Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Headlines, Population

PHILIPPINES: Single Mothers Turn Children Over to Shelters

Marites Sison

MANILA, Apr 15 1999 (IPS) - Elena Garay is unable to see little Amelia each Sunday, but tries to make up for it by showering the toddler with kisses and small gifts every time she does visit the White Cross orphanage in a Manila suburb.

Sunday is her only day off from work as dishwasher-maid at a small eatery, and the 27-year-old mother still has to check on another daughter, two-year-old Andrea, who is in a different children’s shelter.

Elena used to have three daughters. Her eldest, three-year-old Angelica, was among the 25 children who died in a fire at the Fundacion de Damas Filipinas Settlement House in Manila in December. Andrea had been in the same shelter, but escaped unhurt.

Now, at certain hours of the day, Elena calls up the Reception and Child Center (RCC) where Andrea now stays, to make sure it is not ablaze. “They might set that afire, too,” she says. “Then I won’t have any children left.”

Until the Settlement House fire, Filipinos had been largely unaware that at the fringes of society lived single parents who could barely balance work and caring for their children.

While Settlement House was primarily an orphanage, most of the children killed in the blaze had been left there temporarily by single parents.

In recent years, White Cross has also become more of a temporary shelter for children whose parents can no longer take care of them full time.

Most of these parents are single mothers like Elena, who had been abandoned by her common-law husband while she was still pregnant with Amelia.

Just how widespread the phenomenon is of single parents temporarily putting their children in shelters is uncertain, But there is growing evidence of an emerging underclass of single mothers who are marginally employed and struggling to take care of their children while they work.

As a result, officials at both White Cross and the RCC say they are seeing more and more single parents putting their children in their facilities.

The RCC, supposed to take in a maximum of only 120 children at a time, has had to take in as much as 150 to 200. Its latest number of occupants was 220.

Social welfare officials also say that from January to August 1998, 7,135 children were placed in temporary shelters. Most of them were left by single mothers between the ages of 16 and 35. Single fathers accounted for less than one percent of cases.

“The men who leave their children here are often widowers,” says Siony Flores, head social worker at the government-run RCC. “We seldom encounter men who had been left by their wives.”

She adds that majority of the single mothers who place their children in shelters are victims of domestic violence and hard times. Others are unwed mothers, widows, and rape victims with unwanted pregnancies.

“They want to hold on to their children, but they just don’t have the means,” says Remia Capispisan of the Women’s Crisis Centre.

Most of these women are poor, have deficient or no education and little employable skills. Those who do find jobs still are unable to keep their children since they cannot afford childcare.

Vice President Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo has described substitute parenting as a “downside of some aspects of modernisation”.

But while there are laws and measures that help single parents, some social workers say these are too few, underfunded and inadequately implemented that they are useless.

Too often, they also do not recognise that single parenting is a task that has fallen mostly on the women’s shoulders.

After all, it is often the father that walks out on the family, say social workers. When the mother leaves, she almost always takes the children with her, partly due to the traditional thinking that it is a mother’s job to care for the children.

Arroyo, also social welfare secretary, says most of her department’s programmes are “biased toward women”. Yet she agrees that while most low-income women find jobs, salaries are not usually enough to support a family.

A domestic worker, for instance, earns anywhere between 25 to 64 U.S. dollars a month. A minimum of 102 to 168 dollars a month is needed to provide for a child’s food, clothing, medical needs and others, says Constancia Gualberto, who heads the RCC.

“That’s how much we spend per child in the institution,” she says, “and it’s even discounted because we buy everything in bulk – food, clothing, toiletries, vitamins – and it doesn’t include shelter. You can imagine how much it costs to raise a child outside.”

And in these days of shared poverty for many people, there are no more extended families — no village of grandparents, aunts, uncles, cousins to run to when a nuclear family falls apart.

Says Yolanda, 32, who has two daughters in shelters: “My children and I had no home after my husband and I separated, that’s why I brought them (to the shelters). My mother is dead. I can’t rely on my father because he had already neglected us even when I was a child myself.”

Elena tried to keep her family together after her husband walked out. But with no one to mind the children, Elena found it hard to find a job and was soon falling behind the payments on their rented room in a squatters’ area.

Desperate, Elena left her two little girls at the Settlement House. When youngest Amelia was born, Elena took her to live in White Cross.

In the shelters, the children are assured of nutritious meals and ample space to romp around. A housemother looks after them. But no shelter, however perfect, can come close to having loved ones just a touch away.

Social workers say while the toll of separation is heavy on both sides, the child suffers most especially, losing appetite and having poor relations with peers. Most of the already depressed mothers think themselves unworthy of their children.

But it is a situation many have to put up with, sometimes for years. Gualberto says that at the RCC, almost 80 percent of the children left there are taken back within three to 12 months.

Overall figures of the social welfare department, however,are not as reassuring. In 1998, 1,245 children or only 30.5 percent in state shelters were returned to their parents or relatives while 2,387 or 58.5 percent remained there.

Elena Garay says that two years after she first put her daughters in shelters, she is still unsure when they can be together but pledges to get Andrea and Amelia back. “My daughters,” she says, “will grow up in my care.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags