Environment, Headlines, North America

ENVIRONMENT: Canada Failing to Enforce Environmental Laws

Mark Bourrie

OTTAWA, Jun 2 1998 (IPS) - Canada’s 30 million citizens who have believed they were world leaders in environmental commitments have been startled to learn they are among the world’s worst polluters, according to official reports.

“While Canada has demonstrated vision” in advocating international efforts to protect the environment, “it is failing in implementing it,” said Brian Emmett, an independent federal commissioner assigned to monitor the country’s environmental protection performance.

Along with high use of fuel oil, natural gas and petroleum because of the country’s vast, sparsely-populated regions and cold climate, Canadian industry also pollutes heavily. Canada’s resource-based economy, which relies on mines, smelters, paper mills, and other heavy industries, is responsible for large emissions of greenhouse gases and pollutants. Many have found their way into the ecologically-sensitive arctic regions.

The country also has become notorious for its poor conservation practices. The Atlantic coast cod fishery has collapsed because of Canadian over-fishing, and salmon fishing on the Pacific coast is threatened by poor fisheries management.

Similar criticism has come from Canada’s Auditor General Denis Desautels, the official in charge of monitoring the performance of government departments. In a report last week he warned that Canada will not be able to live up to commitments made at last year’s Kyoto Conference to reduce greenhouse gas emmissions to 1990 levels by the year 2010.

In fact, greenhouse gas emissions will rise at least 11 per cent by 2010 because of ineffective policing by the Canadian environment department, he said.

Canada and the United States are responmsible for more greenhouse gas emissions per capita than any other countries. In Canada, Emmett said, there is no strategy for halting annual increases

Another report by a Canadian parliamentary committee calls for a radical change the way the country’s environmental laws are enforced. The reported urged the government either to give the Ministry of Environment enough money to protect Canadians from toxic chemicals or turn environmental enforcement over to a police force.

The parliamentary committee also wants the environment ministry to publish a detailed annual report of its enforcement actions in the previous year.

The enforcement staff of Environment Canada was cut 30 per cent between 1995 and 1997. Full-time prosecution staff has dropped from 10 to four in the entire country. Water sampling stations on the Great Lakes, the world’s largest reserve of fresh water, have been cut by 80 per cent. While acid rain caused by sulphur emissions from mines is a major problem in northern Ontario, causing all fish to be killed in thousands of lakes, but the government stopped water testing in the region last year.

The parliamentary report says bureaucrats in the environment department have tried to prevent elected representatives from finding out how badly the department is performing its enforcement duties.

“Some of the more senior bureaucrats just obstructed (us). They would not give us basic figures on the dollars or numbers of investigators. We felt we were hamstrung,” said Reform Party environment critic Bill Gilmour.

“Not only is this government incapable of applying its own environmental laws properly, but in addition Environment Canada seems to have done everything in its power to hamper the work of the standing committee, which was trying to shed light on the department’s failures,” the opposition Bloc Quebecois wrote in its submission to the scathing report.

“First, the Minister of Environment came on two hours notice to try to explain to the members of the committee that her officials did not have to answer all of the questions. Then, the department sent the committee erroneous information and dubious or inaccurate data, or quite simply refused to answer, claiming ro have no basic information,” the party declared.

“For the Bloc Quebecois, this situation indicates either incompetence on the part of Environment Canada, which has no means of evaluating its own enforcement program, or a desire to conceal from the elected representatives of the people the department’s many weaknesses. In either case, the very credibility of the department is in question.”

The Canadian environment ministry enforces national standards and is supposed to police major waterways to make sure that they are not used as dumping grounds for toxic chemicals. It also controls Canada’s strategy to address global warming issues, sets limits on air pollution, and works with provinces on local pollution issues.

The government department, however,along with those in Canada’s 10 provinces, has been faced with major budget and staff cuts. Last year, the department cut 1,600 jobs — more than 10 per cent of its employees — and 221 million dollars from the budget. In Canada’s largest province, Ontario, the provincial environment department’s budget has been cut by 43 per cent since 1995. Staff levels have been reduced by 36 per cent, from 2,430 to 1,550.

Environmentalists have condemned the cuts, along with so-called “harmonisation” between the federal and provincial governments that has left some environmental issues unpoliced.

“The (harmonisation) accord devolves much of the federal ability to act to the provinces, many of which may not have the capacity, or the political will, to pick up that ball. The consequence is less oversight and enforcement,” said Paul Muldoon, staff lawyer for the Canadian Environmental Law Association.

Even the Canadian Bar Association has attacked the government for the way it is devolving power over environmental enforcement. In a recent critique, the association, which represents most of the country’s lawyers, said: “Delegating enforcement and monitoring functions to the provinces diminishes the federal government’s responsibility for a high standard of environmental protection throughout Canada. Where the province lacks resources (human and monetary) and yet assumes these shifted responsibilities, it is highly likely that environmental protection will suffer.”

Environment Minister Christine Stewart said she would give serious consideration to the committee’s recommendations.

“Because of my concerns, and concerns expressed elsewhere, we already are reviewing our enforcement policies and the way we operate. I think that, in itself, will bring about significant improvements,” she said.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags