Development & Aid, Headlines, Latin America & the Caribbean, Population

ECUADOR-INDIGENOUS: Ransom or Indemnisation?

Mario Gonzalez

QUITO, Feb 25 1997 (IPS) - An agreement between Ecuador’s Achuar indigenous people and an Argentine oil firm has established the precedent that companies interested in operating in the country’s Amazon region are to negotiate directly with indigenous groups living there.

But the Achuar decided to apply a peculiar form of pressure against the company, kidnapping last week five experts of the U.S. firm Walsh, contracted by the San Jorge General Fuel Company (CGC) of Argentina to carry out studies on the environmental impact in the stage of seismic prospecting. The group is demanding a ransom – which they term an “indemnisation” – for the experts’ release.

“We cannot talk about a kidnapping,” said Marco Hinojosa, general commandant of the Ecuadorian police, who has offered to mediate. “It is more like an illegal retention.”

The indigenous group sees the move as an act of “justice,” because the experts had entered their territory without permission, through the use of subterfuge. “They told us they were tourists who wanted to carry out a study to keep the oil companies from entering our territory,” said Santiago Kawarim, president of the Interprovincial Federation of the Achuar Nationality of Ecuador.

“We acted in accordance with the principles established in the January indigenous convention,” in which “it was agreed to prohibit the entry of strangers into our territory,” because “that is the only way to defend our environment and our ancestral right over it,” he added. “We are determined to assert our rights.”

The indigenous group has released two of the experts, but refuses to free the other three until their demands – two million dollars in compensation and access to the environmental and anthropological studies – are met.

Ricardo Nicolas, coordinator of the CGC, said the company was willing to pay one million dollars – but as a ransom, not an indemnisation.

The group will also have access to the studies, and the firm has promised to meet with the indigenous groups before starting to operate in their territory, Kawarim said.

Seismic studies are carried out prior to the excavation of wells, through underground explosions that cause severe damage to the environment, Pablo Ortiz, a consultant with the Forests, Trees and Rural Communities programme of the U.N. Food and Agriculture Organisation, told IPS.

The demands of the Achuar were a simple “extortion,” said Nicolas, who claimed that the studies being realised by Walsh showed no damage to the environment or the indigenous communities.

But the firm has signed an accord with the communities stipulating that they are to be fully informed of its operations in the area. The CGC also financed the travel costs of the indigenous leaders who met with company officials in the village of Shaime. The prospecting has been suspended until another meeting is held between company representatives and the indigenous leaders.

Seven of Ecuador’s 10 indigenous groups live in the Amazon region: the Achuar, Cofane, Huaorani, Quichua, Secoya, Shuar and Shion.

“These people have suffered the invasion of their territory for centuries, by people seeking to reap the wealth of the Amazon. First the gold diggers, then the logging companies and finally the oil consortiums,” said Ortiz, the author of studies on environmental conflicts in the region.

“The historic struggle of these people has always been for the right to their own territory,” he underlined.

In November 1996, 112 indigenous communities filed a lawsuit in the United States against the oil giant Texaco, which was thrown out of the courts in late 1996. The indigenous group was demanding eight million dollars in compensation for environmental and social damages, and the reparation of environmental degradation caused by 25 years of oil prospecting.

The 30,000 indigenous claimants are still awaiting a response from the U.S. court to their petition to reopen the case.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags