Friday, November 20, 2026
Mark Bourrie
- Canada’s decision to cut its foreign aid budget in fiscal 1998-99 , and freeze the level of assistance for the next three years, has been condemned by leading aid organisations.
The cuts came this week in Ottawa’s 104 billion dollar balanced budget for the year beginning April – which the government declared a victory in its four-year war on deficits.
But “what the Canadian government is doing is simple sleight of hand,” said Jim Culpeper, president of the North-South Institute, a think-tank on issues affecting developing nations.
“Except for an additional 20 million dollars for help clearing land mines, there has been no increase in foreign aid spending. It’s dropping from 2.2 billion dollars in 1998-99 to 1.9 billion dollars in 1999-2000, and it stays frozen at that level.”
Culpeper stressed the complaint of other agencies when he declatrted that “the Canadian government says its target is 0.7 per cent of Gross Domestic Product for foreign aid, but it’s doing nothing to reach that level!
“They would have to increase spending by 10 per cent each year, for 15 years, to hit that target and, instead, they’re cutting back.”
Public opinion polls show that, among voters, foreign aid ranks far below debt reductions, tax cuts and domestic social programs as a spending priority. Still, many Canadians mistakenly believe their country remains among the front rank of donor countries, critics noted.
Foreign aid spending was projected on a rolling three-year basis in the 1995-96 federal budget. The plan forecast cuts of 150 million dollars in 1997-98 and a further 150 million dollars in in 1998-99. The 1997 federal budget reiterated its commitment to maintain the cuts in international assistance. Overall, the decline between 1994-95 and 1998-99 is expected to reach close to one billion dollers. In 1996 Canada’s ODA/GNP ratio of 0.31 percent – the lowest since 1969 – was the result of repeated cuts in the aid budget since 1990.
During 1994-98, the ODA/GNP level will have dropped from 0.42 percent to 0.26 percent. This represents Canada’s lowest aid effort since 1965-66 when the aid program was being established.
The Netherlands, a country with half of Canada’s population, has an aid budget that is larger in absolute size than that of Canada, Culpepper said.
Foreign aid has been the most affected of all major federal programs in the years 1994-98 – down by 34 percent while spending on Canada’s military fell only 21 percent during the same period.
In 1996, Canada’s aid program recorded a precipitous decline in real terms of 15 percent over the previous year: only in Portugal and Japan did aid levels fall more drastically. The drop was sufficient to move Canada from 6th to 11th most generous donor, placing it in the bottom half of the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development’s (OECD) 21 donor countries for the first time since the 1960s.
The top three recipients of Canadian aid in 1995-96 were China with 139 million dollars, Zambia, 128 million dollars and Bangladesh, 112 million dollars. The geographical distribution of aid was: Africa, 48 percent; Asia, 34 percent; the Americas, 16 percent; and Eastern Europe, 2 percent.
The OECD previously has criticized Canada for failing to deliver on promised levels of international aid to poorest nations. In January, an OECD review of foreign aid spending among the association’s 29 members showed Canada’s official development assistance fell to a 30-year low of 0.32 per cent of gross domestic product (GDP) in 1996, down from 0.45 per cent of GDP in 1990. (Canada’s GDP has been growing by 3 to 4 per cent each year through the 1990s).
Canada is below the OECD average of 0.40 per cent, and far below the United Nations target of 0.70 per cent of GDP. The United States, Great Britain and Italy give even less, in terms of percentage of GDP but, because their economies are so large, the amount of cash they give is greater.
The United States gives only 0.12 per cent of GDP, but, in cash terms, is the second-largest donor country, after Japan.
In 1993, the governing Liberal Party defeated the Progressive Conservative Party, which governed from 1984. Despite promises to increase foreign aid, the Liberals have actually allowed it to drop in terms of GDP percentage. The OECD expects the level to fall to below 0.30 in the 1998-99 fiscal year.
Canada now gives less as a percentage of GDP than Denmark, Norway, Sweden, The Netherlands, France, Luxembourg, Belgium, Finland, Switzerland and Germany. Much of Canada’s aid is also contingent on using the money to buy Canadian goods and services.
“The reach and depth of Canada’s international involvement – clearly rooted in the country’s values, interests and capabilities – have not been matched by commensurate levels of resources allocated for development co-operation in recent years,” the report said.
“As the government has restored stability to its fiscal situation, this will be a critical moment for the future of canada’s official development assistance [program] and for Canada’s valued international role,” the report said.
In a newspaper interview, Finance Minister Paul Martin defended his country’s poor record. He said Canada “was no worse” than other industrialized countries.
“Unfortunately for reasons we all know, Canada has slowed down its foreign aid, but no more than most other countries. Over time, as our finances improve, that obviously is one area that we would like to see improve,” he said.