Friday, November 20, 2026
Prangtip Daorueng
- When the government announced last year its policy allowing migrant workers from Indochina into Thailand to help ease the labour shortage, little did it realise that it would spawn new problems.
The policy received its share of criticism from local labour unions then, although it was also hailed by some as a pragmatic step to fill the labour shortfall which is expected to worsen as the country moves up the industrial ladder.
With the influx of legal and illegal labourers, however, even Labour Minister Chatchai Eaesakul is now hinting that the policy may have to be reviewed.
The fact that Indochinese workers are willing to receive lower salaries in order to survive has put many Thai workers out of job, says Dr Kritiya Archawanitkul of the Mahidol University.
“The policy has provided an alternative to employers and many of them choose foreign workers because they don’t have to pay as much as they pay for Thai workers and they don’t need to think about welfare as well,” she said.
“Although this is against the law, none of the Indochinese workers who really want a job and a better life dare complain,” she added.
The Thai government, facing labour shortages in factories, agriculture and construction, and prospects that the problem would further aggravate, implemented limited legal status to a large number of foreign labourers in the country.
Effective last September, immigrant workers from neighbouring Burma, Cambodia and Laos were allowed to work in 43 provinces for two years.
The policy allows Thai employers and companies to screen, register and monitor foreign labourers in areas of work that include manual labour in agriculture, fisheries, construction, mining, domestic shipping and light industry.
But foreign workers should not exceed 50 per cent of the total workforce of a particular factory or business.
The stop-gap measure gained the partial endorsement of the International Labour Organisation (ILO) subregional coordinator for Asia, Guy Thijs, who said then that the move appeared to be in the right direction. “I think it’s a good solution,”
But he also warned that since there was “no minimum wage, there is no social security system provided…there’s no system to provide any protection.”
Sriprai Nonsee, a labour advocate with a non-government organisation says most foreign workers don’t get paid the daily minimum wage of 157 bahts (six dollars). “Each is paid only 50 bahts a day but they don’t complain because they don’t know the language and they are afraid of losing their jobs,” she said.
Chongrak Supajit, vice-president of a labour union in Prapadang, an industrial province near Bangkok, which was against the government hiring scheme, said their opposition was proving to be valid.
He said it is difficult to document these workers because many are hiding in small non-registered factories that employ less than 10 people. “A lot of foreign workers are working in these small factories under bad working conditions.”
It is not clear how many foreign labourers have actually come to Thailand after it relaxed its employment rules. Estimates of immigrant workers in the country range from 700,000 to two million.
It is not known either how many Thais have been displaced by illegal and legal foreign labourers, although in some places, companies are laying off workers who have reached a particular age bracket and replacing them with younger and relatively cheaper labour.
Textile workers between 45 and 50 years old and who have been working from 10 to 20 years are being targetted for mass layoffs, says labour leader Arunee Sritoe. This particular group makes up about half the one-million-strong textile industry workforce.
“They are always the first target when a factory has to cut cost. Although many textile factories put the retirement age at 60, I have never seen anybody survive after 45,” says Arunee. “Workers (their age) can no longer find new jobs and some have no social welfare programme to depend on.”
Employers point to the recent slump in the export sector, which in turn slowed economic growth, as the reason behind the retrenchment. But labour experts say that although slower growth affects profitability, the decision to lay off is more a reflection of management’s attitude towards its workers.
Dr Nikon Chandrawitoon, an authority on labour issues, says the retrenchment policy is not only affecting factory workers, but white-collar workers as well.
He cites the case of some banks. “Banking is a very stable business here and they have never laid off workers until recently. It is not about trying to help the business continue. It is about trying to pay less by replacing old workers with younger ones,” he said.
Statistics from the Labour Court show an increase in the number of cases filed in January by employees challenging their retrenchment.
Dr Niphon Pourpongsathon, vice-president of the Thailand Development Research Centre (TDRI) agrees with the observation that companies are using the economic slowdown as scapegoat. The retrenchment policy, he says, reveals management’s basic attitude towards labour.
“If employees don’t pay attention to workers’ welfare and don’t know how to deal with them, this might lead to aggressive reaction from them. That will then affect the economy.”