff, fluent in Vietnamese, will continue at least for the next two years.

But while the UNHCR efforts are laudable, Human Rights Watch/Asia said in a recent report that returning to Vietnam is not without risk. It details several cases of harassment and intimidation of returnees after they resettled in Vietnam.

It reported that in September 1995, a weekly paper published by the Hai Phong Security Police said officials had identified 79 political suspects among 1,432 recent returnees.

Asylum seekers who have military backgrounds or were involved in anti-communist activities while in Hong Kong camps have also been harassed upon their return to Vietnam, Human Rights Watch/Asia added.

One returnee said the police often asked him about his involvement in New Democracy, an anti-communist political group in Hong Kong’s camps. “Local police often come to ‘see’ us. Living becomes relatively complicated,’ he wrote in a June 1996 letter quoted by the Human Rights Watch report.

At special risk are Vietnamese with security backgrounds who have been interviewed by the Hong Kong Security Branch or U.S. defense officials about Vietnam’s command structure or internal security.

Often, Vietnamese officials find out who have been interviewed, creating a “certain degree of danger for those asylum seekers who have been involved in these types of activities”, the Human Rights Watch report pointed out.

In one case, a father in Vietnam wrote to his son in a Hong Kong camp, saying public security officers searched their home and put them under surveillance after learning he had provided documents to the Hong Kong Security Branch.

At the very least, these suggest “the need for more vigilant monitoring”, Human Rights Watch said.

UNHCR officials said majority of the returnees have resumed their normal lives in what they called a “truly remarkable achievement”.

In 1996, UNHCR supported 129 reintegration projects at a cost of 2.8 million U.S. dollars and is spending 5.3 million dollars for this purpose in 1997. UNHCR has spent 59 million dollars for reintegration over the past seven years.

Catherine Bertrand, UNHCR chief representative in Hanoi, says the ‘boat people’ issue was largely resolved by the end of 1996. Indeed, last year had marked the winding down of much of the network serving Indochinese asylum seekers.

The UNHCR had cut funding for camps in South-east Asia by June 30 last year, leading to the closure throughout 1996 of these camps — except in Hong Kong. However, the territory’s major camp called Whitehead detention centre, was closed in January 1997.

And despite China’s June 30 deadline, more than a third of the 2,600 Vietnamese still there have not yet been cleared for return by the Hanoi government, officials say. Even those Vietnamese found to be refugees may not be resettled fast enough in time for Hong Kong’s handover.

This means that come midnight of June 30, a good number of Vietnamese asylum seekers are likely to still be in Hong Kong. Human Rights Watch says this opens up an uncertain future for them, since how Hong Kong’s new rulers will deal with last ‘boat people’ remains to be seen.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags