Monday, November 16, 2026
Analysis - Amir Mir
- Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif’s resolute efforts to hammer home the supremacy of the executive in Pakistan has put the government on an inevitable collision course with the judiciary.
The setting up of special military courts last December to tackle ‘terrorism” in Karachi bypassing the existing legal system has triggered a renewal of activism in the Supreme Court.
On Jan. 10, much to the annoyance of the government, the Supreme Court stayed the delivery of death sentences awarded by the military courts until the validity of the courts is decided.
The government through its attorney general has asked the courts to reconsider the decision, but political observers say the judiciary will not back out as it is fighting to protect its turf.
“It is not possible … for the judiciary to compromise on its role,” observes Akram Sheikh, ex-president of the Supreme Court Bar Association. “It is up to the government to take an administrative decision and it is up to the judiciary to examine it,” he explains.
Avers Asma Jahangir, prominent human rights lawyer: “No law in the country sanctions military courts as a parallel judicial hierarchy, operating outside the Constitution, exempt from control and scrutiny by the superior courts.”
Armed with a two-thirds majority in the National Assembly, Sharif has so far been successful in silencing opponents – forcing the untimely exit of both a president (Farooq Leghari) and chief justice (Sajjad Shah) in December 1977. Last October he forced a defiant army chief (Gen Jahangir Karamat) to step down.
Then the prime minister suspended the provincial assembly of Sindh in November 1998 after his Muslim League party was reduced to a minority and established military courts in the provincial capital to hand out speedy justice in Pakistan’s largest city.
But the decision to give the military sweeping powers to arrest, investigate and try civilians, was soon challenged by the Muslim League’s erstwhile ally the Mohajir National Movement party, better known by its initials MQM, which is blamed for much of the violence in Karachi.
“The Constitution only empowers the government of the day to call the armed forces in aid of civil power instead of acting in displacement of the civil powers,” the MQM petitioned the Supreme Court after a party activist Ashraf Chakar was arrested by a military court on murder charges and executed within days.
Now the apex court has fixed Feb. 1 for the hearing of the five constitutional petitions challenging the establishment of military courts. Notices have been issued to the Sharif government and the attorney general.
Opposition leader Benazir Bhutto has also written to Pakistan’s President Rafique Tarrar, urging him “to refrain from sending to the gallows other people already sentenced by military courts until the Supreme Court has ruled upon their validity.”
The government has, however, refused to bow to the Supreme Court and asked the court to lift its interim order because it interferes with efforts to restore law and order in Karachi.
“The grave aspect of national security, threat and danger to the integrity of Pakistan can only be averted if the process is allowed to complete its full stride. An interruption in this process may lead to a resurgence of violence in Karachi,” states an application filed by the attorney general.
Political observers view this month’s events as a prelude to a head on collision between the executive and the judiciary which has been coming ever since the unceremonious exit of chief justice Shah who was voted out by fellow judges.
According to a law minister in the former opposition Pakistan People’s Party government, Iqbal Hayder, “The unceremonious exit of the chief justice by none other than his fellow judges had adversely damaged the court’s credibility … The current activity of the SC judges might be an attempt to restore its lost credibility.”
Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif has time and again blamed the judiciary for the delay in justice delivery in cases related to sectarian violence which he also cited as a reason for the creation of military courts in Karachi.
In a recent letter to the attorney general, he not only pledged to crush “terrorism” but also complained that although thousands of innocent people have been killed, especially in Sindh, the “terrorists” are not being convicted by the courts.
Sharif’s law minister, Khalid Anwer, was equally scathing about the civilian justice system. “The performance of the judiciary can be judged from the fact that there had not been a single conviction in Karachi against the terrorists for the past three years.”
Military courts have been authorised to give a final judgement after a three-day trial, which I.A. Rehman, the director of the independent Human Rights Commission of Pakistan says is “particularly dangerous” as it leaves no room to rectify a miscarriage of justice.
The battle lines are drawn for a final showdown between a resolute executive and a judiciary which is hitting back with equal vigour.