Environment, Headlines, North America

ENVIRONMENT-HEALTH: Concerns Linger Over Pesticide Trade

Danielle Knight

WASHINGTON, Sep 21 1998 (IPS) - International environmental groups, are concerned that some hazardous substances may slip through the net of a new international agreement to control the trade in highly dangerous pesticides and other chemicals.

Some groups even believe that the U.N. Convention on the Trade in Hazardous Chemicals and Pesticides does not go far enough, and want to ban the substances altogether.

“It’s good to see that governments are committed to making trade in hazardous chemicals a more transparent, informed and consensual process,” says Clifton Curtis, director of the Washington-based World Wildlife Fund’s toxics campaign. “But, the outright elimination of hazardous chemicals remains a big gap.”

Earlier this month in the Netherlands, 100 governments signed a binding agreement, known as Prior Informed Consent or the Convention on the Trade in Hazardous Chemicals and Pesticides. The treaty aims to provide governments with information about these hazardous chemicals, and allow them to decide whether imports of the chemicals should continue.

The treaty aims to reduce the threat to the environment and to the health of millions of farmers worldwide from the many pesticides which are banned or severely restricted in industrialised countries but are still marketed and used in developing countries.

Currently, the distribution of pesticides is not regulated in most developing countries.

“The infrastructure to control these toxic compounds is insufficient and there is a shortage of trained farmers and workers,” says Jacques Diouf, the Director-General of the United Nations Food and Agriculture Organisation (FAO).

“The Convention is an important step forward in helping countries to decide whether they wish to use and import extremely hazardous substances,” says Diouf. ” Pesticides should not threaten the welfare, health or lives of farmers.”

The pesticides regulated by the new agreement have been associated with acute poisonings sometimes resulting in death, sterility, cancer, and neurological damage, according to the FAO. Wildlife is similarly affected by the same chemicals.

A voluntary consent procedure for pesticides has been operating since the late 1980s, based on FAO and United Nation Environment Programme guidelines. But this new convention – to be jointly operated by the FAO and the UN Environment Programme – will provide a legally binding agreement. It will enter into force after it is ratified by 50 countries.

Under the treaty, a pesticide or chemical must be banned or severely restricted for health or environmental reasons in at least two countries in different regions in order to be included on the list given to developing countries. The pesticide will then only be allowed to enter the country if the importing country agrees.

Other pesticides will be subject to the same procedure when it is evident that the chemical is too dangerous to be used in developing countries. Nations are also obliged, but not required, to stop national production of those hazardous substances.

So far, the Convention covers a list of 27 chemicals and pesticides, such as DDT, aldrin, and lindane. More are likely to be added in the future.

The worldwide Pesticide Action Network, Consumers International, the Pesticides Trust and other organisations – who worked with closely with governments throughout the negotiation process – praise the Convention and are calling for its immediate implementation.

“The need is urgent,” says Barbar Dinham of the London-based Pesticides Trust. “There is pressure on global agriculture to increase production, and developing countries frequently provide a market for older, cheaper and hazardous pesticides.

“This Convention will alert governments to health and environmental concerns and help them stop unwanted imports.”

But the Convention will not be itself stop production and use of hazardous pesticides, she says. “Making Prior Informed Consent work is the real challenge which starts now,” says Dinham.

More training and better information is the minimum starting point, she says. “Workers and farmers must know what they are using, and the agrochemical industry must provide easily accessible information.”

Getting the treaty to work in practice and not just on paper will be especially tricky, adds World Wildlife Fund, because often developing countries lack effective regulatory regimes.

While applauding the treaty and pressing for immediate implementation, groups say the Convention may allow some hazardous to slip through the Prior Informed Consent process.

In order to be included on the list of hazardous pesticides, the agreement requires that detailed information must be compiled on specific incidents in developing countries. Organisations say that often this type of information is difficult to gather becuase many farmers and regulatory authorities are unaware of what pesticides they are using since they are often sold in unmarked containers.

In many African countries, says Dinham, poison control centres have not been established and collection information on such incidents is “virtually impossible.”

Groups are also urging the FAO and UN Environment Programme to review on a regular basis the criteria for including pesticides on the list to make sure that the process is effective. The World Wildlife Fund says that, even if the Prior Informed Consent details are eventually ironed out, this trade approach to regulating pesticides and other chemicals is useless because developing countries are now producing the chemicals banned by industrialised countries.

“Beyond these Prior Informed Consent-focused concerns,” says Curtis, “what is critically needed, and long overdue, is a global commitment to phasing out and eliminating the most hazardous chemicals and pesticides that are being produced, used and traded in developing, as well as developed, regions of the world.”

“Governments should be taking action now, to get rid of chemicals with endocrine disrupting, bioaccumulative or persistent properties, rather than talking and delaying those decisions while the impacts only get worse,” he says.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags