Development & Aid, Environment, Headlines, North America

ENVIRONMENT: Greens Split Over Dolphin Protection Agreement

Danielle Knight

WASHINGTON, Feb 15 1998 (IPS) - A dozen tuna-fishing nations, ending years of negotiation, have reached a historic agreement to protect dolphins and other marine life in the Eastern Pacific Ocean.

Belize, Colombia, Costa Rica, Ecuador, France, Honduras, Mexico, Panama, Spain, the United States, Vanuatu, and Venezuela successfully reached an agreement this week at a meeting of the Inter American Tropical Tuna Commission in California. Countries are expected to sign the agreement this May.

Yet, the historic agreement has split the environmental community in two. While groups like Greenpeace, World Wildlife Fund and the Environmental Defence Fund are comfortable with the agreement, others groups are not.

“This marks the beginning of a new era of greater protection and international cooperation on behalf of dolphins, other species and the marine ecosystem,” said Roger E. McManus, president of the Washington-based Center for Marine Conservation, an environmental organisation that strongly favours the agreement.

Other organisations, however, such as Earth Island Institute, the Humane Society and Friends of the Earth say the pact is weak.

“This new agreement allows tuna fishing nations to kill twice the number of dolphins annually that were killed in 1996,” says David Phillips, director of California-based Earth Island Institute’s International Marine Mammal Project. “There is no attempt to reduce dolphin deaths, in direct contrast of previously stated international goals and the U.S. Marine Mammal Protection Act.”

The Eastern Pacific tuna fishery stretches from California out to Hawaii, south to the equator and back to Chile. It’s unique yellowfin tuna there tend to swim with dolphins. Traditionally, tuna boats in these international waters, accompanied by speed boats and helicopters, herd the dolphins and tuna into mile-long purse-seine nets.

Since the purse-seine method of fishing was first introduced to the Eastern Pacific in the 1950s, the populations of both species of dolphins fell an estimated 20-45 percent. Throughout the 1980s, more than 100,000 dolphins were killed each year in the process.

The agreement document states it will provide greater protection and promote the recovery of individual dolphin stocks, especially those that are depleted, while establishing measures to avoid, reduce, and minimize the unintended catching of other sea life such as sea turtles and sharks. It also contains provisions to track tuna to differentiate between dolphin-safe and unsafe tuna.

But even with all of these seemingly pro-dolphin provisions, critics say the agreement is meaningless because it is unenforceable.

The agreement lets tuna captains who use explosives or intimidate international observers, for example, continue to get dolphin kill quotas without even a slap on the wrist, if their government decides so, says Phillips. “In the entire history of the Inter American Tropical Tuna Commission, no nation has ever suspended a captain or imposed meaningful fines on fishing vessels that violate international agreements to protect dolphins.”

“By setting up an agreement that provides no teeth to eliminate the kill, Mexico and the U.S. can claim they are saving dolphins while letting the killing continue,” he adds. Earth Island and others are calling upon Clinton to reject the agreement and instead re-open negotiations for a more binding agreement.

Nina Young, a marine mammologist with the Center for Marine Conservation, however, has a different interpretation. “Independent observers, required under the agreement, on all tuna vessels operating in the Eastern Pacific will ensure that proven dolphin-saving measures are used. Under this agreement, fishers who fail to do so risk being closed out of major tuna markets worldwide, including the United States.”

The controversy over dolphin safe standards began over the U.S. “dolphin-safe” tuna label. The environmental sensitivities of people in the United States, who eat more tuna that people in any other country, had gotten in the way of international trade agreements. Mexico complained that the 1992 U.S. embargo on tuna not deemed “dolphin safe” violated the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade by imposing one country’s law on another country.

In an attempt to ease diplomatic tensions, the U.S. Senate, with the support of President Bill Clinton, approved a compromise in July to lift the embargo while keeping the “dolphin safe” designation.

Amending The U.S. Marine Mammal Protection Act allowed the temporary capture of some dolphins in tuna nets as long as the dolphins are not killed or seriously injured. The amendment was approved under the conditions that a “binding legal agreement” among nations is reached to protect dolphins on an international level.

While Greenpeace and others called the agreement strong, the Sierra Club, Friends of the Earth, Defenders of Wildlife Public Citizen and the Human Society called it the “Dolphin Death Act.”

Critics of the act said it legitimized a harmful method of fishing that corralled dolphins for hours with speedboats, helicopters, and tuna boats – driving them over miles of sea, forcing them to submit to capture nets.

Negotiations of the recent agreement began in 1995 under the Panama Declaration where the 12 tuna fishing countries agreed to work together to strengthen dolphin protections rather than abandon the dolphin-saving practices they had developed in order to meet the tough dolphin death reduction targets set by the United States and the Inter American Tropical Tuna Commission.

In recent years, tuna fishers from Mexico and other Central and South American countries claim to have been more careful about protecting dolphins. And, according to the U.S. National Marine Fisheries Service, dolphin mortalities have been reduced approximately 98 percent, from hundreds of thousands each year to about 3,000 in 1996.

Critics believe that observers on foreign boats may be undercounting dolphin mortalities – either because it’s so difficult to conduct such a count or because they are being pressured or bribed to do so. They maintain that two dolphin stocks exploited by tuna fishermen – eastern spinner dolphins and northern offshore spotted dolphins – remain far below historic levels.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags

Development & Aid, Environment, Headlines, North America

ENVIRONMENT: Greens Split Over Dolphin Protection Agreement

Danielle Knight

WASHINGTON, Feb 15 1998 (IPS) - A dozen tuna-fishing nations, ending years of negotiation, have reached a historic agreement to protect dolphins and other marine life in the Eastern Pacific Ocean.
(more…)

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags