Asia-Pacific, Economy & Trade, Environment, Headlines, Labour

INDONESIA: Forestry Workers Get Jobs, But Not Better Lives

Kafil Yamin

SOLO, Indonesia, Feb 12 1998 (IPS) - Since his teens, 63-year-old Ladiman has been doing casual work for the state forestry corporation Perum Perhutani, helping to plant and fell teak trees in its plantation here.

Though to this day he remains a casual worker, the firm allows Ladiman’s family to plant crops like corn and vegetables on a parcel of the company’s 30,000-hectare teakwood plantation in Cepu, 70 km from this town in Central Java.

Ladiman is one of 48 heads of families included in the social forestry programme called Hutan Bina Desa, which allows local peasants to plant in the patches of land among the teak trees. Each family is also assigned a one-fourth hectare ‘concession’ that produces a ton of corn each harvest and brings added income.

To many, this arrangement — casual work and permission to till some land — is a successful, if modest, way of helping families who live near forested areas.

But critics now say it does too little and may be perpetuating the deprivation it seeks to remove.

They point out that workers share little from the profits of forestry firms, even in the eighties when the forestry sector was a top foreign exchange earner for Indonesia.

Farmers remain landless casual workers, despite decades of hard work for the state-owned company. The peasants themselves say they make far from enough money for their families under the social forestry scheme.

Planting corn in their assigned areas brings in 43 U.S. dollars at harvest. But Ladiman says this is not enough, since harvest comes only one in five months, and even if his wife works at Perum Perhutani’s seedling centres for 22 U.S. cents a day.

During the company’s annual tree felling, the casual workers are paid 22 cents for each cubic metre of wood cut.

Parno, a 57-year-old worker in the social forestry programme, knows little about the forestry business despite years of part- time work. “What I know is that the people in the company are getting richer and richer, with good houses and brand-new cars. While here I am, still as I was before,” he said.

But Martono, head of the forest security division of Perum Perhutani, believes that people living near the forest area could be worse off without the company’s programmes.

These show the company’s concern for local communities and its desire to help ease their poverty, he said. “Long before the government promulgated its anti-poverty drive, we’ve been working on it,” Martono pointed out.

Activists’ groups like Akatiga, a Bandung-based social research centre, dispute this argument. Juni Thamrin, a senior researcher with the group, questions the firm’s social commitment because “the plight of the landless farmers has never changed since the programme started”.

In fact, Thamrin says, the programme is designed to prevent the theft of wood by local people, which reports say has often occurred. Thus, it is mainly an investment in security and not so much to help the poor or allow communities to make use of local resources, critics add.

“So they (Perhutani) ostensibly lend a helping hand to locals to protect their land,” Thamrin observed. The programme only helps the farmers survive from day to day, but does not improve their plight, he argues.

Farmers can plant only certain species that do not harm teak, the main tree in the plantation. And when the trees grow, they naturally deprive the lower-growing plants tended by the farmers of sunshine, affecting their crops. “Worse, most of the species allowed for planting have less economic value,” Thamrin added.

As the debate over the impact of social forestry programmes continue, farmers find themselves coping with problems brought on by Indonesia’s economic crisis.

Farmers in Cepu say they have never heard of the International Monetary Fund, which led a bailout package for Indonesia, or the World Bank, which recently sealed a 450 million dollar loan to improve farmers’ plight.

But they are not immune from the effects of the economic downturn, which is coinciding the worst drought in five decades.

Like other Indonesians, farmers here have found that the cost of cooking oil and fertiliser have soared more than 75 percent in the last five months. Fuel prices have risen by as much as 300 percent, provoking riots and unrest in parts of the country. Angry Indonesians have stoned shophouses and groceries.

To many farmers, the crisis makes their difficult plight even harder.

The government’s move a month ago to dismantle cartel practices in the exports of forestry products is being hailed by firms that now anticipate better business, but any windfall is unlikely to trickle down to casual workers in plantations.

“We’ve been dreaming of having our own land. That’s what the future means to us,” one farmer here said.

Meantime, more blue-collar workers from the cities, who have lost their jobs, are returning to farm in the villages. Forestry workers and farmers here, like Ladiman and Parno, find they have to share their concessions with these returnees.

Life in the village will not be easy, as the casual forestry workers well know, but the returnees have little choice. Said Sugiman, a 38-year-old construction worker: “I am home now. I am not going back to Jakarta. There are no more jobs out there.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags