Development & Aid, Headlines, Latin America & the Caribbean

COMMUNICATION: Govt and Courts Split Over Pirate Radios

Adalberto Wodianer Marcondes

SAO PAULO, Apr 21 1998 (IPS) - There are close to 3,500 licensed radio stations in Brazil and another 7,500 stations that operate clandestinely – a situation that has caused a split between the government on one side and the judiciary and police on the other.

The Ministry of Communications wants to shut down all the pirate radio stations, but to do this it must have police support and therein liers the problem. Both the Federal Police, linked to the Ministry of Justice, and state police forces generally refuse to move against the radio stations unless there is a judicial order involved, and these are not readily available.

In 1994, a federal judge ruled that FM radio stations of less less than 50 watts of power did not need any authorization to operate. His ruling was based on the Brazilian Constitution, which prohibits all restrictions on freedom of information in any means of social communication, explained Jose Carlos Rocha, a professor at the University of Sao Paulo.

Rocha is also the president of the Democracy in Communication Forum, which brings together 1,090 “free” radio stations.

President Fernando Henrique Cardoso implemented legislation to regulate the functioning of community radio stations in Brazil through a law that defines free radios as non-profit, local broadcasters with community ties – and with a maximum output of 50 watts. But the law mandates that there be only one frequency for community radio stations thus limiting the number of sdtations that could broadcast in any given area

Rocha maintains that the new law generates a kind of censorship against the pluralism of ideas, favoring the owners of big commercial stations.

The numbers presented by the Democracy in Communication Forum reveal that more than 50 percent of the 3,500 stations regulated by the government are currently in financial trouble.

Of the 5 billion dollars in business generated by the Brazilian advertising industry, only 4 percent derives from radio, while television accounts for 56 percent. This situation increases the pressure on the part of the owners of licensed radio stations against those considered clandestine, Rocha says.

A campaign by most of the nation’s large radio stations accused the pirate radios of interfering with the frequencies utilized by emergency services, like ambulances, firefighters and the police, and of obstructing communications between airplanes and airport control towers.

An official at the Ministry of Communications, Eduardo Graziano, declared the new law on community radio, introduced only recently and strill to go into effect, was a step forward in the relationship between the government and local residents wanting their own outlets.

Previously, any station, “be it truly community-based or created by opportunists”, was considered illegal. With the new legislation, radio stations that operate within the bounds of what is considered community radio will be able t o operate freely, according to Graziano.

He warned, however, that such stations are a small minority among those that operate clandestinely.

“The Ministry will take action and close clandestine radios but, initially it will go after those that operate in bad faith,” Graziano said. Although “sympathetic” toward the work of some clandestine stations, he emphasized the law must be enforced.

The Federal Police, which is in charge of enforcing the decisions made by the Ministry of Communications, however appears to have a different outlook with respect to clandestine radio stations.

The February edition of the official magazine of the Union of Federal Police Commissioners declared that the new legislation was incapable of satisfying the needs of an already consolidated market. Moreover, it revealed that 50 officers of the Federal Police signed a declaration in support of the legalization of all clandestine radios.

One police officer stated that the problem was not about reaching a compromise with no costs, but about avoiding confrontations around a phenomenon that, while illegal, was of little gravity.

Information published in the magazine demonstrated that, of the 600 stations currently operating in Sao Paulo, the country largest city, more than 40 percent would benefit from the regulation. The others would have to close, which would result in the loss of 3,500 jobs or face the confiscation of equipment with an estimated value of 52 million dollars.

Graziano believes that aboyut 40 percent of all the clandestine radios in the country are in the state of Sao Paulo. Despite political pressure to leave these alone, Graziano insists that only those radios that comply with the law will be allowed to function, and all others will be outlawed.

Meanwhile, in thousands of communities throughout Brazil “free” – according to the Democracy in Communication Forum – or “clandestine” – according to the law – radio stations continue to broadcast advertisements for small local businesses and interview programmes with citizens and community leaders in a language accessible to all.

And, in most cases, these stations remain removed from the debates about their legalization or their extinction. (FIN/IPS/awm/ml/cr/98)

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags