Headlines, Latin America & the Caribbean

MEDIA-BRAZIL: Human Rights Want Less Violence on TV

Mario Osava

RIO DE JANEIRO, Nov 22 1998 (IPS) - Increasing violence and sensationalist reporting on TV have triggered a backlash in Brazil that could lead to a mechanism for imposing restrictions on programming and encouraging respect for human rights on TV.

Reality programming, replete with street fights, domestic violence, sex, adultery and physical mutilations, was the last straw. It led National Secretary of Human Rights Jose Gregori to start a dialogue with TV stations last week in an effort to raise the quality of programmes and reduce their violence content.

Gregori explained that he was not seeking censorship or a code of ethics, but rather some kind of self-regulation “by each station” – instead of by media associations – modelled on Italy’s successful experience. The aim is to prevent abuses and keep broadcasters from resorting to increasing sensationalism in their mad scramble for ratings.

Gregori wants stations to adopt a quality manual for internal control, or an ombudsman.

His initiative came in response to daily complaints against the depths to which local programming has sunk.

The protests became even louder in the wake of the high ratings achieved by ‘Ratinho’ (Little Mouse – the nickname of popular TV host Carlos Massa) with a programme packed with explicit images of violence, such as pictures of a woman with her throat slit, and deformed people.

Ratinho’s overwhelming success gave rise to imitations, as well as a major dispute over his contract. It was reported that his transfer to the Brazilian Television System (SBT) network cost around 36 million dollars.

The reaction to Ratinho’s sensationalist approach was bolstered when he was found last month to have hired extras to act out husbands bursting in and finding their wives in the arms of another man – scenes that were presented as real.

Prosecutor Clilton Guimaraes dos Santos sought a court injunction against Ratinho’s show, and a 29-million-dollar fine.

But as an alternative sanction, he suggested that it be made mandatory for 30 minutes of the two-hour programme to be dedicated to educational news reports on human rights, the environment, consumer defence and drug prevention.

An initial measure taken by the Ministry of Justice was to rate the programme inappropriate for children under 14, which thus delayed its broadcast time from 20:30 to 21:00 local time.

The Brazilian Association of Television and Radio Stations threatened to expell the SBT if it was proven that the association’s code of ethics was violated by the fake reports.

And Senator Arturo da Tavola, chairman of the Senate’s Education Commission, proposed that the SBT’s station contract not be renewed if the network continued to transgress “the ethical and social values of individuals and the family.”

Regular TV programming in general is fighting hard to hold on to viewers in the face of the exodus of the wealthier strata to cable TV, recently introduced in Brazil.

Violence is widespread. A U.N. study found that in 71 hours of cartoons aired by six Brazilian stations in August, a total of 1,432 crimes, or 20 an hour, were shown. Thirty percent of them were murders, and 57 percent attacks which left someone injured.

Nevertheless, research indicates that televised violence does not necessarily stimulate children to become violent. “They know to distinguish fiction from reality,” said Elza Dias Pacheco, who coordinated a study on the issue by the University of Sao Paulo’s Laboratory of Research on Childhood and Communication.

Gregori acknowledged that TV did not directly foment violence, but he lamented that it was doing even less to reduce it. As a public service and according to the constitution, broadcasters are bound to promote civic culture and human rights, he pointed out.

But dialogue is not easy. SBT artistic director Eduardo Lafon insisted that “strong images, which touch on feelings,” are indispensable to mobilise assistance for the poor, for example.

Lafon cited the case of a woman whose jealous husband had left her blind. He appearance on Ratinho’s programme not only brought record ratings, but enabled her to obtain donations that would have been impossible through any other means, he argued.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags