Economy & Trade, Headlines, Labour, North America

LABOUR-US: Bosses Making Top Dollar in US Workplace

Abid Aslam

WASHINGTON, Apr 30 1998 (IPS) - Corporate chiefs in the United States enjoyed a banner year in 1997, chalking up massive increases in pay – despite a lacklustre performance by some, and questions over the performance of their companies’ profits.

U.S. Chief Executive Officers (CEOs) last year saw a 35-percent jump in pay, according to the forty-eighth annual ‘Executive Pay Scoreboard’ compiled by ‘Business Week’ magazine and Standard and Poor’s Compustat, a division of the McGraw-Hill Companies.

That increase was down from 54 percent in 1996 but still amounted to more than 13 times the average 2.6 percent raise earned by blue-collar workers and more than nine times the 3.8 percent pay raise garnered by the average white-collar worker, according to the survey of the 365 largest U.S. companies.

The average boss earned 326 times more than the average factory worker, according to the U.S. Bureau of Labour Statistics’ Employment Cost Index.

Sanford Weill, CEO of insurance services giant Travelers Group, led the pack with 1997 wages of 230.7 million dollars. Coca-Cola’s Roberto Goizueta, who died in October, came in second with 111.8 million dollars. In third place, with 106.8 million dollars, was Richard Scrushy of Healthsouth, a Birmingham, Alabama-based health- care company.

Leaders of top U.S. corporations have not seen an increase in salary, but they have cashed in on “stock-option grants (or gifts of stock), combined with the rise of cushy retirement deals, sign- on bonuses, and ironclad severance packages,” said ‘Business Week’.

This has “made a mockery out of many attempts to truly link pay to performance,” according to the magazine, which added: “The upshot: Good, bad, or indifferent, virtually anyone who spent time in the corner office of a large public company in 1997 saw his or her net worth rise by at least several million (dollars).”

However, U.S. companies’ profits have been overstated by up to one-third, because the cost of granting stock options to executives is not reflected on profit-loss balance sheets, according to a report this month from Smithers and Company, a London-based research group.

Stock option schemes – under which companies grant executives the option to ‘call’, or buy, stock – effectively form part of a company’s wage bill.

The cost typically is equivalent to 21 percent of annual profits, according to Smithers and Company, yet is not reported in the ‘loss’ column of companies’ balance sheets. But because firms benefit from reduced taxes on the option schemes, they claim these gains as ‘profits’.

If that accounting discrepancy were eliminated, Smithers estimates, then the 100 largest U.S. corporations would have posted profits 30 percent lower than those reported in 1995 and 36 percent lower in 1996. Indeed, had the cost of stock options been fully accounted for, a number of companies would have had to have reported losses for 1996, the British report said. These companies included three whose CEOs were among the 20 top-paid executives in 1997:

– Microchip producer Intel, whose CEO, Andrew Grove, took seventh place with total pay amounting to 52.2 million dollars.

– Bio-tech giant Monsanto, whose chief executive, Robert Shapiro, came in tenth with a combined pay package of 49.3 million dollars.

– Pharmaceuticals behemoth Bristol Myers Squibb, where CEO Charles Heimbold earned 29.2 million dollars, putting him in fourteenth place.

“The average boss collected an options-fueled package worth 7.8 million dollars for 1997, pulling down a 35 percent raise over 1996’s 5.8 million dollars,” according to ‘Business Week’. “But for many CEOs, those gains bore little relation to how well their companies – or investors – did during the year.”

Take Ray Irani, the well-groomed CEO of California-based Occidental Petroleum, who took fourth place last year with 101.5 million dollars.

“Did Irani…build a business from scratch, or bring shareholders great rewards? Hardly,” noted ‘Business Week’. Since 1990, “Occidental’s stock has risen just 10 percent, and the company lost 390 million dollars in 1997 – in part due to Irani’s sweet deal.”

The U.S. survey, published Apr. 20, concluded that, “while the concept of linking (executives’) pay to performance has caught fire in the boardroom, reality has proven to be quite different.”

Stock options originally were intended to align CEOs’ interests with those of shareholders but, under most schemes, executives risk only a zero return if a company’s stock plummets. Therefore they are shielded from the risks taken by ordinary investors.

Officials at the State of Wisconsin Investment Board told researchers that shareholders generally were informed of the deals by which CEOs were insulated from market risks only after the arrangements had been made. The agency says shareholders should have veto power over option grants.

The American Federation of Labour-Congress of Industrial Organisations, the leading U.S. labour bloc, blamed the deals on cozy relations between CEOs and the directors who set their pay.

The Council of Institutional Investors, representing more than 100 pension funds with assets of more than one trillion dollars, in March called for companies to ‘index’ option grants – or make their value contingent on out-performing the stock market average or a group of competing stocks.

Although the Council’s proclamation “has no teeth, it is significant that the members unanimously approved it,” declared ‘Business Week’.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags