Headlines, Middle East & North Africa

MIDDLE EAST: Netanyahu’s City Borders Plan Angers Palestinians

Deborah Horan

JERUSALEM, Jul 2 1998 (IPS) - Israel’s plan to create an ‘umbrella municipality’ for Jerusalem that would extend to West Bank settlements has driven another nail into the coffin of an already dying peace process, if Palestinian public opinion is any measure.

On Wednesday, Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat, his patience worn, lashed out at Israel with unusually strong language, depicting the plan to extend some municipal powers to two major Jewish settlements as a “battle for life and death over the city”.

“There will be no peace, no security, no stability without the return of liberated Jerusalem, the eternal capital of a Palestinian state, whether they like it or not,” Arafat said. Palestinians want the eastern half of Jerusalem, where 180,000 of them live, to be the capital of an independent state.

“The Palestinian leadership has no more patience and our people have no more patience,” he said. “All that’s left for us to do is to defend Jerusalem in whatever way we can.”

Yet Palestinian public opinion seems already to have soured on peace. A poll released by the Center for Palestine Research and Studies, a respected West Bank-based think tank, found that half of all Palestinians support the use of violence against Israel. In Sept. 1997, just over one-third did.

The change, say analysts, is due to increased frustration felt by Palestinians over the stalemated peace process. Palestinians have waited for months for a second Israeli troop withdrawal from West Bank territory, possibly as high as 15 percent.

Each week, Israeli leaders have intimated that the withdrawal was imminent, only to deflate expectations. The latest target date seems to be the end of July.

Paradoxically, 68 percent of Palestinians still back the peace process, possibly because they believe it will lead to a declaration of independence on May 5, 1999, after the interim peace deal with Israel expired.

The plan to expand the city borders, unveiled by Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu last month, prompted swift condemnation from Arab and European capitals. A U.S. State Department spokesman called the move a “provocative step”. Three days later, Israel’s Cabinet voted in favour of it.

Arafat, under increasing pressure from a restless public, has called on the Arab League to convene to discuss the plan and has asked the UN Security Council to take up the matter. Reports in the local Israeli press said the U.S. and Britain were working to prevent a resolution condemning Israel to avoid having to cast a veto.

Arafat, noticeably agitated, spent Monday going over maps of the Israeli expansion plan in Gaza, later calling it a “cancerous settlement policy”.

Some Palestinian leaders, notably Hatem Abdel Qader, a legislative council member from Jerusalem, called on Arafat to take concrete steps to thwart Israel’s plans, including an alternative Arab city council.

The maps show a plan to expand Jerusalem’s boundaries considerably to the west and south, in Israel proper, to annex several affluent suburbs. That part of plan has been known for weeks, with most residents of the suburbs opposed to the move since it would likely mean higher taxes without greater benefits.

Later, Netanyahu dropped the bombshell: an “umbrella” municipality extended to Maale Adumim, a settlement of 23,000 seven kilometres east, and Givat Zeev, a 9,000-strong settlement to the north. Both are in the West Bank; both are cited by Israeli politicians as within the boundaries of what they call “greater Jerusalem”.

The umbrella municipality would give Jerusalem mayor Ehud Olmert control over, among other things, building and planning in those two settlements.

The plan also calls for a tunnel to be built connecting Maale Adumim to Jerusalem and for a highway that would ring east Jerusalem.

Netanyahu defended the plan as a way to “strengthen the Jewish majority in Jerusalem” and said it was the best way to “fortify and base our hold” on the city, which Israel considers its “eternal, undivided” capital. He maintained that the plan did not contravene the peace accords signed with the Palestinians.

Palestinians blasted the plan as de facto annexation of the West Bank, which they say clearly contravenes the peace accords. Those accords prohibit any change in status to territory in the West Bank or Gaza and explicitly put negotiations on settlements and Jerusalem on hold pending a final peace deal.

“The Palestinians… consider the plan illegal,” said Ghassan Khatib, a Palestinian political commentator who directs the Jerusalem Media and Communication Center.

“It contradicts with international law and Security Council resolution,” he said. “And it contradicts with the terms of the reference in the peace process, which prohibit taking unilateral steps that are supposed to be part of negotiations on a final peace deal, which this plan clearly does.”

Therefore, he said, Palestinians “view the step as provocative and they think it will further sour the atmosphere and cause further deterioration of trust, which is really not going to help restart the peace negotiations.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags