Economy & Trade, Global, Global Geopolitics, Headlines

TRADE: WTO Paralysed by Dispute Over Leadership

Gustavo Capdevila

GENEVA, May 3 1999 (IPS) - The World Trade Organisation (WTO) remained caught up Monday in an at times bitter confrontation between the two blocks of countries disputing the future leadership of the global body.

Mike Moore, a social democratic former prime minister of New Zealand, has the backing of the United States and the European Union, the world’s two top trading powers.

His adversary is Deputy Prime Minister of Thailand Supachai Panitchpadki, whose candidacy has been mainly sponsored by Asia, including Japan, the world’s third largest economy.

The post was left vacant on May 1, at the end of the four-year mandate of Italy’s Renato Ruggiero. But the election of the new director-general continued to be postponed.

Tanzanian representative Ali Said Mchumo, chairman of the WTO General Council, proposed Friday that Moore be designated by consensus. But Supachai’s supporters responded that only a vote could determine who enjoyed the greatest backing.

Since then, the two groups have found themselves locked in tense debate over the procedure to be used in naming the new director-general.

Underlying the debate is a struggle for power within the WTO, created in 1995 to enforce the multilateral accords negotiated by the Uruguay Round of the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT), predecessor to the WTO.

Mchumo’s report said the two candidates enjoyed similar levels of support among developing nations. Supachai, however, has been touted as the candidate for the developing world, a sector excluded up to now from the leadership of GATT and the WTO.

From its creation in 1948, GATT was headed by Eric Wyndham- White of Great Britain (1948-68), Olivier Long (1968-80) and Arthur Dunkel (1980-93) from Switzerland, and Ireland’s Peter Sutherland (1993-95).

“Leadership from the North since GATT is the hallmark of this organisation”, the representative of Zimbabwe, Tichaona Jokonya, complained Saturday.

The “time has come to accept leadership from the South, especially given the calibre and capability of Dr. Supachai,” he added.

Ideological questions have been virtually absent from the debate, which has mainly focused on procedural aspects.

A declaration by the Association of South East Asian Nations (ASEAN), read by the representative of Malaysia, Hamidon Ali, demanded the application of the provisions of the WTO agreement, which indicate that the vote is “a right which cannot be blocked by anyone.”

But the Friends of the Chair group, which backs Moore, maintained that the procedures governing the election of the new director-general stipulated the need to reach a final agreement by consensus.

The group stated that “the multilateral trading system is facing its first major institutional crisis since its creation, as a result of the reluctance of a core group of Dr. Supachai supporters to accept the outcome of the agreed process.”

The Friends of the Chair group is comprised of Bolivia, Bulgaria, Costa Rica, France, Nicaragua, Sweden, Turkey, the United States, Uruguay and Venezuela.

The climate of confrontation became even more marked Monday in the WTO, up to now touted as one of the international system’s most granitic institutions.

The crisis has jeopardised the future work of the WTO, according to representatives of member states who preferred to remain anonymous.

On Monday, the organisation was to begin to discuss the preparations for the ministerial conference scheduled for Nov 30 to Dec 3 in the U.S. city of Seattle, Washington to reach a decision on a proposal for a new round of multilateral trade talks.

But the leadership crisis blocked the start of the preparations for Seattle, and held up the work of the Committee on Subsidies and Countervailing Measures and the Committee on Regional Trade Agreements.

Mchumo decided to postpone a General Council meeting slated to begin Monday morning, announcing that he would call a meeting sometime on Tuesday.

Trade negotiators held meetings throughout the day Monday in an attempt to overcome the deadlock.

“We are fighting” and will continue to fight, said Supachai after one of the meetings. He added that he and Moore were “neck to neck, and there is no reason for me” to pull out of the race.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags