Sunday, November 22, 2026
Thalif Deen
- Secretary General Kofi Annan has expressed strong reservations about the effectiveness of existing UN sanctions which are designed primarily to punish political leaders for their erratic behaviour or for defying the international community.
“Just as we recognise the importance of sanctions as a way of compelling compliance with the will of the international community,” he said Monday, “we also recognise that sanctions remain a blunt instrument.”
Addressing a seminar on the subject “Toward Smarter, More Effective UN sanctions”, Annan said that most UN sanctions have hurt large numbers of people who are not their primary targets.
“Sanctions need refining if they are to be seen as more than a fig leaf in the future,” he added.
In its 54-year history, the United Nations has imposed sanctions on 13 member states: Afghanistan, Angola, Federal Republic of Yugoslavia, Haiti, Iraq, Liberia, Libya, Rwanda, Sierra Leone, Somalia, South Africa (during the apartheid regime), Southern Rhodesia, Sudan and the former Yugoslavia (a second time after its break up).
Of these, sanctions have been fully lifted only in the case of Haiti, South Africa, Southern Rhodesia and the former Yugoslavia.
Annan pointed out that although sanctions are aimed at political leaders in power, most of them not only transfer the cost to the less privileged, but also “perversely often benefit” from such sanctions by their ability to control and profit from black market activity.
Such activity, he said, arises from controlling the distribution of the limited resources, and by exploiting them as a pretext for eliminating domestic sources of political opposition.
In some cases, said Annan, the existence of sanctions has transformed a society for the worse as sanctions-evaders, smugglers and the like rise to the top of the socio-economic ladder because of their skill at manipulating the situation to their advantage. The range of UN sanctions have traditionally included arms embargoes, the imposition of trade and financial restrictions, interruption of relations by air and sea, and diplomatic isolation.
The primary objective is to change in specific ways the behaviour of a government or a regime which posed a threat to international peace and security. And, in a conflict situation, sanctions were aimed at diminishing the capacity of the protagonists to sustain a prolonged war.
Last month Annan singled out Haiti as an example of a country where UN sanctions were more specific and targeted at individuals.
“The leaders were not allowed to travel, they were not given visas to move around, their bank accounts were frozen, and the individual families were not allowed to travel,” he added.
The sanctions in Haiti were focused on those whose behaviour one is trying to change, and did not have the kind of impact on the local population, as in the case of Iraq, he added.
The sanctions imposed on Iraq, following the Gulf crisis in August 1990, have caused considerable hardship to millions of innocent people, and also resulted in the deaths of hundreds and thousands of children due to ill health and malnutrition.
This, in turn, has been caused by a shortage of medicine, food and relief supplies, triggered by the UN embargo.
As a result, Annan has made a strong case for what he calls “targeted sanctions” or “smart sanctions” which will be aimed at the political leadership of a country, not its people.
Addressing a meeting of the Security Council Monday, US Ambassador James Cunningham said that any overly precise “one size fits all” sanctions structure is destined to fail and will waste valuable resources.
“To be effectively targeted, sanctions regimes must be carefully tailored to the particular situation in which they are to be applied. Experience shows that there is no single template that will fit all, or even most, such situations,” he added.
Canadian Foreign Minister Lloyd Axworthy said that Monday’s Security Council meeting was a clear recognition of the need to address “a fundamental challenge: maximising the effectiveness of sanctions while minimising the harm to civilians.”
A 274-page book titled “The Sanctions Decade,” published by the New York-based International Peace Academy and released Monday, calls for a new UN policy on sanctions. The book, whose publication was sponsored by Canada, presents several case studies of how sanctions have failed to have their desired effect.
“Sanctions too often suffer from poor design, loose commitment from member states, inadequate monitoring, and lax enforcement,” it says.
The present limitations of sanctions, the book argues, stem in part from the shortcomings of the UN system. “They also result from the lack of sanctions enforcement capability in many member states.”
Following a report on sanctions-busting in Angola, the UN Security Council is exploring ways of tightening existing UN embargoes and cracking down on violators.
Besides Angola, the Security Council has not made any exhaustive studies on sanctions-busting or even closely monitored the effectiveness of UN embargoes. Although there is reason to believe that most of the embargoes are being violated, the Security Council or its Sanctions Committees have not pursued the matter except in the case of Angola.
This is due either to the lack of staff, absence of permanent monitoring facilities or shortage of funds.
Ambassador Robert Fowler of Canada, chairman of the Sanctions Committee, said last month that sanctions in Angola have been “grievously flouted” for nearly seven years, primarily by the rebel group, Union for the Total Independence of Angola (UNITA). “Every member of this organisation (the UN) knows these sanctions have been violated,” he said.
In mid-March, the Security Council held a one-day meeting to discuss a report by the Sanctions Committee which accused three heads of state — from Togo, Burkina Faso and the former Zaire — of accepting diamonds in return for safe passage for military and petroleum supplies to UNITA in violation of UN sanctions.
This was the first time the United Nations has made an attempt to probe sanctions violations in a comprehensive manner. It is also the first time that a UN report named three heads of state, including two living presidents, of wrong-doing.
The three, including the late Mobutu Sese Seko of the former Zaire (now the Democratic Republic of Congo), President Gnnasingbe Eyadema of Togo and President Blaise Compaore of Burkina Faso, were accused of accepting diamonds as gifts in return for facilitating military and fuel supplies to UNITA rebels.