Thursday, November 19, 2026
Analysis - Beena Sarwar
- Political opinion has suprisingly swung round from signing the Comprehensive Test Ban Treaty (CTBT) only if rival India does, to unconditional ratification of the treaty by Pakistan before its end-September deadline.
Cutting across party lines, political leaders expressed support for the CTBT and the hope of peaceful relations with their neighbour India at an unusual public dialogue organised by peace groups here recently.
Irreconcilable rivalry stoked by religious passion made India and Pakistan flex their nuclear muscles in May last year. Enemies for 50 years, they are also fighting each other in the frozen wastes of the Himalayas, the world’s highest battle field.
India was the first to go against world opinion and conduct tests after 23 years. Its then two-month-old right-wing Hindu government left the Nawaz Sharif government in Islamabad with little option but to retaliate and even the score.
Trying to scale down tensions, citizen’s groups in Pakistan, who work closely with their counterparts in India, have been trying to build a dialogue between politicians and the people on the nuclear issue.
At the last meeting in Islamabad on Mar. 9, there was consensus also on India and Pakistan being able to resolve all their major disputes, including Kashmir, a bone of contention as old as the state of Pakistan, through dialogue.
What was left unsaid however was the assumption that the level of deterrence both countries had claimed they were seeking when they tested has been achieved, according to scholar Eqbal Ahmad, who moderated the exchange between political leaders and people.
Neither was there any mention of the escalation of the low- intensity war on the India-Pakistan border, the fall-out of the tit-for-tat nuclear tests by their governments, he said.
Six prominent politicians aired the views of their parties, and fielded questions from over a 100 people at the meeting organised by ‘Mashal’ (flame), a small publishing organisation dedicated to increasing social consciousness.
“This is a debate that should have started 50 years, 20 years ago … If it had, the issues we’re talking about would have been of a different nature and we would have been debating the real issues,” said Naveed Qamar of the main opposition Pakistan People’s Party (PPP).
Discussion moved around the viability of pacts to stop the production of fissile material; how many weapons would “minimum deterrence” mean for Pakistan; and Pakistan’s refusal to sign a no-first-use treaty, proposed by India.
“There should be no unilateral nuclear disarmament on Pakistan’s part,” said former information minister Javed Jabbar, now with the Millat Party of ex-president Farooq Leghari.
Ghinwa Bhutto, the charmingly idealistic widow of Benazir Bhutto’s brother who heads a breakaway faction of the PPP, delivered an unqualified “No to Nukes” message.
Dismissing the CTBT as “a piece of paper” she urged the government to “sign it and get it out of the way”, and pointed out that the country lacked basic facilities like water and health care.
But more startling were the views of former Air Marshal Asghar Khan, chief of the Tehrik-e-Istaklal, who said the nuclear bomb won’t give either country any security. “We cannot use it and India won’t need to”.
On Kashmir, a seemingly unresolvable quarrel with India, he said both countries should forget the 1949 U.N resolution (plebiscite for Kashmir, with the option to accede to either India or Pakistan) as “history” and to find another answer.
“If Pakistan had believed in plebiscite, it would not have annexed Gilgit and Skardu,” the air marshal said.
A nine party Pakistan National Conference of which both Khan and Ghinwa’s parties are members, would like to see both countries keep what they have got, “and let the Valley have its independence.”
Separatist militants in the Kashmir Valley have been waging war with India since 1990. Two years ago, a government loyal to New Delhi was voted to power in Kashmir, which India claims indicates a return to normalcy in the state.
Citizen’s groups in both countries say the people of Kashmir should decide their own future – a view that has found support with some mainstream political parties here.
Qamar of the Pakistan People’s Party, said “it is necessary for both sides to give up their long-held positions and work towards a solution with the concurrence of the Kashmiri people.”
Kashmir continues to be a simmering flash-point of war. Two of the three India-Pakistan wars have been fought for the control of the Muslim majority state, which Pakistan claims.
Ruling party senator, Akram Zaki, a former foreign secretary, said Pakistan’s successful tests achieved “strategic parity” with India, and made India amenable to dialogue with Islamabad.
Pakistan forced the world to sit up and take notice of Kashmir, and “made it necessary for Vajpayee (India’s prime minister) to come here (last month), and to acknowledge that negotiations on Kashmir must take place,” he said.
A powerful former army chief, Gen Mirza Aslam Beg who heads the Awami Qayadat Party, was clear Pakistan’s nuclear programme was “India specific” and tried to argue that “the nuclear option is the cheapest”, which did not go unchallenged.
In a country where political dialogue is rare, this cool- headed discussion between those with conflicting points of view was welcomed.