Friday, November 20, 2026
Danielle Knight
- U.S. environmental groups, frustrated at the apparent sidelining of environmental concerns by the World Trade Organisation (WTO), want to set up a neutral tribunal to balance trade and environment interests.
The groups point to the recent WTO ruling against a U.S. ban on imports of shrimp caught in nets without devices that exclude endangered sea turtles as a final blow to their interests. The environmentalists believe the international body may be the wrong forum for balancing conflicts between trade and the environment because it is dominated by trade interests.
“Any organisation, like the WTO, that acts as a judge in its own case is bound to rule in its own favour,” says Kathryn S. Fuller, president of the World Wildlife Fund (WWF) in the United States. “In 50 years, there never has been a trade restriction upheld because of environmental concerns.”
Groups say the recent WTO dispute settlement panel ruling against the U.S. law provided that latest evidence that trade interests continually trump environmental concerns.
Beginning in the late 1980s, the United States began requiring its domestic shrimp fleets to use turtle excluder devices. Later it extended this mandate to countries seeking to sell shrimp in U.S. markets. When Asian shrimps, caught without the devices, were denied entry here, four countries complained to the WTO.
Malaysia, Thailand, India, and Pakistan said the requirement discriminated unfairly against them, depriving them of access to U.S. markets. Thailand, which uses the turtle exclusion devices, said it filed the case out of principle that the trade ban is not consistent with international trade rules.
The WTO dispute settlement panel ruled that the U.S. law, as applied, goes too far in requiring exporting countries to adopt U.S. sea turtle conservation laws.
Environmental groups, however, maintained that the ruling violated the WTO’s own rules which allow exceptions for global environmental protection.
“In making this ruling, the WTO ignored it’s own charter that explicitly allows nations to pass laws to conserve natural resources as long as those laws also apply within their own borders,” says Brennan Van Dyke, a senior staff attorney with the Washington-based Center for International Environmental Law.
The shrimp/turtle ruling is just the latest in a string of trade rulings against environmental safeguards, say groups. “In the past 50 years, the WTO and its predecessor – the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT) – never upheld a trade restriction based on an environmental concern,” said WWF’s Fuller.
In 1991, the panel voted against a U.S. ban on imported tuna caught in ways that killed dolphins. Two GATT panels ruled that the U.S. was not entitled to impose sanctions should instead seek a multilateral agreement on “dolphin-safe” fishing. Other WTO decisions sought to weaken clean air regulations, say environmentalists.
Because the dispute settlement panel is dominated by trade negotiators usually with no special background in environmental issues or international law that the rulings end up favouring trade interests, say groups.
A longer-term solution to the trade and environment conflict will require fundamental changes in how conflicts are resolved, says Van Dyke. “A different fora is needed in order to work on how to balance the competing interests of trade and environment.”
Environmental groups want to set up an independent, neutral tribunal that would include representative experts on the environment, international law, science, and trade. “The WTO is a sick patient that won’t heal by itself,” Dan Seligman, a trade analyst at the Sierra Club, told IPS. “It needs outside doctors.”
Business interests, however, oppose creating another body as arbiter. While acknowledging that something must be done to fairly settle such disputes, they say the only way to strike a balance between competing interests is to promote change within the WTO system.
“The preferred course, and the only one our trading partners are likely to accept, its to clarify existing GATT/WTO rules,” says Abraham Katx, president of the U.S. Council for International Business. He says that negotiators should explicitly decide how dispute panels should decide the legitimacy of using trade sanctions to enforce or improve environmental standards.
The Clinton administration, strongly denouncing the recent decision on the U.S. law, said it would continue to uphold the current ban. U.S. Trade Representative, Charlene Barshefsky, meanwhile echoed environmentalists’ call for a more fair balance of trade and environment interests.
Writing in the Journal of Commerce this week she recommended the creation of an ‘Eminent Persons Group’ that would “provide fresh perspectives to the WTO on environmental questions.”
Barshefsky also called for improvements in WTO procedures to broaden public access, particularly concerning the dispute panel. “There’s no reason why the general public and experts in areas like environmental policy should not be able to observe the WTO dispute settlement proceedings and submit views to dispute settlement panels,” she wrote.