Sunday, November 22, 2026
Jorge Pina
- Humanitarian groups greeted Friday, although with some reservations, a draft law approved by parliament after a year-long debate, which details the rights and duties of immigrants.
Sergio Briguglio, the coordinator of the Catholic organisation Caritas, said the bill, approved by the Senate Thursday at the “last minute” in legislative terms, grants immigrants unlimited residency in Italy after five years of legal residency.
But Briguglio said the initiative did not provide for the automatic legalisation of the country’s 200,000 undocumented immigrants. According to government figures, there are some 1.2 million foreigners in Italy, which has a total population of around 60 million.
The draft law stipulates the immediate deportation of foreigners with criminal records or without identity documents, such as a passport from their country of origin.
Although it does not provide for the automatic legalisation of undocumented immigrants as advocated by Briguglio, the draft law does make it possible for illegal immigrants who can prove they were in Italy prior to the bill’s (future) ratification by the executive branch to apply for a residency permit.
Undocumented immigrants must also demonstrate that they have a job and have not committed any crime.
Within the next three months, Interior Minister Giorgio Napolitano will submit a report to parliament, which will indicate the activities performed by illegal immigrants from outside the European Union and their distribution throughout Italy.
According to a government report, close to 48,000 immigrants were reported in connection with criminal activity in 1997, more than 40 percent of them in connection with prostitution-related crimes, 22.35 percent with drugs and 15.4 percent with crimes against property. Foreigners account for 28.4 percent of the prison population in Italy.
Of the total number of immigrants in Italy, 40 percent are from Europe – two-thirds of them from eastern Europe – 30 percent are North Africans and 16 percent Asians. Fourteen percent came to Italy from the Americas.
The European Union’s 15 member countries hosted 18.1 million immigrants in 1995, 80 percent of whom came from outside the EU. Germany ranks first with seven million immigrants, followed by France (3.5 million) and Great Britain (2.2 million).
A group of Peruvian nationals consulted by IPS were wary about the draft law. They said they would wait and see what happened when others went to the police to regularise their situation before applying for residency permits.
Their problem was that they did not have regular jobs, but got by on seasonal and temporary work. “They give us work only if we are undocumented, because otherwise we cost too much,” said one of the immigrants, who asked not to be identified.
“Since they are not willing to pay our social benefits and the rest of the rights enjoyed by Italian workers, we are forced to remain illegal,” he explained.
The draft law, which was resisted by the right-wing opposition and the separatist Northern League, outlines a quota system for work permits for “extracomunitarios” – immigrants from outside the European Union – in accordance with the demands of the labour market.
The quotas are to be set on a yearly basis. The term “extracomunitario” is applied to immigrants from the developing South and eastern Europe, not the United States or Norway, for example.
The law also provides for family reunification, for which the interested parties must demonstrate that their relative(s) in Italy has/have enough income to support them.
The centre-left government submitted the bill to parliament on Feb. 19, 1997, but resistance from the right-wing bloc and the Northern League delayed its approval until Thursday.
Tom Benettollo, the president of Solidarity, an immigrant advocacy group, said he was satisfied with the draft law because “the state has assumed an important quota of responsibility with respect to immigrants.”
Immigration is no longer considered a problem of law and order, but “a structural phenomenon, for which a response is necessary, with a description of the rights and duties of foreigners,” whose “cultural and economic contribution to our country” must be recognised, he added.
In Benettollo’s view, the possibility of unlimited residency after five years in the country is particularly important, as is the affirmation of immigrants’ rights to education and healthcare.
But Senator Maria Grazia Siliquini of the right-wing National Alliance criticised the bill, asserting that “it even privileges ‘extracomunitarios’ over unemployed Italians.”
Minister of Social Solidarity Livia Turco described the initiative as an “important” law that detailed the rights and responsibilities of immigrants and extended to them “opportunities equal to those available to Italians.”