Sunday, November 22, 2026
Andrei Ivanov
- With world aluminium prices at their lowest for four years, Russia’s aluminium industry is facing serious problems with some experts warning of a possible collapse.
The cost of producing a ton of aluminium in Russia is now around 1,400 dollars, but it has been trading on the London Metal Exchange at less than 1,300 per ton recently and was only barely bettering that price Monday.
“They are selling below their costs,” says Svetlana Smirnova, a metals analyst at United Financial Group in Moscow. “If this continues for another six months, we will see the collapse of the industry,” she warns.
The industry needs to cut costs, but this requires radical and expensive restructuring, which can only be financed by borrowing. But with interest rates in Russia currently running at 80 percent, this is impossible for most enterprises.
At a meeting last week with deputies of the lower house of the Russian Parliament (State Duma), major Russian aluminium producers decided they needed more state support in face of falling prices.
According to German Tkachenko, vice-president of Sibirsky Alyuminiy group, the Duma deputies were told that the industry needed changes in legislation on Value Added Tax which scrapped an exemption on tolling operations. He explained that it now takes 30 to 40 days to get back the money paid as VAT.
At present, Russian smelters import the raw material, alumina, process it for its owner, pay the VAT and are then reimbursed after the metal crosses the border. But even this concession will stop at the end of 1998.
Smirnova points out that when Prime Minister Sergei Kiriyenko cancelled a proposed decree on VAT exemption this month, he said Russian smelters would not need the tax break in future as the government planned to bring down the refinancing rate by the end of the year.
But instead of falling, interest rates have continued to rise. reaching 150 percent before settling back to 80 percent.
As a radical solution, Russia’s aluminium producers are pressing for Western-style vertical integration of aluminium companies which would be responsible for the whole process from production to sales.
“We could increase our revenues by selling finished products inside the country instead of rolled metal,” says Tkachenko.
But there is no doubt that the sector also needed more real investment, he said, adding that lower rail tariffs for aluminium would also help.
Smelters are hoping for price rises, but must also restructure operations urgently. Prices will go up eventually, says Tatyana Nikolskaya, metals analyst at Pioneer Securities in Moscow, “but the question is can they implement cost cuts before facing huge losses by the end of the year”.
Companies can reduce production costs if they restructure distribution systems and marketing but this requires funds and their very survival may depend on finding this money, explains Smirnova.
Some companies may be able to arrange direct sales contracts with foreign buyers which would enable them to raise loans from foreign banks secured by these contracts. But for others, finding the necessary finance could be difficult.
As well as low prices and high costs, the industry also faces penalties for its appalling environmental record, points out Nikolskaya. “Because the technology is old, it causes significant pollution, and (the smelters) have to pay high penalties for this.”
But despite the mounting problems, many analysts believe Russia’s aluminium industry will limp on.
“There have been predictions about the collapse of the industry ever since the break up of the Soviet Union, but in spite of this production has increased over the last five or six years,” says metals analyst Adam Rowley of Macquarie Equities.
Some of the larger smelters were still making money, although others had genuine problems. But even those in dire straits will continue to produce.
“Smelters losing money will continue to battle on for as long as they can, if anything they’ll try to produce a little bit more. They need to keep cash flow going and foreign revenues coming in just to survive,” Rowley says.
Russia exported 2.7 million tons of aluminium outside the Commonwealth of Independent States last year, up from 2.62 million tons in 1996.
Analysts expect exports to remain steady this year, although revenue will fall because of the low price. Most plants have sufficient stocks of raw materials to be able to survive at least in the short term.
Tkachenko says producers want the government to defend Russian interests during the expected privatisation of raw material producing plants in the Commonwealth of Independent States.
Pavlodar in Kazakhstan and Mikolayiv in Ukraine produce alumina used by the Sayansk aluminium plant, the third biggest aluminium producer in Russia and part of the Sibirsky Alyuminiy group.
Last month, Russia’s Krasnoyarsk, Bratsk, Novokuznetsk and Volgograd aluminium smelters announced the formation of a consortium to bid for a stake in Ukraine’s Mikolayiv. Sibirsky Alyuminiy group had declared its intention to bid in April.
The consortium intends to acquire 31 percent of the plant, which has a production capacity of a million tons of alumina per year and accounts for 20 percent of the Russian market.
Russian smelters need to secure vital supplies of the raw material, which is not produced in sufficient quantities inside Russia itself.
Konstantin Chernyshev, senior analyst at Rinako Plus, says this is a logical step. “With Russia lacking large capacities for alumina, smelters have to be connected with large producers elsewhere.”
The smelters may also be joining forces to ensure no single company gains a hold over the scarce alumina supplies, explains Andrei Kozlov, a metal analyst at Aton Capital Group.
To some extent the large smelters seem to thrive on adversity, say some. “What we’ve seen is that smelters have proved a lot more resilient than I think anyone would have predicted,” says metals analyst Adam Rowley.
They will, most probably weather the present storm. But restructuring may have to wait a few more years.
Andrei Ivanov
- With world aluminium prices at their lowest for four years, Russia’s aluminium industry is facing serious problems with some experts warning of a possible collapse.
(more…)