Active Citizens, Civil Society, Environment, Headlines

COMMODITIES-UKRAINE/RUSSIA: Slugging It Out In Sugar Trade Standoff

Andrei Ivanov and Judith Perera

MOSCOW/LONDON, Jul 29 1998 (IPS) - Next week’s massive import tax hikes on the sugar trade with Russia will do nothing to sweeten a bitter standoff between Russian processors and Ukrainian exporters, who will be exempted from Saturday’s scheduled rises.

Russian import taxes are to rise from a token one percent to 75 percent on raw sugar and from 25 percent to 45 percent for processed white sugar, effective from Saturday, Aug. 1, and in force until Dec. 31.

But the hikes will not apply to an expected influx of cheap Ukrainian refined sugar in the last quarter of 1998. This is due to a sugar trade deal signed last November under which Ukraine was given clearance to export 600,000 tonnes a year of white sugar, duty-free to Russia.

The deal was intended to end a political row that blew up when Moscow imposed a 25 percent import levy on Ukrainian sugar in May 1997, after accusing Kiev of dumping cheap sugar on its markets and threatening its domestic processing industry.

However the conditions of the November deal are not clear and the Russian Sugar Producer’s Union now plans to ask the Russian authorities to review the terms of the agreement unless Ukraine exports sugar to Russia evenly throughout the year rather than in a single block at the end of the year.

The agreement reportedly envisaged shipments of 100,000 tonnes in the first and fourth quarters and 200,000 tonnes in the second and third quarters. But so far none of the five Russian firms that won the right to import the sugar have signed agreements with Ukrainian suppliers.

Tension built up when it became clear that Ukraine would not be able to export any sugar before September — precisely the time when Russia begins to harvest its own sugar beet, which provides badly needed work for the domestic refining industry.

Russian producers are concerned that Ukrainian imports in September could lead to a sugar glut as well as to a crisis in the Russian refining sector.

However, according to Russian sugar analyst Sergei Gudoshnikov at the International Sugar Organisation in London, even if the Ukrainian sugar arrives in a single batch, there should be no real problem. “I don’t think the situation is so serious for the Russian market,” he says.

He believes it is almost certain that Ukraine will not be able to fulfil the 600,000 tonne quota from last year’s crop and will need to wait for the new crop to arrive. But even so, the impact on Russia will be limited, he insists.

This is a view shared by other analysts. Chris Pack, an analyst at Czarnikow in London, says that even if Ukraine exports its full quota, it will have little effect on the Russian market as it represents only a small proportion of total sugar imports.

“Russia is a deficit area and 600,000 tonnes is not a huge amount compared with total annual imports.” This year’s import requirement is estimated at 4.25 million tonnes.

Ukraine, on the other hand produces more sugar than it needs.

Last year it produced two million tonnes of sugar from 17 million tonnes of beet. Domestic demand has been measured at 1.5-1.7 million tonnes, and it is expected to harvest 21.4 million tonnes of beet this year.

Russia and Ukraine are neighbouring states with similar-sized crops, and the harvests are bound to coincide. However, Ukraine need not sell its quota immediately but could store and deliver it when it was needed. “It’s a management problem,” says Pack, who did however envisage possible disputes over who should finance the storage.

Gudoshnikov believes the problem is largely academic as price differences could well place a obstacle in the way of the imports.

The domestic sugar price in Ukraine is currently 530 dollars per tonne, considerably higher than in Russia, where prices have fallen from 500 dollars per tonne at the beginning of the year to below 450 dollars per tonne now.

Ukrainian leaders are aware of this potential problem. Farm Minister Boris Supikhanov has warned that Russia may not take up its quota of 600,000 tonnes of duty-free Ukrainian sugar in 1998 because of its high price relative to global market levels.

Ukraine is currently ready to ship 300,000 tonnes of sugar at 540 dollars per tonne, he says. But a lower price would lead to substantial losses.

World sugar prices currently average at 450 to 460 dollars per tonne and Russia is unlikely to pay much more for any imports with white sugar market futures are already falling in value in anticipation of next week’s Russian import tax rises.

Russia is the main importer of sugar in a market already depressed by abundant supplies and a lack of large buyers. The economic crisis in Asia has cut imports by China and India, and Russia’s tax plans have sent prices spiralling downwards again.

Raw world sugar futures for October delivery have fallen 5.33 percent to 8.51 cents a pound.

There are other potential buyers of Ukrainian sugar such as Uzbekistan or even neighbouring Belarus. But it is also unlikely that they will be prepare to pay above world prices.

Vyacheslav Sipper, head of sugar production at the Belarusian Agriculture Ministry says Belarus will increase imports of raw sugar this year by nearly 50 percent, in face of serious shortages.

“We will raise imports of raw sugar to 300,000 tonnes from 210,000 tonnes last year in view of the very high demand for sugar among the population and (supply) difficulties this year,” he says, although it is not clear how these imports will be financed.

At present, sugar is available only in a limited number of markets where free prices are tolerated. But few Belarusians, who are paid an average of 50 dollars a month, can afford to buy their basic food there.

Sugar is an essential ingredient for preserving vegetables and fruit, grown by millions of people for the winter in small summer allotment gardens. The economy is still run Soviet-style and people carry the notorious ‘just-in-case’ bags in case subsidised sugar or other goods suddenly appear on shelves in state shops.

For the present, the laws of supply and demand do not seem to be working in the states of the former USSR, at least as far as sugar is concerned. Ukraine has more than it needs. Russia and Belarus need more than they have. But the price is just not right.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags