Friday, November 20, 2026
Daniel Gatti
- Praised by some governments, encouraged by entrepreneurs but rejected by labor unions, the “flexibilization” of labor has emerged as one of the dominant themes in the Latin America landscape.
There are many misconceptions surrounding the theory of being “flexible” in the job market-place in Latin America. Many have taken a position vis-a-vis the issue of flexibility, interpreting it in only one of its dimensions: the transformation of the labor market. This has invariably meant employment insecurity, the growth of the tertiary sector, and the deregulation of relations between workers and employers.
This was the concept of flexibilization that was at the center of debate this year in Latin America as well as in other parts of the world, in a scenario dominated by the rise of unemployment.
It was this same notion that led to the elimination of thousands of jobs and the creation of jobs so precarious that in Argentina they were branded “trash contracts”. But there are other “good” forms of flexibilization that are gradually making inroads, despite the fact that “the dominant conception is the one advocated in the United States at the beginning of the 1970s”, according to Argentine labor analyst Carlos Delinaris.
In Argentina in 1997 the government of Carlos Menem was able to reduce unemployment, from 18.6 percent to 16.4 percent. But he achieved this thanks to “trash contracts”.
Eighty percent of the new jobs that were created in the past two years are characterized by their extreme precariousness (such jobs have limited duration, they do not include compensation for dismissal, nor sick leave).
Since 1989, when he began his first term, Menem has been advocating measures that favored temporary contracts and reductions in the sums for compensation for dismissal, work- related accidents, and employers’ contributions to social security. A similar process has been under way in other countries in the region.
Government and business leaders have been promoting measures to “flexibilize” contract rules, arguing that they can help combat unemployment. They have also been advocating for measures that make it easier to fire workers, with the excuse that that is the only way to make businesses competitive.
This trend is opposed by labor unions, mostly in countries where the economies are the weakest; but they have been unable to accomplish much. Flexibilization, meanwhile, has been accompanied by the creation of jobs in the informal sector, which in turn has brought down wages in the low productivity sectors.
A study by the International Labor Organization (ILO) released in May indicates that between 1990 and 1995, of every 100 jobs created in Latin America, 84 corresponded to the informal sector, where income levels are the lowest. Forf example, in Venezuela – where 12 percent of the economically active population is unemployed – the government adopted flexibilization norms that violated international conventions.
In Central America, the maquiladoras have become true laboratories for labor deregulation. These are mostly assembly plants owned by foreign capital and based in free trade zones where basic labor rights are often disregarded.
In Uruguay – where unemployment is slightly above 12 percent – the government’s attempts to deregulate labor relations have not succeeded. But firms continue to use dismissals and temporary job contracts as a form of adapting to the crisis and improving their levels of productivity.
In Brazil, unions in the automobile sector have accepted salary reductions in order to avoid massive layoffs, a trend that could spread to other sectors.
A similar phenomenon is occurring in Argentina, where many unions have accepted the renegotiation of salaries and working conditions, and in the process sacrificing rights that were won in the past.