Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Headlines, Population

POPULATION-PAKISTAN: No Consensus on Census

Irfan Husain

KARACHI, Mar 15 1998 (IPS) - Armed soldiers have been called out to assist census officials in Pakistan to do a house-to-house headcount of people that has whipped up political and ethnic passions.

The census exercise has drawn flak from all minority communities and political parties including former prime minister Benazir Bhutto who has warned against the disintegration of the country.

The ruling Pakistan Muslim League (PML) has been accused of rigging the survey which is taking place seven years after it was due in 1991 and, despite elaborate preparations, there is evidence of many embarrassing glitches.

Initially, complicated forms calling for all kinds of personal information ranging from whether a household had a TV set to the number of rooms in a residence were handed out, sparking an outcry from sections that feared the government would use the information to widen the net of income tax payees in the country.

Also the officials said all forms would have to be accompanied by photographs, and attested by “gazetted officers” like bureaucrats, which critics said would be difficult for the majority of rural people who would choose not to participate. But the government has not been able to reassure or convince ethnic communities that the census was in their best interests.

Pakistani politics is now fragmented on ethnic lines than it was in 1981 during the last census which went off fairly smoothly. Since the Constitution states the both parliament seats and federal resources would be divided among the population according to the results of the census, it is in every community’s interests to inflate their numbers.

Balochistan, Pakistan’s biggest but least populous province, has a large Pathan population that has been augmented by the presence of large numbers of Afghan refugees. So far, the Baloch have dominated the provincial assembly due to their numbers in the 1981 census but they now fear that this edge might be whittled down. The Pathans, on the other hand, accuse the Baloch- dominated local administration of attempting to rig the count.

Pathans were out on the streets, burning census forms in early March in protest against the census exercise, prompting the government to call in additional troops.

In volatile Sindh, the scene of so much ethnic violence, the situation is exacerbated by the presence of large numbers of Mohajirs or migrants who came to Pakistan from India at Partition, 50 years ago.

Since 1947, the urban centres have been scenes of bloody ethnic battles, with the government trying to crush the Mohajir National Movement (better known by its acronym MQM) set up in the mid-1980s to defend the rights of Urdu-speaking settlers from India against the local Sindhis.

Currently, the MQM is in a prickly alliance with the ruling Muslim League, and an uneasy calm prevails. However, the results of the census could trigger another round of bloodshed as the Sindhis fear they may be turned into a minority in their own province, while the Mohajirs suspect the government of wishing to use the census to continue denying them university places and government jobs which are subject to a quota system.

Then there is the urban-rural divide: so far, the assemblies are dominated by feudals who have managed to escape taxation and land reforms by their majority in Parliament. However, many demographers feel that given Pakistan’s rapid urbanisation, an accurate head count would sharply reduce the power of the feudals.

Punjab, Pakistan’s most populous province, has a vested interest in keeping its numerical superiority over the other three provinces as it enjoys the lion’s share of assembly seats, government jobs and federal resources.

With each province and virtually every ethnic group, together with the powerful feudal lobby, interested in inflating their numbers, the census exercise is a political mine-field, with serious doubts about its accuracy being raised.

Pakistan’s population, meanwhile, continues to gallop ahead at one of the highest growth rates in the world. It grew at around 3.1 percent in the 1980s, and is now estimated at around 140 million. Abida Hussain, the minister in charge of population welfare claims that the growth rate has fallen to 2.7 percent, but in the absence of a census, it is difficult to accept this sharp reduction when the government’s efforts to curb population growth has lacked conviction and official support.

For instance, Nawaz Sharif, Pakistan’s prime minister, recently directed the state-controlled television to stop broadcasting direct family planning messages. It is rumoured that his powerful father, a conservative man in his seventies, considered such programmes “vulgar”.

In order to defuse criticism of the ongoing census, the government recently announced that the results would not affect either the demarcation of constituencies or the division of assets. This bit of political jugglery has sown further confusion because people are asking why the country needs to count its numbers if nothing will change.

What is likely is that the government will sit on the findings until after the budget for the next fiscal year is passed in June, and then release figures gingerly if they do not rock the boat too much. But clearly, it is in a no-win situation: whatever results are finally announced, they are bound to upset one community or another.

Still, most political commentators agree that, if Nawaz Sharif – a businessman turned politician from Punjab – can loosen the feudals’ grip on power, he will have done the country a huge service.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags