Saturday, November 21, 2026
Alejandro Kirk
- The abduction of Kurdish leader Abdullah Ocalan by Turkish agents in Kenya sparked a new controversy over Europe’s political autonomy.
Political and human rights exponents reacted with astonishment Thursday to the televised images of a blindfolded, handcuffed and apparently drugged Ocalan on the plane taking him to Turkey, and to the death of three Kurds outside the Israeli consulate in Berlin.
The episode is “a defeat for Europe,” said Walter Veltroni, secretary-general of the Leftist Democratic party which heads Italy’s governing coalition.
“The European parliament and governments had pledged their efforts to convoke an international conference on a solution to the Kurdish problem in Turkey. Nothing has happened yet,” states a document signed by a group of intellectuals.
Among the signatories figured Nobel Literature laureate Dario Fo, Danielle Mitterrand – the widow of former French president Francois Mitterrand – writer Antonio Tabucchi and film director Ettore Scola.
“The repression, the destruction of villages, the torture, the murders perpetrated by the Turkish army and police, the millions of Kurds forced to flee and become fugitives have been amply documented and denounced by all of the international bodies and the European Parliament’s investigatory commissions,” states the document.
But “the Turkish government responds with bombings and repression” to such denunciations, it adds, while pointing out that Turkey is a candidate for admission to the European Union (EU).
According to international commentator Romasso di Francesco, the EU remains a prisoner to the geostrategic objectives of the United States, which sees Turkey as the North Atlantic Treaty Organisation’s (NATO) “gendarme” in southeastern Europe.
The EU should immediately call an international conference on the Kurdish problem, similar to that being held on the crisis of the Albanian minority in Yugoslavia, as a condition for Turkey’s eventual admission, said Di Francesco.
“The United States which applauds the arrest of ‘Ocalan the terrorist’ is the same United States that has chosen the ‘terrorists’ of the Kosovo Libration Army as key interlocutors in Rambuoillet,” he added.
Under the threat of bombing, NATO forced the Yugoslavian government and Albanian separatists of the province of Kosovo to start peace talks last week on autonomy for the region, in the town of Rambouillet near Paris.
The expulsion from Turkey Wednesday of a team of Dutch and German lawyers defending Ocalan and Ankara’s announcement that no international observers would attend the trial confirmed, in the eyes of human rights groups, the absence of democratic legal guarantees in that country.
Observers stressed that Ocalan would undoubtedly receive a stiff sentence without any need for illegal manuevring, because the Turkish penal code classifies demands for autonomy for the 15 million Kurds as acts of “banditry” and “treason.”
It is precisely the Turkish regime’s refusal to take the Kurdish problem into consideration that has generated the violence, said former Italian senator Pietro Ingrao.
“Ocalan has killed? But tell me, what could his people do if they do not have the right even to call themselves a nation, nor to recognise themselves as a territory or create their own laws, while split into pieces, each subjected to foreign control, according to a division decided on or backed by the civil West?” said Ingrao.
Ingrao, an anti-Nazi resistance fighter in World War II, pointed out that “we Italian patriots also killed when we were under the German boot.”
According to Ingrao, one of the reasons why Europe – “even social democratic Europe” – abandoned Ocalan to his fate was because he carried the “leprosy” of being communist.
Italy is in a special situation with respect to the Ocalan case, because the Kurdish leader sought asylum here last November, in the wake of his expulsion from Syria, and after a similar request was turned down by Russia.
After Ocalan’s arrival to Italy, the centre-left government of Prime Minister Massimo D’Alema attempted to set up an international tribunal to try the fugitive leader, with the aim of debating the crux of the Kurdish problem there.
Italy’s initiative met with a cool reaction from the rest of the EU members, and outright rejection from the United States, which pressed for Ocalan to be handed over to Turkish authorities.
Rome rejected the extradition requests issued by Ankara, because the Italian constitution prohibits prisoners from being handed over to countries where – like in Turkey – the death penalty is applied.
The asylum request – to be resolved on Feb 24 – is based on an article of the Italian constitution that grants the right to live in Italy to any person whose “effective exercise of the democratic freedom guaranteed by the Italian constitution” is impeded in his or her country.
Meanwhile, those opposed to the petition for asylum say Ocalan has been accused not only by the Turkish regime, but of acts of violence committed by the Kurdistan Workers Party (PKK) in Germany.
After the failure of Rome’s efforts, Ocalan agreed to leave Italy on Jan 16, setting out on a desperate flight in which he was pursued by Turkish intelligence services, reportedly with U.S. and Israeli support.
Ocalan once more sought refuge in Greece, Italy, Russia and the Netherlands. But he met with systematic refusal, until his kidnapping Monday in an obscure episode in the Greek Embassy in Kenya, where he was in hiding.
Israel, Greece, the United States and Kenya have denied any role in the abduction. But they have failed to convince PKK sympathisers in Europe, who occupied several Greek diplomatic offices and tried – at the price of a massacre – to occupy the Israeli consulate in Berlin.