Development & Aid, Environment, Headlines, North America

ENVIRONMENT: Industries that Simplify Nature Erode Ecosystems

Danielle Knight

WASHINGTON, Mar 1 1998 (IPS) - Fish farming and pulp-paper industries that simplify nature – in order to produce higher outputs of food, lumber or paper, are eroding ecosystems, say environmental experts.

Both fish farming and pulp-and-paper industries are growing rapidly around the globe and are are using unsustainable and destructive practices in efforts to increase volume, say researchers at Worldwatch Institute, an influential Washington think tank.

Yet for both industries, there are proven techniques for sustaining high production yields without such negative ecological consequences, according to the researchers.

The multi-billion dollar fish farming industry is growing at an explosive rate worldwide, but at huge cost to local communities and coastal ecosystems and sometimes to the health of wild oceanic fish, says Ann Platt McGinn in her report “Blue Revolution.” The title reflects the decades-old international agricultural research scheme known as the “Green Revolution.”

From 12.4 million tons in 1990, farmed fish production nearly doubled to 23 million tons by 1996. This explosion in aquaculture production is occurring at the same time that the world’s fishing fleets have suffered catastrophic losses and many ocean fish stocks have dropped to all time lows.

The increasing demand for fish and lucrative export markets for the product have encouraged farmers to increase output with fewer species and intensified production. As farmers rely more on artificial inputs (such as fishmeal, high-protein feed, chemicals and antibiotics) the volumes of waste, pollution, poor land-use practices and disease outbreaks are increasing.

In terms of environmental impacts, shrimp and salmon farming, which together accounted for 6.3 percent of world output in 1995, according to McGinn, are the worst offenders. In Asia and South America, shrimp farming for the international market – supported by export-hungry governments – is operating “the fish-farming equivalent of slash-and-burn agriculture,” she writes.

In Phuket, an island in southern Thailand, shrimp-breeding ponds have blanketed the landscape. Despite the money this type of aquaculture brings to the area, people who live nearby have not welcomed the new business.

Wastes from the ponds have been dumped on the ground, causing the villagers’ coconut trees to turn brown and their well water to go bad, according to McGinn. “They can no longer use the wells, and have had to haul in drinking water from somewhere else, ” she says. “When the wastes from cultivated shrimp were redirected into the bay, wild shrimp were killed – destroying the traditional local economy.

“For generations, the villagers have made their living by fishing shrimp from the sea, but the arrival of commercial prawn farmers is putting them out of business.”

The growth of fish-farming has also produced an absurd result, McGinn says. “Many farmed fish are raised on feed that is produced from ocean fish and, under present production methods, it takes five kilograms of ocean fish to produce one kilogram of high quality farmed fish – resulting in a large overall protein loss.”

One of the key benefits of fish-farming was reducing the pressure on marine fisheries. Yet, for carnivorous species such as shrimp, salmon, trout, and bass, aquaculture actually increases demands on marine production in order to provide feed for the farmed fish, explains McGinn.

Many of today’s fish farms also require and waste exorbitant amounts of fresh water, she adds. And aquaculture also puts further puts pressure on marine ecosystems by its reliance on wild stocks to supply seed.

McGinn notes, that in some operations, however, fish farmers have developed techniques that enable their industry to produce food in a highly efficient manner – much more so than in either ocean fishing or conventional agriculture.

One improvement involves using new water recirculation technologies. Another positive change is the integration of aquaculture with other industries such as fertilizer production, so that the byproducts of one industry become the inputs to another.

The paper and wood pulp industry, like fish production, also simplifies nature and puts severe stress on ecosystems, says Worldwatch researcher Ashley Mattoon.

“Because of the soaring global demand for forest products – especially paper – tree plantations are rapidly expanding worldwide and in some cases displacing natural forests,” writes Mattoon in her report “Paper Forests.” Between 1980 and 1995, the area of global tree plantations roughly doubled in size, as the Earth’s natural forest area continues to shrink by about 16 million hectares per year, according to her statistics.

As the raw timber of northern industrialised countries have been clear-cut, the pulp industry has increasingly looked to set up tree plantations in developing countries, such as Indonesia, Brazil and South Africa. In Latin America, for example, plantation area has increased 50 percent in the last 12 years, to a current total of 7.5 million hectares – an area slightly larger than Panama. Indonesia is planning to triple its plantation area within the next 15 years.

“Billions of trees are being planted to meet the world’s soaring appetite for paper, but pulp plantations are hardly forests,” Mattoon sharges.

Contrary to timber industry claims, plantations do not “reforest” the planet, she says.

“Industrial plantations do not provide many of the essential benefits natural forests provide – such as the formation of soil, provision of habitat for pollinators, and protection of biodiversity.”

Farming trees in a concentrated area is clearly preferable to mining the world’s last remaining old growth stands, admits Mattoon. But, in their present form, pulp plantations are driven almost entirely by short-term commercial considerations, at tremendous social and ecological costs.

The key difference between forests and tree plantations is diversity, she writes. “Natural forests are some of the most diverse ecosystems on earth, but plantations are generally monocultures that do not offer habitat for crop pollinators, flood control or fruit production.”

Large-scale monocultures are prone to disease and pest outbreaks and so they commonly require heavy pesticides which often end up polluting water supplies, says Mattoon

The 337 billion a year timber industry could do much to reduce the environmental impacts associated with their industrial plantations, writes Mattoon. She points to the forestry management principles of the Forest Stewardship Council, which certify the sustainable harvesting practices of timber companies. Their policies emphasize conservation, local economic health, watershed protection, and the reduction of pesticide use.

But no matter how carefully crafted it is, no plan has much of a chance if the world’s growing appetite for wood fiber is not reduced, stresses Mattoon. “At least as important as forest management is the management of consumption.”

She recommends investing in non-wood and recycled fibers. “The use of recycled paper has increased substantially, from 23 percent as a global average in 1970, to 36 percent in 1994, but there is still plenty of room for growth.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags

Development & Aid, Environment, Headlines, North America

ENVIRONMENT: Industries that Simplify Nature Erode Ecosystems

Danielle Knight

WASHINGTON, Mar 1 1998 (IPS) - Fish farming and pulp-paper industries that simplify nature – in order to produce higher outputs of food, lumber or paper, are eroding ecosystems, say environmental experts.
(more…)

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags