Sunday, November 22, 2026
Gustavo Capdevila
- The issue of agriculture is hindering the discussions on the declaration that the World Trade Organisation (WTO) is to approve next week at its ministerial conference in the U.S. city of Seattle, Washington.
The prospect of a compromise on the question of agriculture glimpsed last week went up in smoke Sunday, when WTO Director- General Mike Moore reached the conclusion that there was “no more room for debate.”
The United States and Cairns Group – made up of 15 agriculture exporting countries – had previously struck a deal to engage in negotiations with the European Union (EU), which heads the bloc opposed to the liberalisation of agriculture.
In its understanding with the Cairns Group, the United States accepted the idea of submitting trade in farm products to the same rules governing other kinds of goods.
In a key point of the accord, Washington agreed on the elimination of all export subsidies – which would include the credits with which the U.S. government finances farm exports.
With the tacit alliance between the Cairns Group and the United States, the discussions extended to the EU, which has the backing of Japan, South Korea, Norway and Switzerland.
But after lengthy debates over the weekend, Brussels rejected the draft of a possible accord, because it failed to reflect its minimum demands, said a Cairns Group source.
Although the group of farm exporting countries is confident that some sort of compromise agreement may still be reached, “the reality is that we cannot go any farther, because we have conceded as much as we can,” said the source.
The EU “was only trying to find out how much we were willing to yield, in order to design its strategy for Seattle,” he added.
The failed agreement mentioned the total submission of agriculture to WTO rules, the principle of the “multifunctionalism” of agriculture and the elimination of export subsidies. It also ranked the issues to be negotiated and to be kept in mind.
The Cairns Group has rejected the idea of including the concept of multifunctionalism in the talks on trade in farm products, arguing that it was simply a new guise for protectionism.
The multifunctionalism argument focuses on “non-commercial” concerns like food security, the environment, recreation and the landscape, and is used by some countries as an excuse for maintaining farm subsidies.
But in the latest discussions with the EU, the Cairns Group accepted the multifunctionalism argument, in order to obtain concessions from the Europeans.
A clause of the aborted agreement stated that “non- commercial” concerns had to be addressed with transparent measures that did not cause distortions in trade.
The Cairns Group does not question multifunctionalism in and of itself, but is concerned with coming up with ways to meet the stated goals without affecting trade or production.
Not only agriculture, but the questions of the enforcement of previously agreed multilateral agreements, industrial tariffs and new trade issues are also holding up the drafting of the document that the ministers are to approve in Seattle from Nov 30 to Dec 3.
Over the weekend, new obstacles emerged in the area of new issues – which include trade and the environment, trade and investment, competition policy, transparency of public procurements, social clauses and electronic commerce.
The draft of the final document had some 60 bracketed items, signalling a similar number of discrepancies among negotiators. But after Sunday’s discussions, the number had risen to 140, making even more remote the possibility of reaching an understanding in the near future.
The setting for the negotiations moves this week to Seattle, where WTO authorities and personnel of the Secretariat, in charge of summing up the content of the negotiations in a text, will begin to head Wednesday.
The discussions will get underway again next weekend in Seattle, where the delegations will gather. In the meantime, Moore has continued making phone contacts with the ministers of WTO member states, in an attempt to gain manuevering room for the negotiations.
The Seattle declaration will contain only a limited number of resolutions, leaving open the prospect for further negotiations, after a reasonable length of time of no longer than a year, said a Latin American negotiator who preferred to remain anonymous.
With respect to the question of agriculture, the source ruled out the possibility of a repeat of the Uruguay Round (1986-94) experience, when the United States and European Union struck a bilateral deal at the eleventh hour which frustrated the aims of efficient agricultural exporting countries.
This time “we have achieved a strong enough alliance with the United States to deter another ‘Blair House’,” said a source close to the Cairns Group in a reference to the residence for official guests in Washington where the U.S.-European accord was reached in 1994.