Saturday, November 21, 2026
Gustavo Capdevila
- The progess made by states in acknowledging domestic violence against women as an important human rights issue stands in contrast with the lack of strategies for implemention of the commitments assumed, according to the United Nations Special Rapporteur on Violence Against Women.
“Few countries have really gone beyond the policy-making stage” and drawing up “national plans of actions and programmes for raising awareness,” laments a report by Special Rapporteur Radhika Coomaraswamy.
The report admits that regardless of religious or ideological barriers, countries seem to have accepted that violence in the family must be combatted as a violation of the human rights of women.
But states have “overwhelmingly” failed in their international obligations to prevent, investigate and prosecute domestic abuse, it maintains.
Coomaraswamy told the UN Commission on Human Rights in Geneva last week that the rights of women were not yet accorded priority or enforced by national policies.
Women continue to be considered second-class citizens, and treated as such, and their rights are still seen as secondary, said the Special Rapporteur.
Violence against women is considered a “women’s issue,” rather than a serious human rights problem that affects a signficant proportion of the population of all countries, she added.
With rare exceptions, governments continue to consider, to a varying degree, domestic violence as a private family matter.
But in order to gain an understanding of domestic violence, a definition of “family” vis-a-vis international humanitarian law is needed, said Coomaraswamy.
Although the family has been defined as the basic, natural unit of society, there is little orientation regarding the social construction of the family in terms of international law.
Family structures vary throughout the world, ranging from nuclear family groups, through compound, lineal and single-parent families, to families with same-sex parents, she added.
Coomaraswamy insisted that the concept of family be extended to encompass a variety of forms, in order for protection to be provided to all members, regardless of family structure.
She pointed out that the Office of the UN High Commmissioner for Refugees considered lesbians and gays “members of a particular social group” for the purposes of refugee recognition.
The Special Rapporteur said it was “important to understand that feminist critiques of the oppressive and violent aspects of traditional family forms are neither anti-family nor an attempt to destroy the family.”
She also expressed her growing concern over “honour crimes,” in which families kill a female relative deemed to have defiled the honour of the family.
“Reportedly, honour crimes are legal in Lebanon,” said Coomaraswamy, who explained that honour was defined “in terms of women’s assigned sexual and familial roles as dictated by traditional family ideology.”
Violations of family honour can consist of adultery, premarital relationships – which may or may not include sexual relations – rape, and falling in love with an “inappropriate” person.
Frequently, as in cases reported to the Special Rapporteur from Turkey, the male members of the family meet to decide on the execution of the woman, Coomaraswamy told the Commission on Human Rights.
Once the decision has been taken, the family will often give the woman the opportunity to commit suicide. If she refuses to do so, one of the male family members will be forced to kill her. Adolescent boys are often compelled to commit the murder because they will receive a light sentence.
“Honour crimes” are also seen in a number of other countries in the Middle East and South Asia, the Special Rapporteur pointed out.
She cited a particularly “gruesome murder” committed early this month in Pakistan, when a female client of one of the Human Rights Commission’s Special Rapporteurs, attorney Asma Jehangir, was shot in the head in Jehangir’s law offices for daring to seek a divorce from the man who had subjected her to constant battering.
Coomaraswamy asked the Commission to urge the government of Pakistan to seriously address honour killings and support crisis centres and shelters for women victims of honour crimes.
“The government of Pakistan should take all necessary steps to protect the lives of Asma Jehangir and her collegues,” she added. “If they cannot provide such security, the Commission should consider giving her international protection.”
The Special Rapporteur underlined the significance of a case brought before the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights last year. According to the attorneys who filed the case, Pamela Ramjattan, a citizen of Trinidad and Tobago, was repeatedly battered by her husband.
But the domestic violence was not considered by the government of Trinidad and Tobago as mitigating circumstances in her conviction for murder, which led to a death sentence.
Although the Inter-American Commission has not yet reached a conclusion in this case, its appearance before a human rights tribunal underscores the argument that domestic violence against women is an important aspect of international human rights violations, Coomaraswamy stressed.
But she added that “without implementation strategies and proper information gathering, the recognition of violence in the family as an important area of concern and the struggle against domestic violence will be futile.”