Active Citizens, Civil Society, Development & Aid, Environment, Headlines, Health

ENVIRONMENT-KIRGIZSTAN: Truck Crash Cyanide Spill’s Deadly Effects

Andrei Ivanov and Judith Perera

MOSCOW, Jun 5 1998 (IPS) - Almost 700 people have been forced to seek medical treatment as the spillage from a May truck accident which tipped kilos of sodium cyanide into a river in Kirgizstan continues to poison unsuspecting locals. One woman has died.

The local hospital has only enough beds for 12 victims and the most severe cases of poisoning are having to be shipped to the capital Bishkek, some 200 miles away. The spill is also is blamed for fish and cattle deaths in the area.

On May 20, a truck carrying nearly 20 tons of sodium cyanide powder to the Kumtor gold mine crashed into the Barskaun river that feeds Lake Issyk-Kul, one of the largest and most picturesque bodies of water in Central Asia.

The damaged containers leaked over 2,000 kilos of sodium cyanide into the water. The mine is operated by Canadian firm Cameco, the world’s largest publicly traded uranium company, through its subsidiary, the Kirgiz-Canadian Kumtor Operating Company (KOC).

Kumtor said last week the leak posed “no serious threat to people, animals or agriculture.” The company says the truck was removed from the river in five hours which limited the spill. But Kirgiz Minister for Nature Protection Kulubek Bokonbayev says 1,700 kilos of the poison flowed downstream and between 200-300 kilos found its way into the lake itself.

The authorities have advised against fishing in the lake and police cordons had been put up in some areas to stop people bathing.

Bokonbayev says many tourists have cancelled their holidays and that contracts for investment in hotels in the area by foreign firms have also been cancelled.

“The Kirgiz government is preparing a suit against the Canadian company to redeem the inflicted damage”, he says. Damages are estimated at 160 million soms (8.5 million dollars).

In a statement, KOC says it has sent medicine worth about 5,000 dollars to Barskaun and intends to drill a well to provide a constant water supply to the village. However, this is unlikely to be enough to prevent the Kirgiz government from going ahead with the lawsuit.

Bokonbayev insists that the situation is now under control and that the latest data shows no cyanide either at the area of the incident or in the river mouth.

KOC President Gerhard Glattes says the company is prepared to pay compensation. “This is a very sad and unfortunate incident for Kumtor. Of course, our company will compensate for any damage.”

Although the Kirgiz authorities deny any severe environmental damage, they are refusing to allow independent investigation. Kumtor and the Kirgiz Ministry of Extraordinary Situations insist that the environmental damage has been minimal.

Glattes says a special commission has investigated the site and concluded that the ecology was not threatened. Ecology Ministry experts say water samples show cyanide levels in the lake to be within the norm.

However Abyl Karymshakov, chairman of the inter-regional committee on ecology, says the damage probably is two to three times more than the official figure.

Local observers say dead fish and cattle have been found at the site. Local authorities have shut off the water supply to the village of Barskaun and its thousands of residents. Their only other option, however, is the water of Issyk-Kul.

A governmental commission chaired by vice premier Boris Silayev says KOC compounded the problem by failing promptly to notify authorities. He said that residents of the Issyk-Kul region watered their gardens after the spill and poisoned the soil.

He said KOC will be required to decontaminate the soil and bear the full cost. Regional authorities learned of the incident about 19.00 hours local time, seven hours after the event, and the Ministry of Ecology was informed only the following morning.

Silayev also says that 680 residents of the region have sought medical treatment and 71 have been kept in hospital. The Legislative Assembly of the Kirgiz Parliament has formed a six- person parliamentary commission to investigate the accident. It is to report to the parliament by Jun. 16.

Yevgeni Usov of Greenpeace-Russia says chemicals like sodium cyanide should be transported under conditions similar those applied to radioactive materials. And the Bishkek-based Bureau on Human Rights and Rule of Law says that international agreements on chemical weapons require special authorisation for transnational delivery of large shipments of poisonous materials.

According to the governmental Kirgiz Customs Committee, sodium cyanide is imported into Kirgizstan from China.

A committee official said that the Kirgiz government has exempted KOC from customs duties, making it difficult to determine what materials KOC may have imported.

Member of Parliament Mukar Cholponbaev says KOC had failed to honour an agreement with the government to pave the road connecting the Kumtor site with the town of Balykchy. Cholponbaev said road conditions are too dangerous for such heavily laden trucks.

He said five trucks were transporting more than 100 tons of chemicals on the day of the spill. Ironically the 250 kilometre stretch of road from Bishkek to Balikchy, on the western tip of Issyk-Kul is among the best in Central Asia, largely due to Kumtor’s advance infrastructure work.

But at Balikchy the road divides, running along the north and south shores of the lake. The north shore of Issyk-Kul with all the tourist accommodations has a good road. However, the south shore road which leads to the Kumtor mine is much less developed.

In 1993, a parliamentary commission issued a report criticising the Kumtor project for failing to meet agreed standards, including environmental protection measures. The commission suggested the government should cancel the contract.

However, the government at the time accused the commission of being obstructive and in May 1994 approved the project. The parliament was dissolved in September 1994.

The project has so far run 176 million dollars over budget but is seen as vital to the country’s economy. Kumtor taps one of the biggest gold deposits in the country, from its site, 4,000 metres above sea level in the mountains southeast of Lake Issyk-Kul.

The contract for the project, a joint venture between Canada’s CAMECO and Kirgizstan’s state gold company, Kirgizaltyn, was signed in 1992 and the first gold was produced at the end of 1996.

In 1997, the first full year of production, Kirgizstan produced 17 tons of gold worth 176 million dollars, of which 14 tons came from Kumtor. This has helped Kirgizstan to cut its trade deficit and fed a reported 49 percent increase in industrial output last year.

The project also provides jobs at a time of high and rising unemployment, not only at the mine itself, but in support industries.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags