Friday, November 20, 2026
Diego Cevallos
- Mexico’s 10 million ethnic Indians remain poor and continue to suffer discrimination three years into President Vicente Fox’s administration, whose policies towards indigenous people have merely taken a welfare approach, a high-level United Nations official said Wednesday.
At the end of a 17-day official visit to Mexico, the U.N. special rapporteur on the situation of the human rights and fundamental freedoms of indigenous people, Rodolfo Stavenhagen, urged the Mexican government to design a comprehensive policy towards indigenous people that goes beyond mere rhetoric.
Mexico is the Latin American nation with the largest number of indigenous people, in absolute terms.
The country’s Indians have extremely poor human development indicators, something that Fox – the first president to come from a party other than the Institutional Revolutionary Party (PRI) in seven decades – promised to change when he took office in December 2000.
In March 2002, the president presented a programme titled ”towards a new relationship”, which he said would pull the country’s ethnic groups out of their destitution through policies that would leave behind the ”paternalistic” approach traditionally taken by Mexican governments.
But the programme’s effectiveness has been called into question, and Stavenhagen said the government’s social policies for indigenous people remain welfare-oriented.
Fox, however, said on Wednesday that official reports have found that the proportion of Mexicans without an adequate diet fell from 24.2 to 20.3 percent of the population of 100 million between 2000 and 2002, thanks to his government’s social policies.
The president also pointed out that the reduction seen in the proportion of the population suffering from hunger was achieved mainly in rural areas, where indigenous people are concentrated.
In addition, he said the percentage of Mexicans with incomes that are insufficient ”for the development of their capacities and ability to overcome poverty” was reduced from 31.9 to 26.5 percent in the same period.
”Our social policies have left paternalism and clientelism behind, and today operate under a formula of shared responsibility,” said Fox.
More than half of all Mexicans, and nearly all of the country’s indigenous people, live below the poverty line.
That reality persists despite the ideals of the agrarian revolution of the early 20th century, which held up the campesinos or peasants, and among them the country’s Indians, as the symbol of national pride, and under which costly social development plans targetting them were launched.
Stavenhagen warned that if the situation remained unchanged, there would be an increased risk of outbreaks of violence, such as the brief fighting that broke out in early 1994 when the Zapatista National Liberation Army (EZLN) – a poorly armed mainly indigenous insurgent group – first appeared in the impoverished southern Mexican state of Chiapas.
Next year, the U.N. official will present a report on his visit to Mexico to the U.N. Human Rights Commission, which could issue recommendations for the government to follow.
But Stavenhagen merely corroborated the existence of a reality that is no news to Mexico’s politicians – ”the fact that an entire social group is excluded from the country’s development, and faces total discrimination,” Luis Hernández, a member of the Zapatista National Liberation Front, which groups EZLN sympathisers, told IPS.
According to official statistics, 75 percent of the country’s indigenous people have not completed primary school – double the proportion among the population at large – and 44.7 percent are illiterate – four times the national average.
Infant mortality among Indians stands at 48.3 for every 1,000 live births, against 28.2 per 1,000 at a national level, and 73.2 percent of indigenous children are short for their age, compared to 50.5 percent of Mexican children at large.
In addition, nearly 60 percent of the homes of indigenous people lack piped water, compared to 15.7 percent of households nationwide.
”It is obvious that indigenous people and campesinos are no better off, or are even worse off, than before,” said Hernández, who questioned the statistics presented by Fox on the reduction of poverty in rural areas.
The conditions faced by indigenous people in Mexico are dire, said Stavenhagen, who expressed particular concern about the existence of a number of simmering conflicts over land between different indigenous groups, which have in the past triggered acts of violence, including mass killings of campesinos, and could do so again.
The Fox administration recognises 14 ”red zones” where land disputes are smoldering, mainly over questions of property boundaries. All of the areas are in parts of the country basically inhabited by indigenous people.
Another issue that worries Stavenhagen is the ”failure” of the constitutional reforms on indigenous rights approved by Congress in 2001.
Although the reforms were approved after the EZLN leadership staged a spectacular visit to the capital to press for their ratification, the modifications that were introduced by Congress left the rebel group and other indigenous organisations unsatisfied.
The reforms included the recognition of indigenous peoples’ rights to autonomy and self-determination, but within limits based on ”national interests.”
The EZLN squashed any possibility of returning to the negotiating table, complaining that the version of the constitutional amendment that was approved made a mockery of the San Andrés accords on indigenous rights and culture signed in 1996 by the Zapatistas and the government of Ernesto Zedillo (1994-2000).
The San Andrés accords were the only agreements reached before the peace talks were broken off in 1996.
Most of the EZLN’s less than 10,000 members are unarmed, and the group remains holed up in the remote jungles and mountains of Chiapas. An armed truce between the rebels and the army reached in early 1994 after just two weeks of fighting remains in effect.
Hernández said that many Mexicans hope that in the wake of the visit by the U.N. special rapporteur, the government and the rest of the country’s political actors will take seriously the need to design an integral policy towards indigenous people.
For now, Indians remain the poorest of the poor in this Latin American country, and Fox has failed to live up to his promises, which were similar to those of his PRI predecessors, to pull them out of their destitution. (END/IPS/LA/HD/PR/TRA-SO SW/DC/MP/03)