Economy & Trade, Europe, Headlines

TRADE-BANANAS: US Demands May Lead to ‘Modifications’ to EU Regime

Debra Percival

BRUSSELS, Jul 25 1995 (IPS) - Under pressure from the United States, the European Commission is to draw up a report in September which will consider “modifications” to the European Union’s (EU) two- year-old banana regime.

The announcement was made Tuesday by EU Farm Commissioner Franz Fischler following a visit here by trade ministers of the four Latin American countries who have signed the so-called ‘banana framework agreement’ with the European Union — Colombia, Costa Rica, Nicaragua and Venezuela.

The core of this accord, clinched at the Marrakesh (Morocco) signing of the Uruguay Round of the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT) in April 1994, is country quotas in the EU’s general banana import quota for Latin America.

In exchange, the four agreed to shelve challenges to the regime under World Trade Organisation (WTO) rules. The Geneva-based WTO is the successor to GATT.

The framework pact is now part and parcel of the European Union’s Single Market arrangements which have been up and running since July 1 1993.

The arrangement is designed to protect the high cost production of African and Caribbean nations: St.Lucia, Dominica, Jamaica, Belize, Suriname, Cameroon, Cote d’Ivoire, whose economies are heavily dependent on banana income. They are also benefits for Latin American producers who have reached agreement with the EU.

The African and Caribbean producers are set an annual duty-free quota of 857,700 tonnes whilst participating Latin American nations are allocated a 2.2 million annual quota on which they have to pay tariffs of 75 European Currency Units (ecus) — about 90 dollars — per tonne.

“Our main purpose in Brussels was to confirm to the European Union that the (framework) agreement is very important and is working well and we do not want the system to be changed,” said Costa Rica’s Trade Minister, Jose Rossi, in an interview with IPS.

The EU’s system is presently under attack from the United States which is threatening retaliatory trade sanctions against the European Union under Washington’s 301 trade legislation unless the EU scraps the framework agreement. It is also criticised by Latin American nations who have not signed up to the accord.

Washington’s complaint is that in setting country quotas for the four framework signatories, the agreement penalises U.S.-based banana firms like ‘Chiquita’ who are losing out on licences. The United States has given the EU until Oct. 17 to act.

But Rossi said that the specific country quotas were essential to guarantee the four country’s market share: “The problem is in this regulated market (as is the case with the EU regime), the only basis on which we can compete is price.”

He argued that labour costs in Costa Rica were some 30 per cent higher than for example in Ecuador so that if the EU had opted for an open market system — without tariffs or quotas — Costa Rica could still compete in quality terms with other Latin American nations, but may have otherwise been priced out of the market.

The framework deal allocates 23.4 per cent of the 2.2 million tonnes quota to Costa Rica — 21 per cent to Colombia, three per cent to Nicaragua and two per cent to Venezuela. Other Latin American exporters like Ecuador, Guatemala, Honduras, Panama and Mexico have to compete for the other 50 per cent quota share.

Rossi said that in meeting Fischler Tuesday, the representative delegations from Colombia, Costa Rica, Nicaragua and Venezuela had proposed to the European Commission, several modifications to the system to appease Washington.

“Our position is that the system is kept in place and through improvements, we will try to solve the problem with the United States as well. We have made proposals to the United States government — not in the essence, but in the way the system is run.”

Rossi said the two most important concerns were over how the European Union calculates its quarterly reference quantities to companies, and an increase in the quota to the 2.7 million tonnes.

The Costa Rican trade minister said the United States had threatened to remove trade preferences from Colombia and Venezuela as members of the Andean pact countries and from Costa Rica under the Caribbean Basin Initiative (CBI) if there was no change in the framework agreement by January 1996.

Fischler is also under pressure to bring about changes from Germany — the biggest EU consumer of bananas — and other traditional EU buyers of the Latin American fruit — those being The Netherlands, Luxembourg, Belgium and Denmark.

In a bid to force the EU to up the quota to three million tonnes, Germany successfully blocked an EU proposal at a meeting last week of EU farm ministers, to up the Latin America quota to 353,000 tonnes to supply the three EU newcomers Finland, Sweden and Austria which joined the Union in January this year.

In addition to the U.S. and German attacks, the EU is worried about a “mushroom effect” said EU spokesman, Gerry Kiely.

On this count, the EU would be concerned by a German court decisions earlier this month which ruled in favour of two German importers — ‘Porto’ of Hamburg and ‘Atlanta’ of Frankfurt — who sought redress from the German Customs Office for loss of earnings due to insufficient banana licences under the EU regime.

The German city courts awarded the companies the right to import an additional 10,000 tonnes between them. The rulings could be overturned by the Luxembourg-based European Court of Justice where both companies have filed complaints, but this outcome could take many months. In the meantime, the EU is worried that other German companies will follow suit to upset the EU quota system.

Also unhappy are Sweden, Finland and Austria, who say they are losing out on licences since they are not primary banana importers. The EU system is so styled that primary importers of bananas are awarded the biggest number of licences.

“During the summer months we can assess these new aspects and report to the Commission on the matter,” Fischler said at a press conference on Tuesday.

But Fischler gave his guarantee that the framework accord will not be up for review: “The framework agreement which is part of the GATT agreement will not be called into question.”

But some EU officials warned that the Commission ups the quota beyond what is expected by the widened EU membership, it will face a barrage of complaints from Caribbean and African nations, as well as from the EU’s own banana producers in Spain (Canaries), Portugal (Azores) and the French Overseas Departments (Guadeloupe and Martinique).

All these have consistently maintained that any slight increase of the quota to Latin American nations will adversely affect their revenues, and in the cases of the developing country producers, their economic stability.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags