Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Headlines, Human Rights, Population

RIGHTS-CAMBODIA: Rural Road Leads to People Power

Debra Boyce

RATTANAKIRI, Cambodia, Jun 2 1999 (IPS) - The road is simple, unpaved and only a kilometer long, but it has opened up a new world to the hill tribe community of Labang 1 in Cambodia’s remote north-east.

The Pheung community, part of one of Rattanakiri province’s largest indigenous groups, was once accessible only by a narrow ox cart path that was flooded for half of the year. Children were late for school, traders avoided the isolated villages and it was a struggle for villagers to get their goods to market.

Since the stretch of road was built in 1997, life has greatly improved in Labang 1. But more importantly, the villagers say, the road was the first opportunity to plan their own future.

“We now have many ideas and many projects that we want,” says resident Ruan Phay Poan. “We knew what we needed but before no one asked us.”

The road into Labang 1 is just one of hundreds of projects that have resulted from a policy experiment in decentralisation called the “local planning process”.

First started in Cambodia’s strife-torn northwest by the United Nations Capital Development Fund (UNCDF), the programme places development planning, financing and management at the provincial and local levels rather than imposed by the national government hundreds of kilometres away in Phnom Penh.

The idea of local planning is gradually taking root around the country, helping to push ahead Cambodia’s long-term development and social reconstruction.

“This has changed attitudes at the local level,” says Soparth Pongquan of the Bangkok-based Asian Institute of Technology (AIT), which gave technical assistance to the UNCDF initiative on local planning.

People say ‘now we have clear plans and there is more understanding’ or say ‘before we decide anything, we have to ask the people’,” says Soparth, who heads the AIT side of the project.

“The local planning process provides empowerment,” says Min Muny, provincial programme manager of the United Nations Development Programme’s (UNDP) Carere project in Rattanakiri, which supports a national government decentralisation scheme.

“It’s time we bring the village to discuss with the higher levels and the province will also have to respond. This is a big change in Cambodian society, usually you just have to accept whatever is offered,” Min Muny added.

The first attempt at local governance began in 1996 in the strife-torn provinces of Battambang and Banteay Meanchey. With assistance in design and evaluation from AIT, UNCDF introduced the local planning process to two communes, the second lowest level of authority, in these provinces on the Thai border.

The process, while novel to Cambodia, is straightforward.

Villagers elect development committees, whose members are trained in their roles and responsibilities. Villagers collect socio-economic information, and together set goals for their communities.

Commune development committees, headed by the commune chief and consisting of respected leaders, then approve the projects. The province provides the monitoring and financing from a local development fund set aside for each commune. Villagers are required to contribute to a portion of the project with either labour or materials.

For Cambodia, this is a completely new process. Local officials are appointed, rather than elected, and all planning and financing is done at the national level in Phnom Penh, with little communication or coordination with local authorities.

The result, says Seng Pho, a UNDP staffer who works with village and commune development committees in Rattanakiri, were many projects such as dams or irrigation schemes that were either unnecessary or not a priority, and thus a waste of money.

But gradually that attitude is changing. The national government, with support from the UNDP’s Carere project, in 1997 made the local planning process the heart of a decentralisation experiment.

Known as Seila, which means foundation stone in Khmer, the programme has brought local planning to three other provinces, Pursat in the west, Siem Reap in the north and Rattanakiri in the northeast.

The culmination of these new strategies and policies is a government commitment to hold for the first time commune council elections, scheduled for the end of this year.

“As a policy experiment, in this way it is a success,” says Bettina Fuhrmann, programme manager of UNCDF.

“The fact that Carere took it up is a sign that it worked. Although the process has evolved and changed from Battambang to Rattanakiri the basic principle is the same. People at the grassroots level do what they want to do. We ask them to put on paper a plan, and be sure the plan is implemented,” she adds.

Nationwide, more than 1,100 villages are now participating in local planning, with more than one million Cambodians, about 10 percent of the population, benefitting from the project, says Benoit Thierry, programme manager and UNDP rural development adviser in Phnom Penh.

UNCDF is a major contributor to Seila and has continued to fund infrastructure projects, such as roads and bridges, in Battambang and Banteay Meanchey, spending more than 4.5 million dollars since 1996.

In Rattanakiri, where infrastructure is less critical, other donors have provided capital funding for projects such as rice mills and buffalo banks.

The idea of local planning was welcomed somewhat hesitantly by the villagers of Labang 1 commune in Rattanakiri. Residents of three adjoining villages decided they wanted a road, but after submitting their plan to the commune nothing happened, recalls Nguy Houch, a village committee member.

“We thought at first we had been cheated,” he says. “After the proposal for the road was approved, everyone believed in the process.”

The villagers built the road themselves, with materials provided by the local development fund. “All the villagers are happy to contribute material or labor because they are asking for the project themselves,” explains Nguy Houch. “They think it is important to improve the situation of their village.”

The next two projects in the commune were a buffalo bank, which has provided buffalo to the poorest families, and a rice mill. Villagers again contributed to the projects and pay a small sum of money each time they use the rice mill for maintenance.

Sitting under the corrugated tin roof of the commune school recently, representatives of the commune and four village committees prepared a commune plan for their third round of projects. One village wants a well, another a school. A second rice mill and buffalo bank have also been proposed.

Success is not measured only in the number of roads built, says Min Muny, but also in villagers’ increased ability to make goals and plans. Village committees need also to be made up of 40 percent women.

“The big challenge is not the tangible output,” says Min Muny. “It’s changing the attitude, building the ability of the (village committee), so people can talk frankly and clearly. Communication is important for democracy.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags